Search

This report provides results from a controlled, double blind, randomized, prophylactic leprosy vaccine trial conducted in South India. Four vaccines, viz BCG, BCG+ killed M. leprae, M.w and ICRC were studied in this trial in comparison with normal saline placebo. From about 3,00,000 people, 2,16,000 were found eligible for vaccination and among them, 1,71,400 volunteered to participate in the study. Intake for the study was completed in two and a half years from January 1991. There was no instance of serious toxicity or side effects subsequent to vaccination for which premature decoding was required. All the vaccine candidates were safe for human use. Decoding was done after the completion of the second resurvey in December 1998. Results for vaccine efficacy are based on examination of more than 70% of the original "vaccinated" cohort population, in both the first and the second resurveys. It was possible to assess the overall protective efficacy of the candidate vaccines against leprosy as such. Observed incidence rates were not sufficiently high to ascertain the protective efficacy of the candidate vaccines against progressive and serious forms of leprosy. BCG+ killed M. leprae provided 64% protection (CI 50.4-73.9), ICRC provided 65.5% protection (CI 48.0-77.0), M.w gave 25.7% protection (CI 1.9-43.8) and BCG gave 34.1% protection (CI 13.5-49.8). Protection observed with the ICRC vaccine and the combination vaccine (BCG+ killed M. leprae) meets the requirement of public health utility and these vaccines deserve further consideration for their ultimate applicability in leprosy prevention.

All the vaccines supplied for the large scale comparative leprosy vaccine trial of ICRC bacilli, M.w, BCG plus killed M. leprae (candidate vaccines), BCG and normal saline (control arms) at CJIL Field Unit, Chennai were tested for quality control by the suppliers following the procedures laid down in the WHO protocol for killed M. leprae. Quality control for BCG was carried out at BCG vaccine laboratory as per protocol. Toxicity and sterility tests were done on all the vaccine batches/lots received. As part of the quality control, bacterial count, and protein estimation were also done. Studies showed that the bacterial content and protein concentration were comparable with the original preparations. Vaccines were free from micro-organisms, toxic materials and safe for human use. Thus the quality of all vaccine preparations was satisfactory.

BCG is one of the vaccines used, as control arm, in an ongoing large scale comparative leprosy vaccine trial in South India. The objective of the present study was to examine, in the local population, the sensitizing ability, as measured by skin test reactions to tuberculin, and reactogenecity, in terms of skin lesions at the site of vaccination, for the two batches of BCG vaccine used in the above trial. The study was undertaken in 816 tuberculin-negative, previously not vaccinated school children, aged five to 14 years. Each child received one of the two batches of BCG vaccine or normal saline (control), by random allocation. At 12 weeks from vaccination, character and size of local response, at the vaccination site, were recorded. At the same time, the children were retested with tuberculin and post-vaccination reactions to the test were measured after 72 hours. At three years after vaccination all available children were re-examined for the presence and size of BCG scar at the site of vaccination. It was found that healing of vaccination lesions was uneventful, with both batches of BCG. The mean size of the lesion was similar for the two batches, the overall mean being 6.3 mm. The mean size of post-vaccination tuberculin sensitivity increased with age, and it was 14.5 mm and 15.6 mm. The sensitizing effect attributable to the vaccine was 11 mm and 12 mm, for the two batches of BCG respectively. This study showed that the two batches of BCG, in a dose of 0.1 mg, used in the ongoing leprosy vaccine trial were acceptable in terms of vaccination lesion and were highly satisfactory in terms of development of hypersensitivity.

Phase-II and extended Phase-II studies were conducted in three different sets of the population in Thiruthani Taluk, Chengalpattu District, South India, involving BCG and killed Mycobacterium leprae (KML) combination vaccines to ascertain the acceptability of the vaccines. In the Phase-II study, 997 healthy volunteers were vaccinated on individual randomization with one of the vaccines arms: BCG 0.1 mg + 6 x 10(8) KML, BCG 0.1 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML, BCG 0.1 mg + 5 x 10(6) KML, BCG, 0.1 mg or normal saline. Blood samples were taken and the serum was tested for antibody levels against phenolic glycolipid-I (PGL-I) and the 35-kDa protein of M. leprae. In this study, we observed regional suppurative adenitis in 6% (6 out of 100), 3% (3 out of 100), and 3% (3 out of 100) of the vaccinees in the BCG 0.1 mg + 6 x 10(8) KML, BCG 0.1 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML, and BCG 0.1 mg + 5 x 10(6) KML vaccine arms, respectively, in the 13-70 year age group. Earlier BCG scar status, skin-test reactions to lepromin-A, Rees' MLSA, and serum antibody levels against PGL-I and the 35-kDa protein did not help to identify the group at risk of developing suppurative adenitis. Suppurative adenitis appears to have a different relationship between the age of the subject and the dose of the vaccine. In order to overcome the problem of regional suppurative adenitis and to know the mechanism involved, an extended Phase-II study was conducted in similar groups of the population by reducing the BCG and KML doses, i.e., with BCG 0.05 mg + 6 x 10(8) KML, BCG 0.05 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML, and BCG 0.01 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML. Biopsy specimens were collected from lymph nodes of the suppurative adenitis cases and were subjected for culture and histopathological examination. The observations showed that regional suppurative adenitis could be reduced to 1% in the BCG 0.05 + 6 x 10(8) KML group, 0.5% in the BCG 0.05 + 5 x 10(7) KML group, and 0.5% in the BCG 0.01 + 5 x 10(7) KML group. This phenomenon of suppurative adenitis appears to be related to the total dose of mycobacterial antigens. Suppurative adenitis was seen by weeks 18 and 20 post-vaccination in the latter two lower doses; whereas it was seen by week 8 in the higher dose of the combination vaccines. No case of suppurative adenitis was observed in the BCG 0.1 mg group. Culture and histopathology ruled out the possibilities of progressive BCG infection and superadded infection. Considering the above results, BCG 0.05 mg + 6 x 10(8) KML was acceptable for a large-scale vaccine trial in South India.

This study is an extension of a previous study on an antileprosy combination vaccine of BCG plus killed Mycobacterium leprae (KML) regarding its sensitization potential and reactogenicity. The study was extended to see if by reducing the dose of BCG in the combination vaccine the incidence of suppurative adenitis could be reduced without a significant reduction in the level of postvaccination skin-test responses. The study included 860 individuals, and three preparations of the combination vaccine [BCG 0.05 mg + 6 x 10(8) KML (I), BCG 0.05 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML (II), BCG 0.01 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML (III)] along with normal saline (i.v.) were used. Each individual received one of these four preparations by random allocation. They were also tested with Rees' M. leprae soluble antigen (MLSA) and lepromin A 12 weeks after vaccination. Reactions to the MLSA were measured after 48 hr; reactions to lepromin A after 48 hr and 3 weeks. The character and size of the local response at the vaccination site were recorded at the third, eighth, and 15th week postvaccination. The results of the study showed that by halving the dose of BCG in the combination vaccine BCG plus 6 x 10(8) KML a) the incidence of suppurative regional adenitis was reduced significantly, b) there was no significant change in the post-vaccination response at 12 weeks as measured by Rees' MLSA and lepromin A, and c) the evolution of the vaccination lesion was somewhat prolonged. This dose was found satisfactory for use in a comparative antileprosy vaccine trial in South India.

A study was conducted in 997 individuals in two villages in south India to find the acceptability and sensitizing effect of the antileprosy combination vaccine of BCG plus killed Mycobacterium leprae (KML). Three preparations of the combination, BCG 0.1 mg + 6 x 10(8) KML (I), BCG 0.1 mg + 5 x 10(7) KML (II), and BCG 0.1 mg + 5 x 10(6) KML (III), along with BCG 0.1 mg (IV), and normal saline (V), were used in the study. Each individual received one of the above five preparations by random allocation. They were also tested with Rees' M. leprae soluble skin-test antigen (MLSA) and lepromin-A, both at intake and 12 weeks after vaccination. Reactions to Rees' MLSA were measured after 48 hr; those to lepromin-A after 48 hr and 3 weeks. The character and size of the local response at the vaccination site were recorded at 3, 8, 12, 15, and 27 weeks after vaccination. The mean sizes of postvaccination sensitization to both Rees' MLSA and lepromin-A in the vaccine groups were significantly larger than those in the normal saline group, clearly demonstrating the ability of the vaccines to induce sensitization as measured by responses to the two skin tests. The sensitizing effect was the highest following vaccination with vaccine I. It was not significantly different for vaccines II, III, and IV, although, generally, a dose-response effect was observed. The sensitizing effect attributable to the vaccine was more clearly seen in children than in adults. The above conclusions were the same irrespective of which results were considered, reactions to Rees' MLSA or Fernandez or Mitsuda reactions to lepromin-A. A significant finding of the study was that at intake the Mitsuda reactions provided a measure of sensitizing effect due to vaccine. The healing of vaccination lesions was uneventful. In more than 90% of vaccinated individuals, the lesions had healed by the 12th week in vaccine groups II, III, and IV, and by the 15th week in vaccine group I. The results showed that vaccination with BCG or combination vaccines was equally safe in individuals with or without previous BCG scars. Thirteen persons, aged 10 years or older, developed suppurative lymphadenitis around the 8th week (7 in vaccine group I, 3 each in vaccine groups II and III). However, healing was prompt after drainage in these individuals.