1. Gender Effects in the Canadian Intermediate Appellate Courts.
- Author
-
Johnson, Susan W., Songer, Donald R., and Masood, Ali
- Subjects
- *
APPELLATE courts , *JUDGES , *WOMEN judges , *WOMEN in public life , *POLITICAL science research - Abstract
This study offers a preliminary look at the impact of gender effects and consciousness-raising in the Canadian intermediate appellate courts. This analysis is one component of a larger project that examines the impact of trailblazer women cross-nationally within intermediate appellate courts. In this preliminary work, we investigate the impact of judge gender on decisions of the intermediate appellate courts in five of the largest provinces in Canada between 1986 and 2010. The results support our theoretical intuitions on gender consciousness-raising by female judges in criminal and civil liberties cases. We find differences in female decision patterns in criminal cases, but not in equality and privacy cases, where prior research suggests some differences in decision-making patterns might exist. We hypothesize that these findings might be due to diminishing effects of gender differences over time, and thus, we plan to extend our time period of analysis in order to explore gender effects by trailblazers, similar to Moyer and Haire's (2015) study of trailblazer women on the U.S. courts of appeal. The proposed research project, currently in progress, will build on this study and an existing study of the U.S. courts (Masood and Songer 2013), by examining trailblazer effects in the U.S., Canada, and England intermediate appellate courts. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2016