Search

Epigenetic approaches using the histone deacetylase 2 and 3 inhibitor-MI192 have been reported to accelerate stem cells to form mineralised tissues. Gelatine methacryloyl (GelMA) hydrogels provide a favourable microenvironment to facilitate cell delivery and support tissue formation. However, their application for bone repair is limited due to their low mechanical strength. This study aimed to investigate a GelMA hydrogel reinforced with a 3D printed scaffold to support MI192-induced human bone marrow stromal cells (hBMSCs) for bone formation. Cell culture: The GelMA (5 wt%) hydrogel supported the proliferation of MI192-pre-treated hBMSCs. MI192-pre-treated hBMSCs within the GelMA in osteogenic culture significantly increased alkaline phosphatase activity (p ≤ 0.001) compared to control. Histology: The MI192-pre-treated group enhanced osteoblast-related extracellular matrix deposition and mineralisation (p ≤ 0.001) compared to control. Mechanical testing: GelMA hydrogels reinforced with 3D printed poly(ethylene glycol)-terephthalate/poly(butylene terephthalate) (PEGT/PBT) scaffolds exhibited a 1000-fold increase in the compressive modulus compared to the GelMA alone. MI192-pre-treated hBMSCs within the GelMA–PEGT/PBT constructs significantly enhanced extracellular matrix collagen production and mineralisation compared to control (p ≤ 0.001). These findings demonstrate that the GelMA–PEGT/PBT construct provides enhanced mechanical strength and facilitates the delivery of epigenetically-activated MSCs for bone augmentation strategies.

The integration of light-driven technologies into biofabrication has revolutionized the field of tissue engineering and regenerative medicine, with numerous breakthroughs in the last few years. Light-based bioprinting approaches (lithography, multiphoton and volumetric bioprinting) have shown the potential to fabricate large scale tissue engineering constructs of high resolution, with great flexibility and control over the cellular organization. Given the unprecedented degree of freedom in fabricating convoluted structures, key challenges in regenerative medicine, such as introducing complex channels and pre-vascular networks in 3D constructs have also been addressed. Light has also been proven as a powerful tool, leading to novel photo-chemistry in designing bioinks, but also able to impart spatial-temporal control over cellular functions through photo-responsive chemistry. For instance, smart constructs able to undergo remotely controlled shape changes, stiffening, softening and degradation can be produced. The non-invasive nature of light stimulation also enables to trigger such responses post-fabrication, during the maturation phase of a construct. Such unique ability can be used to mimic the dynamic processes occurring in tissue regeneration, as well as in disease progression and degenerative processes in vivo. Bringing together these novel multidisciplinary expertise, the present Special Issue aims to discuss the most recent trends, strategies and novel light-based technologies in the field of biofabrication. These include: 1) using light-based bioprinting to develop in vitro models for drug screening, developmental biology models, disease models, and also functional tissues for implantation; 2) novel light-based biofabrication technologies; 3) development of new photo-responsive bioinks or biomaterial inks.

Bone regeneration of critical-sized bone defects, bone fractures or joint replacements remains a significant clinical challenge. Although there has been rapid advancement in both the fields of bone tissue engineering and additive manufacturing, functional bone implants with rapid vascularization capacity to ensure osseointegration and long-term biological fixation in large bone defects remains limited in clinics. In this study, we developed an in vitro vascularized bone implant by combining cell-laden hydrogels with direct metal printed (DMP) porous titanium alloys (Ti–6Al–4V). A 5 wt% allylated gelatin (GelAGE), was utilized to co-encapsulate human mesenchymal stromal cells (hMSCs) and human umbilical vein endothelial cells (HUVECs) to investigate concurrent osteogenic and vasculogenic performance. DMP macro-porous Ti–6Al–4V scaffolds were subsequently infused/enriched with cell-laden GelAGE to examine the feasibility to deliver cells and engineer vascular-like networks in the hybrid implant. Furthermore, as a proof of concept, a full-scale porous Ti–6Al–4V acetabular cup was impregnated with cell-laden hydrogel to validate the clinical potential of this strategy. The vasculogenic potential was evaluated by examining micro-capillary formation coupled with capillary network maturation and stabilization. Osteogenic differentiation was assessed via alkaline phosphatase activity as well as osteocalcin and osteopontin expression. Our results suggested that GelAGE supported HUVECs spreading and vascular-like network formation, along with osteogenesis of hMSCs. Titanium hybrid constructs with cell-laden hydrogel demonstrated enhanced osteogenesis with similar vasculogenic capability compared to the cell-laden hydrogel alone constructs. The full-scale implant with cell-laden hydrogel coating similarly showed cell distribution and spreading, implying the potential for further clinical application. Our study presents the feasibility of integrating bio-functional hydrogels with porous titanium implants to fabricate a vascularized hybrid construct with both mechanical support and preferable biological functionality (osteogenesis/vasculogenesis), which paves the way for improved strategies to enhance bone regeneration in complex large bone defects achieving long-term bone-implant fixation.

Recently developed modular bioassembly techniques hold tremendous potential in tissue engineering and regenerative medicine, due to their ability to recreate the complex microarchitecture of native tissue. Here, we developed a novel approach to fabricate hybrid tissue-engineered constructs adopting high-throughput microfluidic and 3D bioassembly strategies. Osteochondral tissue fabrication was adopted as an example in this study, because of the challenges in fabricating load bearing osteochondral tissue constructs with phenotypically distinct zonal architecture. By developing cell-instructive chondrogenic and osteogenic bioink microsphere modules in high-throughput, together with precise manipulation of the 3D bioassembly process, we successfully fabricated hybrid engineered osteochondral tissue in vitro with integrated but distinct cartilage and bone layers. Furthermore, by encapsulating allogeneic umbilical cord blood-derived mesenchymal stromal cells, and demonstrating chondrogenic and osteogenic differentiation, the hybrid biofabrication of hydrogel microspheres in this 3D bioassembly model offers potential for an off-the-shelf, single-surgery strategy for osteochondral tissue repair.

As emerging therapeutic factors, extracellular vesicles (EVs) offer significant potential for myocardial infarction (MI) treatment. Current delivery approaches for EVs involve either intra-myocardial or intravenous injection, where both have inherent limitations for downstream clinical applications such as secondary tissue injury and low delivery efficiency. Herein, an injection-free approach for delivering EVs onto the heart surface to treat MI is proposed. By spraying a mixture of EVs, gelatin methacryloyl (GelMA) precursors, and photoinitiators followed by visible light irradiation for 30 s, EVs are physically entrapped within the GelMA hydrogel network covering the surface of the heart, resulting in an enhanced retention rate. Moreover, EVs are gradually released from the hydrogel network through a combination of diffusion and/or enzymatic degradation of the hydrogel, and they are effectively taken up by the sprayed tissue area. More importantly, the released EVs further migrate deep into myocardium tissue, which exerts an improved therapeutic effect. In an MI-induced mice model, the group treated with EVs-laden GelMA hydrogels shows significant recovery in cardiac function after 4 weeks. The work demonstrates a new strategy for delivering EVs into cardiac tissues for MI treatment in a localized manner with high retention.

The rise of antibiotic resistance, coupled with increased expectations for mobility in later life, is creating a need for biofilm inhibitors and delivery systems that will reduce surgical implant infection. A limitation of some of these existing delivery approaches is toxicity exhibited toward host cells. Here, we report the application of a novel inhibitor of the enzyme, methylthioadenosine nucleosidase (MTAN), a key enzyme in bacterial metabolic pathways, which include S-adenosylmethionine catabolism and purine nucleotide recycling, in combination with a poly(vinyl alcohol)-tyramine-based (PVA-Tyr) hydrogel delivery system. We demonstrate that a lead MTAN inhibitor, selected from a screened library of 34 candidates, (2S)-2-(4-amino-5H-pyrrolo3,2-dpyrimidin-7-ylmethyl)aminoundecan-1-ol (31), showed a minimum biofilm inhibitory concentration of 2.2 ± 0.4 μM against a clinical staphylococcal species isolated from an infected implant. We observed that extracellular DNA, a key constituent of biofilms, is significantly reduced when treated with 10 μM compound 31, along with a decrease in biofilm thickness. Compound 31 was incorporated into a hydrolytically degradable photo-cross-linked PVA-Tyr hydrogel and the release profile was evaluated by HPLC studies. Compound 31 released from the PVA-hydrogel system significantly reduced biofilm formation (77.2 ± 8.4% biofilm inhibition). Finally, compound 31 released from PVA-Tyr showed no negative impact on human bone marrow stromal cell (MSC) viability, proliferation, or morphology. The results demonstrate the potential utility of MTAN inhibitors in treating infections caused by Gram-positive bacteria, and the development of a nontoxic release system that has potential for tunability for time scale of delivery.

The principle challenge for engineering viable, cell-laden hydrogel constructs of clinically-relevant size, is rapid vascularization, in order to moderate the finite capacity of passive nutrient diffusion. A multiscale vascular approach, with large open channels and bulk microcapillaries may be an admissible approach to accelerate this process, promoting overall pre-vascularization for long-term viability of constructs. However, the limited availability of bioinks that possess suitable characteristics that support both fabrication of complex architectures and formation of microcapillaries, remains a barrier to advancement in this space. In this study, gelatin-norbornene (Gel-NOR) is investigated as a vascular bioink with tailorable physico-mechanical properties, which promoted the self-assembly of human stromal and endothelial cells into microcapillaries, as well as being compatible with extrusion and lithography-based biofabrication modalities. Gel-NOR constructs containing self-assembled microcapillaries are successfully biofabricated with varying physical architecture (fiber diameter, spacing, and orientation). Both channel sizes and cell types affect the overall structural changes of the printed constructs, where cross-signaling between both human stromal and endothelial cells may be responsible for the reduction in open channel lumen observed over time. Overall, this work highlights an exciting three-way interplay between bioink formulation, construct design, and cell-mediated response that can be exploited towards engineering vascular tissues.

3D bioprinting involves the combination of 3D printing technologies with cells, growth factors and biomaterials, and has been considered as one of the most advanced tools for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine (TERM). However, despite multiple breakthroughs, it is evident that numerous challenges need to be overcome before 3D bioprinting will eventually become a clinical solution for a variety of TERM applications. To produce a 3D structure that is biologically functional, cell-laden bioinks must be optimized to meet certain key characteristics including rheological properties, physico-mechanical properties, and biofunctionality; a difficult task for a single component bioink especially for extrusion based bioprinting. As such, more recent research has been centred on multicomponent bioinks consisting of a combination of two or more biomaterials to improve printability, shape fidelity and biofunctionality. In this article, multicomponent hydrogel-based bioink systems are systemically reviewed based on the inherent nature of the bioink (natural or synthetic hydrogels), including the most current examples demonstrating properties and advances in application of multicomponent bioinks, specifically for extrusion based 3D bioprinting. This review article will assist researchers in the field in identifying the most suitable bioink based on their requirements, as well as pinpointing current unmet challenges in the field.

Evolution of metallurgy and biomaterials has progressively shifted the focus of metallic bone-interfacing implant design from adequate mechanical strength and biocompatibility to rapid osseointegration and infection inhibition. The now relatively well-established technology - powder bed additive manufacturing (AM), offers the ability to fabricate porous implants with precise mechanical properties, topological pore architectures and patient-specific design functions, has revolutionized the production of customized multifunctional metallic implants for the individual patient with anatomic-specific requirement. Even though AM titanium and its alloy Ti-6Al-4V have been investigated and adopted for clinical application for decades, the development of porous AM titanium implants is far from complete and further research is required to achieve excellent long-term clinical performance. In this review, we summarize the current status of AM in bone-interfacing implant fabrication, with particular focus on the experimental outcomes of various factors that influence osseointegration, bone and vascular ingrowth as well as hybrid strategies to combat infection, including: pore size, porosity, pore structure, surface modification techniques and incorporation of biological factors. In addition, we also discuss the osteogenic capacity of constructs fabricated through different manufacturing methods and titanium alloys. To this end, we highlight the exciting prospect of AM for bone-interfacing implant manufacture through optimization via material development, implant design, bio-functionalization to clinical evaluation to provide enhanced patient specificity and long-term function.

Decellularisation of tissues, utilising their biochemical cues, poses exciting tissue engineering (TE) opportunities. However, removing DNA from cartilage (dCart) requires harsh treatments due to its dense structure, causing loss of bioactivity and limiting its application as a cartilaginous extra cellular matrix (ECM). In this study, we demonstrate for the first time the successful application of vitreous humor (VH), a highly hydrated tissue closely resembling the glycosaminoglycan (GAG) and collagen composition of cartilage, as an ECM hydrogel to support chondrogenic differentiation. Equine VH was extracted followed by biochemical quantifications, histological examinations, cytotoxicity (human mesenchymal stromal cells, hMSCs and human articular chondrocytes, hACs) and U937 cell proliferation studies. VH was further seeded with hACs or hMSCs and cultured for 3-weeks to study chondrogenesis compared to scaffold-free micro-tissue pellet cultures and collagen-I hydrogels. Viability, metabolic activity, GAG and DNA content, chondrogenic gene expression (aggrecan, collagen I/II mRNA) and mechanical properties were quantified and matrix deposition was visualised using immunohistochemistry (Safranin-O, collagen I/II). VH was successfully extracted, exhibiting negligible amounts of DNA (0.4 ± 0.4 µg/mg dry-weight) and notable preservation of ECM components. VH displayed neither cytotoxic responses nor proliferation of macrophage-like U937 cells, instead enhancing both hMSC and hAC proliferation. Interestingly, encapsulated cells self-assembled the VH-hydrogel into spheroids, resulting in uniform distribution of both GAGs and collagen type II with increased compressive mechanical properties, rendering VH a permissive native ECM source to fabricate cartilaginous hydrogels for potential TE applications. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Fabricating bioactive and cell-instructive cartilage extracellular matrix (ECM) derived biomaterials and hydrogels has over recent years proven to be a challenging task, often limited by poor retention of inherent environmental cues post decellularisation due to the dense and avascular nature of native cartilage. In this study, we present an alternative route to fabricate highly permissive and bioactive ECM hydrogels from vitreous humor (VH) tissue. This paper specifically reports the discovery of optimal VH extraction protocols and cell seeding strategy enabling fabrication of cartilaginous matrix components into a hydrogel support material for promoting chondrogenic differentiation. The work showcases a naturally intact and unmodified hydrogel design that improves cellular responses and may help guide the development of cell instructive and stimuli responsive hybrid biomaterials in a number of TERM applications.

Oxygen inhibition is a phenomenon that directly impacts the print fidelity of 3D biofabricated and photopolymerized hydrogel constructs. It typically results in the undesirable physical collapse of fabricated constructs due to impaired cross-linking, and is an issue that generally remains unreported in the literature. In this study, we describe a systematic approach to minimizing oxygen inhibition in photopolymerized gelatin-methacryloyl (Gel-MA)-based hydrogel constructs, by comparing a new visible-light initiating system, Vis + ruthenium (Ru)/sodium persulfate (SPS) to more conventionally adopted ultraviolet (UV) + Irgacure 2959 system. For both systems, increasing photoinitiator concentration and light irradiation intensity successfully reduced oxygen inhibition. However, the UV + I2959 system was detrimental to cells at both high I2959 concentrations and UV light irradiation intensities. The Vis + Ru/SPS system yielded better cell cyto-compatibility, where encapsulated cells remained85% viable even at high Ru/SPS concentrations and visible-light irradiation intensities for up to 21 days, further highlighting the potential of this system to biofabricate cell-laden constructs with high shape fidelity, cell viability, and metabolic activity.

A photopolymerizable-tyraminated poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA-Tyr) system that has the ability to covalently bind proteins in their native state was evaluated as a platform for cell encapsulation. However, a key hurdle to this system is the radicals generated during the cross-linking that can cause oxidative stress to the cells. This research hypothesized that incorporation of anti-oxidative proteins (sericin and gelatin) into PVA-Tyr gels would mitigate any toxicity caused by the radicals. The results showed that although incorporation of 1 wt% sericin promoted survival of the fibroblasts, both sericin and gelatin acted synergistically to facilitate long-term 3D cell function. The encapsulated cells formed clusters with deposition of laminin and collagen, as well as remaining metabolically active after 21 d.

Multicomponent gelatin-methacryloyl (GelMA) hydrogels are regularly adopted for cartilage tissue engineering (TE) applications, where optimizing chemical modifications for preserving biofunctionality is often overlooked. This study investigates the biological effect of two different modification methods, methacrylation and thiolation, to copolymerize GelMA and heparin. The native bioactivity of methacrylated heparin (HepMA) and thiolated heparin (HepSH) is evaluated via thromboplastin time and heparan sulfate-deficient myeloid cell-line proliferation assay, demonstrating that thiolation is superior for preserving anticoagulation and growth factor signaling capacity. Furthermore, incorporating either HepMA or HepSH in chondrocyte-laden GelMA hydrogels, cultured for 5 weeks under chondrogenic conditions, promotes cell viability and chondrocyte phenotype. However, only GelMA-HepSH hydrogels yield significantly greater differentiation and matrix deposition in vitro compared to GelMA. This study demonstrates that thiol-ene chemistry offers a favorable strategy for incorporating bioactives into gelatin hydrogels as compared to methacrylation while furthermore highlighting GelMA-HepSH hydrogels as candidates for cartilage TE applications.

The development of high-resolution neuroprosthetics has driven the need for better electrode materials. Approaches to achieve both electrical and mechanical improvements have included the development of hydrogel and conducting polymer composites. However, these composites have limited biological interaction, as they are often composed of synthetic polymers or non-ideal biological polymers, which lack the required elements for biorecognition. This study explores the covalent incorporation of bioactive molecules within a conducting hydrogel (CH). The CH was formed from the biosynthetic co-hydrogel poly(vinyl alcohol)–heparin and the conductive polymer (CP), poly(3,4-ethylene dioxythiophene). Adhesive biomolecules sericin and gelatin were covalently incorporated via methacrylate crosslinking within the CH. Electrical properties of the bioactive CH were assessed, and it was shown that the polar biomolecules improved charge transfer. The bioactivity of heparin within the hybrid assessed by examining stimulation of B-lymphocyte (BaF3) proliferation showed that bioactivity was retained after electropolymerization of the CP through the hydrogel. Similarly, incorporation of sericin and gelatin in the CH promoted neural cell adhesion and proliferation, with only small percentages (⩽2 wt.%) required to achieve optimal results. Sericin provided the best support for the outgrowth of neural processes, and 1 wt.% was sufficient to facilitate adhesion and differentiation of neurons. The drug delivery capability of CH was shown through incorporation of nerve growth factor during polymer fabrication. NGF was delivered to the target cells, resulting in outgrowth of neural processes. The CH system is a flexible technology platform, which can be tailored to covalently incorporate bioactive protein sequences and deliver mobile water-soluble drug molecules.

Bioprinting of living cells is rapidly developing as an advanced biofabrication approach to engineer tissues. Bioinks can be extruded in three-dimensions (3D) to fabricate complex and hierarchical constructs for implantation. However, lack of functionality can often be attributed to poor bioink properties. Indeed, advanced bioinks encapsulating living cells should: (i) present optimal rheological properties and retain 3D structure post-fabrication, (ii) promote cell viability and support cell differentiation, (iii) localise proteins of interest (e.g. vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF)) to stimulate encapsulated cell activity and tissue ingrowth upon implantation. In this study, we present the results of the inclusion of a synthetic nanoclay, Laponite (LPN) together with a gelatin methacryloyl (GelMA) bioink and the development of a functional cell-instructive bioink. A nanocomposite bioink displaying enhanced shape fidelity retention and interconnected porosity within extrusion-bioprinted fibres was observed. Human bone marrow stromal cell (HBMSC) viability within the nanocomposite showed no significant changes over 21 days of culture in LPN-GelMA (85.60 ± 10.27 %), compared to a significant decrease in GelMA from 7 (95.88 ± 2.90 %) to 21 days (55.54 ± 14.72 %) (p

Bottom-up biofabrication approaches combining micro-tissue fabrication techniques with extrusion-based 3D printing of thermoplastic polymer scaffolds are emerging strategies in tissue engineering. These biofabrication strategies support native self-assembly mechanisms observed in developmental stages of tissue or organoid growth as well as promoting cell-cell interactions and cell differentiation capacity. Few technologies have been developed to automate the precise assembly of micro-tissues or tissue modules into structural scaffolds. We describe an automated 3D bioassembly platform capable of fabricating simple hybrid constructs via a two-step bottom-up bioassembly strategy, as well as complex hybrid hierarchical constructs via a multistep bottom-up bioassembly strategy. The bioassembly system consisted of a fluidic-based singularisation and injection module incorporated into a commercial 3D bioprinter. The singularisation module delivers individual micro-tissues to an injection module, for insertion into precise locations within a 3D plotted scaffold. To demonstrate applicability for cartilage tissue engineering, human chondrocytes were isolated and micro-tissues of 1 mm diameter were generated utilising a high throughput 96-well plate format. Micro-tissues were singularised with an efficiency of 96.0 ± 5.1%. There was no significant difference in size, shape or viability of micro-tissues before and after automated singularisation and injection. A layer-by-layer approach or aforementioned bottom-up bioassembly strategy was employed to fabricate a bilayered construct by alternatively 3D plotting a thermoplastic (PEGT/PBT) polymer scaffold and inserting pre-differentiated chondrogenic micro-tissues or cell-laden gelatin-based (GelMA) hydrogel micro-spheres, both formed via high-throughput fabrication techniques. No significant difference in viability between the construct assembled utilising the automated bioassembly system and manually assembled construct was observed. Bioassembly of pre-differentiated micro-tissues as well as chondrocyte-laden hydrogel micro-spheres demonstrated the flexibility of the platform while supporting tissue fusion, long-term cell viability, and deposition of cartilage-specific extracellular matrix proteins. This technology provides an automated and scalable pathway for bioassembly of both simple and complex 3D tissue constructs of clinically relevant shape and size, with demonstrated capability to facilitate direct spatial organisation and hierarchical 3D assembly of micro-tissue modules, ranging from biomaterial free cell pellets to cell-laden hydrogel formulations.

Development of tissue engineering solutions for biomedical applications has driven the need for integration of biological signals into synthetic materials. Approaches to achieve this typically require chemical modification of the biological molecules. Examples include chemical grafting of synthetic polymers onto protein backbones and covalent modification of proteins using crosslinkable functional groups. However, such chemical modification processes can cause protein degradation, denaturation or loss of biological activity due to side chain disruption. This study exploited the observation that native tyrosine rich proteins could be crosslinked via radical initiated bi-phenol bond formation without any chemical modification of the protein. A new, tyramine functionalised poly(vinyl alcohol) (PVA) polymer was synthesised and characterised. The tyramine modified PVA (PVA-Tyr) was fabricated into hydrogels using a visible light initiated crosslinking system. Mass loss studies showed that PVA-Tyr hydrogels were completely degraded within 19 days most likely via degradation of ester linkages in the network. Protein incorporation to form a biosynthetic hydrogel was achieved using unmodified gelatin, a protein derived from collagen and results showed that 75% of gelatin was retained in the gel post-polymerisation. Incorporation of gelatin did not alter the sol fraction, swelling ratio and degradation profile of the hydrogels, but did significantly improve the cellular interactions. Moreover, incorporation of as little as 0.01 wt% gelatin was sufficient to facilitate fibroblast adhesion onto PVA-Tyr/gelatin hydrogels. Overall, this study details the synthesis of a new functionalised PVA macromer and demonstrates that tyrosine containing proteins can be covalently incorporated into synthetic hydrogels using this innovative PVA-Tyr system. The resultant degradable biosynthetic hydrogels hold great promise as matrices for tissue engineering applications.

Sericin peptides and PVA are chemically modified with methacrylate groups to produce a covalent PVA/sericin hydrogel. Preservation of the sericin bioactivity following methacrylation is confirmed, and PVA/sericin hydrogels are fabricated for both B. mori and A. mylitta sericin. Cell adhesion studies confirm the preservation of sericin bioactivity post incorporation in PVA gels. PVA/A. mylitta gels are observed to facilitate cell adhesion to a significantly greater degree than PVA/B. mori gels. Overall, the incorporation of sericin does not alter the physical properties of the PVA hydrogels but does result in significantly improved cellular interaction, particularly from A. mylitta gels.

Background Dityrosine crosslinking in proteins is a bioinspired method of forming hydrogels. This study compares oxidative enzyme initiators for their relative crosslinking efficiency and cytocompatibility using the same phenol group and the same material platform. Four common enzyme and enzyme-like oxidative initiators were probed for resulting material properties and cell viability post-encapsulation. Results All four initiators can be used to form phenol-crosslinked hydrogels, however gelation rates are dependent on enzyme type, concentration, and the oxidant. Horseradish peroxidase (HRP) or hematin with hydrogen peroxide led to a more rapid poly (vinyl alcohol)-tyramine (PVA-Tyr) polymerization (10–60 min) because a high oxidant concentration was dissolved within the macromer solution at the onset of crosslinking, whereas laccase and tyrosinase require oxygen diffusion to crosslink phenol residues and therefore took longer to gel (2.5+ hours). The use of hydrogen peroxide as an oxidant reduced cell viability immediately post-encapsulation. Laccase- and tyrosinase-mediated encapsulation of cells resulted in higher cell viability immediately post-encapsulation and significantly higher cell proliferation after one week of culture. Conclusions Overall this study demonstrates that HRP/H2O2, hematin/H2O2, laccase, and tyrosinase can create injectable, in situ phenol-crosslinked hydrogels, however oxidant type and concentration are critical parameters to assess when phenol crosslinking hydrogels for cell-based applications. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s40824-016-0077-z) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.