Search

The number and distribution of recessive alleles in the population for various diseases are not known at genome-wide-scale. Based on 6447 exome-sequences of healthy, genetically-unrelated Europeans of two distinct ancestries, we estimate that every individual is a carrier of at least 2 pathogenic variants in currently known autosomal recessive (AR) genes, and that 0.8-1% of European couples are at-risk of having a child affected with a severe AR genetic disorder. This risk is 16.5-fold higher for first cousins, but is significantly more increased for skeletal disorders and intellectual disabilities due to their distinct genetic architecture.

Next generation sequencing tests are used routinely as first-choice tests in the clinic. However, systematic performance comparing the results of exome sequencing as a single test replacing Sanger sequencing of targeted gene(s) is still lacking. Performance comparison data are critically important for clinical case management. In this study, we compared Sanger-sequencing results of 258 genes to those obtained from next generation sequencing (NGS) using two exome-sequencing enrichment kits: Agilent-SureSelectQXT and Illumina-Nextera. Sequencing was performed on leukocytes and buccal-derived DNA from a single individual, and all 258 genes were sequenced a total of 11 times (using different sequencing methods and DNA sources). Sanger sequencing was completed for all exons, including flanking ± 8 bp regions. For the 258 genes, NGS mean coverage was > 20 × for > 98 and > 91% of the regions targeted by SureSelect and Nextera, respectively. Overall, 449 variants were identified in at least one experiment, and 407/449 (90.6%) were detected by all. Of the 42 discordant variants, 23 were determined as true calls, summing-up to a truth set of 430 variants. Sensitivity of true-variant detection was 99% for Sanger sequencing and 97–100% for the NGS experiments. Mean false-positive rates were 3.7E-6 for Sanger sequencing, 2.5E-6 for SureSelect-NGS and 5.2E-6 for Nextera-NGS. Our findings suggest a high overall concordance between Sanger sequencing and NGS performances. Both methods demonstrated false-positive and false-negative calls. High clinical suspicion for a specific diagnosis should, therefore, override negative results of either Sanger sequencing or NGS.

Systematic performance comparing the results of exome-sequencing as a single test replacing Sanger-sequencing of targeted gene(s) is still lacking. In this study we compared Sanger-sequencing results of 258 genes to those obtained from next generation sequencing (NGS) using two exome-sequencing enrichment kits: Agilent-SureSelectQXT and Illumina-Nextera. Sequencing was performed on leukocytes and buccal-derived DNA from a single individual, and all 258 genes were sequenced a total of 11 times (using different sequencing methods and DNA sources). Sanger-sequencing was completed for all exons, including flanking ±8bp regions. For the 258 genes, NGS mean coverage was >20x for >98% and >91% of the regions targeted by SureSelect and Nextera, respectively. Overall, 449 variants were identified in at least one experiment, and 407/449 (90.6%) were detected by all. Of the 42 discordant variants, 23 were determined as true calls, summing-up to a truth set of 430 variants. Sensitivity of true-variant detection was 99% for Sanger-sequencing and 97%-100% for the NGS experiments. Mean false-positive rates were 3.7E-6 for Sanger-sequencing, 2.5E-6 for SureSelect-NGS and 5.2E-6 for Nextera-NGS. Our findings suggest a high overall concordance between Sanger-sequencing and NGS. Both methods demonstrated false positive and false negative calls and similar performances. Consequently, high clinical suspicion for a specific diagnosis should override negative results of either Sanger-sequencing or NGS.

BackgroundKisspeptin 1 receptor (KISS1R) gene mutations are rare but have recently become an important etiology of normosmic isolated hypogonadotropic hypogonadism (IHH).ObjectivesTo characterize the genetic defect, the phenotype, and response to therapy of three IHH siblings with a novel severe KISS1R mutation.Patients and methodsThree siblings (16- and 22-year-old sisters and their 20-year-old brother) born to consanguineous parents with normal neonatal external genitalia presented with no pubertal development, normosmia, and a low response to GNRH stimulation. Homozygosity mapping, KISS1R gene sequencing, and RNA expression were performed.ResultsThe females' basal low estradiol level (50 pmol/l) failed to rise in response to human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG). The brother's low testosterone (1.87 nmol/l) responded to combined hCG and human menopausal gonadotropin (hCG) and HMG therapies, but the testes remained small (1–2 ml). Secondary sexual characteristics were attained by exogenous sex steroid replacement. SNP array studies revealed shared homozygosity for a chromosome 19 region encompassing KISS1R. Sequencing revealed a novel homozygous KISS1R mutation at the nt-1 canonical acceptor splice site of intron 1 in affected siblings. The mother (menarche at 14 years) was heterozygous. cDNA sequencing showed that the G>A mutation results in skipping of exon 2 and a premature stop codon at residue 151.ConclusionsThe novel severe N-terminal KISS1R splice site (c.245−1G>A) mutation results in IHH. Heterozygous female carriers may manifest a subtle fertile phenotype. The subnormal gonadal response to hCG in patients may implicate a direct role of KISS1R in gonadal function. The normal neonatal virilization in a male homozygous to this severe mutation challenges the hypothesis that KISS1R is required for fetal development of male external genitalia.

XX female gonadal dysgenesis (XX-GD) is a rare, genetically heterogeneous disorder characterized by lack of spontaneous pubertal development, primary amenorrhea, uterine hypoplasia, and hypergonadotropic hypogonadism as a result of streak gonads. Most cases are unexplained but thought to be autosomal recessive. We elucidated the genetic basis of XX-GD in a highly consanguineous Palestinian family by using homozygosity mapping and candidate-gene and whole-exome sequencing. Affected females were homozygous for a 3 bp deletion (NM_016556.2, c.600_602del) in the PSMC3IP gene, leading to deletion of a glutamic acid residue (p.Glu201del) in the highly conserved C-terminal acidic domain. Proteasome 26S subunit, ATPase, 3-Interacting Protein (PSMC3IP)/Tat Binding Protein Interacting Protein (TBPIP) is a nuclear, tissue-specific protein with multiple functions. It is critical for meiotic recombination as indicated by the known role of its yeast ortholog, Hop2. Through the C terminus (not present in yeast), PSMC3IP also coactivates ligand-driven transcription mediated by estrogen, androgen, glucocorticoid, progesterone, and thyroid nuclear receptors. In cell lines, the p.Glu201del mutation abolished PSMC3IP activation of estrogen-driven transcription. Impaired estrogenic signaling can lead to ovarian dysgenesis both by affecting the size of the follicular pool created during fetal development and by failing to counteract follicular atresia during puberty. PSMC3IP joins previous genes known to be mutated in XX-GD, the FSH receptor, and BMP15, highlighting the importance of hormonal signaling in ovarian development and maintenance and suggesting a common pathway perturbed in isolated XX-GD. By analogy to other XX-GD genes, PSMC3IP is also a candidate gene for premature ovarian failure, and its role in folliculogenesis should be further investigated.