1. Assessment of network module identification across complex diseases
- Author
-
Choobdar, Sarvenaz, Ahsen, Mehmet E., Natoli, Ted, Lysenko, Artem, Ma, Tianle, Mall, Raghvendra, Marbach, Daniel, Mattia, Tomasoni, Medvedovic, Mario, Menche, Jörg, Mercer, Johnathan, Micarelli, Elisa, Monaco, Alfonso, Narayan, Rajiv, Müller, Felix, Narykov, Oleksandr, Norman, Thea, Park, Sungjoon, Perfetto, Livia, Perrin, Dimitri, Pirrò, Stefano, Przytycka, Teresa M., DREAM Module Identification Challenge Consortium, Qian, Xiaoning, Raman, Karthik, Ramazzotti, Daniele, Ramsahai, Emilie, Ravindran, Balaraman, Rennert, Philip, Sáez Rodríguez, Julio, Schärfe, Charlotta, Sharan, Roded, Shi, Ning, Subramanian, Aravind, Shin, Wonho, Shu, Hai, Sinha, Himanshu, Slonim, Donna K., Spinelli, Lionel, Srinivasan, Suhas, Suver, Christine, Szklarczyk, Damian, Tangaro, Sabina, Zhang, Jitao D., Thiagarajan, Suresh, Tichit, Laurent, Tiede, Thorsten, Tripathi, Beethika, Tsherniak, Aviad, Tsunoda, Tatsuhiko, Türei, Dénes, Ullah, Ehsan, Vahedi, Golnaz, Valdeolivas, Alberto, Stolovitzky, Gustavo, Vivek, Jayaswal, von Mering, Christian, Waagmeester, Andra, Wang, Bo, Wang, Yijie, Weir, Barbara A., White, Shana, Winkler, Sebastian, Xu, Ke, Xu, Taosheng, Kutalik, Zoltán, Yan, Chunhua, Yang, Liuqing, Yu, Kaixian, Yu, Xiangtian, Zaffaroni, Gaia, Zaslavskiy, Mikhail, Zeng, Tao, Zhang, Lu, Zhang, Weijia, Lage, Kasper, Zhang, Lixia, Zhang, Xinyu, Zhang, Junpeng, Zhou, Xin, Zhou, Jiarui, Zhu, Hongtu, Zhu, Junjie, Zuccon, Guido, Crawford, Jake, Cowen, Lenore J., Bergmann, Sven, Aicheler, Fabian, Amoroso, Nicola, Arenas, Alex, Azhagesan, Karthik, Baker, Aaron, Banf, Michael, Batzoglou, Serafim, Tomasoni, Mattia, Baudot, Anaïs, Bellotti, Roberto, Boroevich, Keith A., Brun, Christine, Cai, Stanley, Caldera, Michael, Calderone, Alberto, Cesareni, Gianni, Chen, Weiqi, Fang, Tao, Chichester, Christine, Cowen, Lenore, Cui, Hongzhu, Dao, Phuong, De Domenico, Manlio, Dhroso, Andi, Didier, Gilles, Divine, Mathew, Lamparter, David, Del Sol, Antonio, Feng, Xuyang, Flores-Canales, Jose C., Fortunato, Santo, Gitter, Anthony, Gorska, Anna, Guan, Yuanfang, Guénoche, Alain, Gómez, Sergio, Lin, Junyuan, Hamza, Hatem, Hartmann, András, He, Shan, Heijs, Anton, Heinrich, Julian, Hescott, Benjamin, Hu, Xiaozhe, Hu, Ying, Huang, Xiaoqing, Hughitt, V. Keith, Jeon, Minji, Jeub, Lucas, Johnson, Nathan T., Joo, Keehyoung, Joung, InSuk, Jung, Sascha, Kalko, Susana G., Kamola, Piotr J., Kang, Jaewoo, Kaveelerdpotjana, Benjapun, Kim, Minjun, Kim, Yoo-Ah, Kohlbacher, Oliver, Korkin, Dmitry, Krzysztof, Kiryluk, Kunji, Khalid, Kutalik, Zoltàn, Lang-Brown, Sean, Le, Thuc Duy, Lee, Jooyoung, Lee, Sunwon, Lee, Juyong, Li, Dong, Li, Jiuyong, Liu, Lin, Loizou, Antonis, Luo, Zhenhua, Choobdar, Sarvenaz, Ahsen, Mehmet E., Crawford, Jake, Tomasoni, Mattia, Le, Thuc Duy, Li, Jiuyong, Liu, Lin, Zhang, W, Marbach, D, The DREAM Module Identification Challenge Consortium, Choobdar, S, Ahsen, M, Crawford, J, Tomasoni, M, Fang, T, Lamparter, D, Lin, J, Hescott, B, Hu, X, Mercer, J, Natoli, T, Narayan, R, Aicheler, F, Amoroso, N, Arenas, A, Azhagesan, K, Baker, A, Banf, M, Batzoglou, S, Baudot, A, Bellotti, R, Bergmann, S, Boroevich, K, Brun, C, Cai, S, Caldera, M, Calderone, A, Cesareni, G, Chen, W, Chichester, C, Cowen, L, Cui, H, Dao, P, De Domenico, M, Dhroso, A, Didier, G, Divine, M, del Sol, A, Feng, X, Flores-Canales, J, Fortunato, S, Gitter, A, Gorska, A, Guan, Y, Guenoche, A, Gomez, S, Hamza, H, Hartmann, A, He, S, Heijs, A, Heinrich, J, Hu, Y, Huang, X, Hughitt, V, Jeon, M, Jeub, L, Johnson, N, Joo, K, Joung, I, Jung, S, Kalko, S, Kamola, P, Kang, J, Kaveelerdpotjana, B, Kim, M, Kim, Y, Kohlbacher, O, Korkin, D, Krzysztof, K, Kunji, K, Kutalik, Z, Lage, K, Lang-Brown, S, Le, T, Lee, J, Lee, S, Li, D, Li, J, Liu, L, Loizou, A, Luo, Z, Lysenko, A, Ma, T, Mall, R, Mattia, T, Medvedovic, M, Menche, J, Micarelli, E, Monaco, A, Muller, F, Narykov, O, Norman, T, Park, S, Perfetto, L, Perrin, D, Pirro, S, Przytycka, T, Qian, X, Raman, K, Ramazzotti, D, Ramsahai, E, Ravindran, B, Rennert, P, Saez-Rodriguez, J, Scharfe, C, Sharan, R, Shi, N, Shin, W, Shu, H, Sinha, H, Slonim, D, Spinelli, L, Srinivasan, S, Subramanian, A, Suver, C, Szklarczyk, D, Tangaro, S, Thiagarajan, S, Tichit, L, Tiede, T, Tripathi, B, Tsherniak, A, Tsunoda, T, Turei, D, Ullah, E, Vahedi, G, Valdeolivas, A, Vivek, J, von Mering, C, Waagmeester, A, Wang, B, Wang, Y, Weir, B, White, S, Winkler, S, Xu, K, Xu, T, Yan, C, Yang, L, Yu, K, Yu, X, Zaffaroni, G, Zaslavskiy, M, Zeng, T, Zhang, J, Zhang, L, Zhang, X, Zhou, X, Zhou, J, Zhu, H, Zhu, J, Zuccon, G, Stolovitzky, G, Spinelli, Lionel, Institut de Mathématiques de Marseille (I2M), Aix Marseille Université (AMU)-École Centrale de Marseille (ECM)-Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Marseille medical genetics - Centre de génétique médicale de Marseille (MMG), Aix Marseille Université (AMU)-Institut National de la Santé et de la Recherche Médicale (INSERM), Theories and Approaches of Genomic Complexity (TAGC), DREAM Module Identification Challenge Consortium, Aicheler, F., Amoroso, N., Arenas, A., Azhagesan, K., Baker, A., Banf, M., Batzoglou, S., Baudot, A., Bellotti, R., Bergmann, S., Boroevich, K.A., Brun, C., Cai, S., Caldera, M., Calderone, A., Cesareni, G., Chen, W., Chichester, C., Choobdar, S., Cowen, L., Crawford, J., Cui, H., Dao, P., De Domenico, M., Dhroso, A., Didier, G., Divine, M., Del Sol, A., Fang, T., Feng, X., Flores-Canales, J.C., Fortunato, S., Gitter, A., Gorska, A., Guan, Y., Guénoche, A., Gómez, S., Hamza, H., Hartmann, A., He, S., Heijs, A., Heinrich, J., Hescott, B., Hu, X., Hu, Y., Huang, X., Hughitt, V.K., Jeon, M., Jeub, L., Johnson, N.T., Joo, K., Joung, I., Jung, S., Kalko, S.G., Kamola, P.J., Kang, J., Kaveelerdpotjana, B., Kim, M., Kim, Y.A., Kohlbacher, O., Korkin, D., Krzysztof, K., Kunji, K., Kutalik, Z., Lage, K., Lamparter, D., Lang-Brown, S., Le, T.D., Lee, J., Lee, S., Li, D., Li, J., Lin, J., Liu, L., Loizou, A., Luo, Z., Lysenko, A., Ma, T., Mall, R., Marbach, D., Mattia, T., Medvedovic, M., Menche, J., Mercer, J., Micarelli, E., Monaco, A., Müller, F., Narayan, R., Narykov, O., Natoli, T., Norman, T., Park, S., Perfetto, L., Perrin, D., Pirrò, S., Przytycka, T.M., Qian, X., Raman, K., Ramazzotti, D., Ramsahai, E., Ravindran, B., Rennert, P., Saez-Rodriguez, J., Schärfe, C., Sharan, R., Shi, N., Shin, W., Shu, H., Sinha, H., Slonim, D.K., Spinelli, L., Srinivasan, S., Subramanian, A., Suver, C., Szklarczyk, D., Tangaro, S., Thiagarajan, S., Tichit, L., Tiede, T., Tripathi, B., Tsherniak, A., Tsunoda, T., Türei, D., Ullah, E., Vahedi, G., Valdeolivas, A., Vivek, J., von Mering, C., Waagmeester, A., Wang, B., Wang, Y., Weir, B.A., White, S., Winkler, S., Xu, K., Xu, T., Yan, C., Yang, L., Yu, K., Yu, X., Zaffaroni, G., Zaslavskiy, M., Zeng, T., Zhang, J.D., Zhang, L., Zhang, W., Zhang, X., Zhang, J., Zhou, X., Zhou, J., Zhu, H., Zhu, J., and Zuccon, G.
- Subjects
Identification methods ,Cellular signalling networks ,Computer science ,Population genetics ,[SDV]Life Sciences [q-bio] ,Quantitative Trait Loci ,Gene regulatory network ,DREAM challenge ,network ,modules ,predictions ,Genome-wide association study ,Computational biology ,Biochemistry ,Models, Biological ,Polymorphism, Single Nucleotide ,Gene regulatory networks ,Functional clustering ,03 medical and health sciences ,Human disease ,Humans ,Disease ,ddc:610 ,Protein Interaction Maps ,Molecular Biology ,ComputingMilieux_MISCELLANEOUS ,030304 developmental biology ,0303 health sciences ,Network module ,[SDV.BIBS] Life Sciences [q-bio]/Quantitative Methods [q-bio.QM] ,Network topology ,Gene Expression Profiling ,Computational Biology ,Cell Biology ,[SDV.BIBS]Life Sciences [q-bio]/Quantitative Methods [q-bio.QM] ,Gene expression profiling ,[SDV] Life Sciences [q-bio] ,Molecular network ,Phenotype ,Protein network ,Network Module Identification ,Analysis ,Algorithms ,Biotechnology ,Genome-Wide Association Study - Abstract
Many bioinformatics methods have been proposed for reducing the complexity of large gene or protein networks into relevant subnetworks or modules. Yet, how such methods compare to each other in terms of their ability to identify disease-relevant modules in different types of network remains poorly understood. We launched the ‘Disease Module Identification DREAM Challenge’, an open competition to comprehensively assess module identification methods across diverse protein–protein interaction, signaling, gene co-expression, homology and cancer-gene networks. Predicted network modules were tested for association with complex traits and diseases using a unique collection of 180 genome-wide association studies. Our robust assessment of 75 module identification methods reveals top-performing algorithms, which recover complementary trait-associated modules. We find that most of these modules correspond to core disease-relevant pathways, which often comprise therapeutic targets. This community challenge establishes biologically interpretable benchmarks, tools and guidelines for molecular network analysis to study human disease biology., In this DREAM challenge, 75 methods for the identification of disease-relevant modules from molecular networks are compared and validated with GWAS data. The authors provide practical guidelines for users and establish benchmarks for network analysis.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF