1. Mistaken Identity: Frequency and Effects of Gender-Based Professional Misidentification of Resident Physicians
- Author
-
Shana Berwick, Hila Calev, Margaret M. Hayes, C. Christopher Smith, Brian R Poole, Andrew Matthews, Amrita Mukhopadhyay, and Jordan Talan
- Subjects
Adult ,Male ,medicine.medical_specialty ,020205 medical informatics ,Cross-sectional study ,Sexism ,MEDLINE ,Identity (social science) ,Survey result ,02 engineering and technology ,Education ,Physicians, Women ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Surveys and Questionnaires ,Internal Medicine ,0202 electrical engineering, electronic engineering, information engineering ,medicine ,Humans ,030212 general & internal medicine ,Academic Medical Centers ,business.industry ,Internship and Residency ,Survey tool ,Survey research ,General Medicine ,Test (assessment) ,Cross-Sectional Studies ,General Surgery ,Family medicine ,Medical profession ,Emergency Medicine ,Female ,business - Abstract
Purpose Evaluation of the medical profession at all levels has exposed episodes of gender-based role misidentification whereby women physicians are disproportionately misidentified as nonphysicians. The authors of this study investigate this phenomenon and its repercussions, quantifying the frequency with which resident physicians experience role misidentification and the effect this has on their experience and behavior. Method In 2018, the authors conducted a cross-sectional survey study of internal medicine, surgical, and emergency medicine residents at a single, large, urban, tertiary academic medical center. The survey tool captured both the self-reported frequency and effect of professional misidentification. The authors used a t test and linear multivariate regression to analyze the results. Results Of the 260 residents who received the survey, 186 (72%) responded, and the authors analyzed the responses of 182. All 85 of the women respondents (100%) reported being misidentified as nonphysicians at least once in their professional experience by patients or staff members, compared with 49% of the 97 men respondents. Of those 182 residents, 35% of women were misidentified more than 8 times per month by patients compared with 1% of men. Of the 85 women physicians responding to the survey, 38% felt angry and 36% felt less satisfied with their jobs as a result of misidentification compared with, respectively, 7% and 9% of men. In response to role misidentification, 51% of women changed their manner of attire and 81% changed their manner of introduction, compared with, respectively, 7% and 37% of men. Conclusions These survey results demonstrate that women physicians are more likely than men physicians to be misidentified as nonphysicians and that role misidentification provokes gender-polarized psychological and behavioral responses that have potentially important professional ramifications.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF