Search

Black women have a lower incidence of vertebral and hip fractures than white women, possibly due to differences in skeletal and mineral metabolism. One suggested mechanism is that blacks have decreased skeletal sensitivity to parathyroid hormone (PTH). To test this hypothesis, we infused h(1-34)PTH in healthy premenopausal black (n = 15) and white (n = 18) women over 24 h and measured serum and urine indices of bone turnover and calcium metabolism throughout the infusion. At baseline, the mean 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25(OH)D) concentration was significantly lower in black women (46%). There were also nearly significant trends toward higher PTH and lower urinary calcium and pyridinoline levels in black women. During infusion, there were no racial differences in the mean (1-34)PTH levels achieved or in resultant elevations of serum calcium or 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D (1,25(OH)2D) levels. Endogenous parathyroid suppression (measured by (1-84)PTH levels) was also similar between blacks and whites. There was an initial decline in urinary calcium/creatinine in both groups with a greater reduction in black women early in the infusion period (p < 0.05 at 8 h). Furthermore, blacks had lower levels of urinary calcium/creatinine throughout the infusion (p < 0.05 group difference). Bone formation markers (carboxy-terminal propeptide of type I procollagen and osteocalcin) decreased within 8 h and continued to decline throughout the infusion with no distinguishable racial differences (p < 0.05 time trend for both). The most dramatic difference between black and white women in response to PTH infusion was represented by the bone resorption markers. Three separate metabolites of bone resorption (cross-linked N-telopeptide of type I collagen, cross-linked C-telopeptide of type I collagen, and free pyridinoline) all showed substantially greater elevations in white (mean peak increments 399, 725, and 43%) compared with black women (mean peak increments 317, 369, and 17%) during the infusion (p < 0.05 group differences for all three variables). These data strongly suggest that blacks have decreased skeletal sensitivity to the acute resorptive effects of increased PTH. This finding indicates that calcium homeostasis may be accomplished in blacks (during times of relative calcium deficiency) by greater conservation of calcium from nonskeletal sources (most likely renal) with relative preservation of skeletal tissue. These differences in calcium economy could account, at least in part, for the increased bone mass and lower incidence of osteoporotic fractures in black women.

Although bone loss occurs universally with age, the incidence of age-related osteoporotic fractures varies widely among ethnic groups. In the U.S., age-adjusted hip fracture incidence is 50% lower in African-American than in white women. Adult African-American women also have higher bone mass, but it is not known whether this difference is entirely due to higher peak bone mass or also results from slower rates of bone loss. Rates of bone loss were measured prospectively in 122 white and 121 African-American healthy, nonobese, pre- and postmenopausal women. Bone density was measured at 6-month intervals over a mean of 3-4 yr using single and dual photon absorptiometry of the forearm (cortical bone) and spine (trabecular bone). Similar rates of premenopausal bone loss were documented in both white and African-American women. However, in early menopause, bone loss was faster in the white women in the forearm (-2.4%/yr in whites vs. -1.2%/yr in African-Americans; P = 0.045), with a similar trend in the spine (-2.2%/yr in whites vs. -1.3/yr in African-Americans; P = 0.27). In women more than 5 yr postmenopause, the rates of bone loss did not differ by ethnic group. Our results indicate that the higher bone mass in African-American women is largely due to the attainment of a greater peak bone mass by early adulthood. However, slower rates of bone loss in the early postmenopausal period may also contribute to the higher bone density of older African-American women. Although bone loss occurs in both groups, there are ethnic differences in bone loss rates which indicate that data derived from white women cannot be simply extrapolated to nonwhite populations. Ethnic group-specific data on the determinants of bone homeostasis are needed.

The disparity in fracture incidence and bone mass in women of European (white) and African (black) ancestry is of unknown etiology. To determine if racial differences in bone mass reflected racial differences in the mechanisms of bone turnover underlying bone mineral loss, we measured serum osteocalcin, serum alkaline phosphatase, fasting urinary calcium and hydroxyproline excretion, 24 h urinary excretion of calcium and sodium, and dietary intakes of calcium and vitamin D in 263 healthy pre-, peri-, and postmenopausal white and black women. In addition, radial and spinal bone density were measured cross-sectionally for comparison with biochemical measures of bone turnover. The biochemical parameters thought to reflect bone resorption (fasting urinary calcium and hydroxyproline excretions) were lower in black than in white women throughout the age and menopausal stages studied. The parameters thought to reflect bone formation (alkaline phosphatase and osteocalcin), were similar in the two racial groups among the premenopausal women, but osteocalcin was significantly lower among the peri- and postmenopausal blacks. Cross sectionally measured radial bone density increased with age in premenopausal black women, but it did not change with age in the white premenopausal subjects, a statistically significant difference. In peri- and postmenopausal women radial density declined significantly with years after menopause in both racial groups, but the rate of decline was significantly slower in the black women. Lumbar bone density in premenopausal white and black women did not change with age. After menopause lumbar bone density declined significantly and similarly in both racial groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The etiology of the racial disparity in bone mass and fracture rate is unknown. Since the PTH-vitamin D endocrine system is a major regulator of calcium metabolism and bone turnover, this cross-sectional study examined the relationship of radial and lumbar bone density to vitamin D metabolite and PTH concentrations and to calcium intake and excretion in 67 white and 70 black highly comparable, healthy, premenopausal women. Bone density at both radial and lumbar sites was higher in blacks than in whites. Serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D was slightly but not statistically significantly (P = 0.08), lower in blacks than in whites, but there were no racial differences in 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D, PTH, or renal tubular maximum for reabsorption of phosphate. The mean 25-hydroxyvitamin D concentration in blacks was well within the normal range and was not associated with evidence of secondary hyperparathyroidism. There were no correlations of bone density to vitamin D or PTH concentrations. Although there were no racial differences in dietary intake of calcium and vitamin D or in sodium excretion, 24-h urinary calcium excretion was significantly lower in blacks than in whites, and calcium excretion was inversely associated with radial bone density. In contrast to previous reports, in healthy, normal weight, premenopausal black women there is no evidence of vitamin D deficiency or secondary hyperparathyroidism, suggesting that factors other than the vitamin D-PTH axis are responsible for racial differences in bone mass.

The reasons for a different incidence of osteoporotic fractures in white and black women are unknown. Previous racial comparisons of bone mass have been limited by racial differences in body weight and socioeconomic, health, and nutritional status. This cross-sectional study examined bone density in 105 black and 114 white healthy nonobese women, 24-65 yr old, using dual photon absorptiometry of the lumbar spine and single photon absorptiometry of the distal radius. Bone density at both sites was higher in blacks at all ages than in whites. When adjusted for age and body mass index, mean bone density was 6.5% higher in blacks at both spine and radius (P less than 0.0001). The cross-sectional rate of decline of vertebral bone density was similar between races; however, radial density increased 3.8%/decade (P = 0.03) in premenopausal blacks under age 46 yr, while it declined 3.2%/decade (P = 0.09) in premenopausal whites. The racial difference in slopes in these premenopausal women is significant (P = 0.002). These findings suggest that attainment of higher peak bone mass and delayed onset of bone loss contribute to the lower incidence of osteoporotic fractures in black women.