1. Correlation of manual semi-quantitative and automated quantitative Ki-67 proliferative index with OncotypeDXTM recurrence score in invasive breast carcinoma
- Author
-
Carissa Laboy, Luis Z. Blanco, Rachel Brancamp, Brian S. Finkelman, Kalliopi P. Siziopikou, Amanda Meindl, Brannan B. Griffin, Jennifer L. Pincus, and Suguna P. Narayan
- Subjects
Oncology ,Cancer Research ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Proliferative index ,Concordance ,medicine.medical_treatment ,Breast Neoplasms ,Breast cancer chemotherapy ,Breast cancer ,Internal medicine ,Image Processing, Computer-Assisted ,medicine ,Humans ,Breast ,Automation, Laboratory ,biology ,business.industry ,Carcinoma, Ductal, Breast ,Cancer ,General Medicine ,Middle Aged ,Prognosis ,medicine.disease ,Immunohistochemistry ,Ki-67 Antigen ,Ki-67 ,biology.protein ,Female ,Breast carcinoma ,business ,Kappa - Abstract
BACKGROUND: Ki-67 immunohistochemistry (IHC) staining is a widely used cancer proliferation assay; however, its limitations could be improved with automated scoring. The OncotypeDXTM Recurrence Score (ORS), which primarily evaluates cancer proliferation genes, is a prognostic indicator for breast cancer chemotherapy response; however, it is more expensive and slower than Ki-67. OBJECTIVE: To compare manual Ki-67 (mKi-67) with automated Ki-67 (aKi-67) algorithm results based on manually selected Ki-67 “hot spots” in breast cancer, and correlate both with ORS. METHODS: 105 invasive breast carcinoma cases from 100 patients at our institution (2011–2013) with available ORS were evaluated. Concordance was assessed via Cohen’s Kappa (κ). RESULTS: 57/105 cases showed agreement between mKi-67 and aKi-67 (κ 0.31, 95% CI 0.18–0.45), with 41 cases overestimated by aKi-67. Concordance was higher when estimated on the same image (κ 0.53, 95% CI 0.37–0.69). Concordance between mKi-67 score and ORS was fair (κ 0.27, 95% CI 0.11–0.42), and concordance between aKi-67 and ORS was poor (κ 0.10, 95% CI −0.03–0.23). CONCLUSIONS: These results highlight the limits of Ki-67 algorithms that use manual “hot spot” selection. Due to suboptimal concordance, Ki-67 is likely most useful as a complement to, rather than a surrogate for ORS, regardless of scoring method.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF