Search

The isozymes of class III alcohol dehydrogenase/glutathione-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase from cod were characterized. They exhibited three unexpected properties of general interest. First, these dimeric isozymes, derived from two types of subunit (h and l, for high- and low-activity forms), were recovered from liver preparations in only the homodimeric ll and heterodimeric hl combinations. Dissociation and reassociation of the isolated hl form in vitro also resulted in lower yields of the hh than the ll homodimer, although class III subunits are usually freely associable over wide borders of divergence (human and Drosophila). The h and l primary structures show that both chain types are characteristic of class III enzymes, without large amino acid replacements at positions of known subunit interactions. Hence, the hh dimer partial restriction indicates nontraditional alterations at h-subunit interfaces. The structure provides a possible explanation, in the form of h-chain modifications that may influence the anchoring of a loop at positions of two potentially deamidative beta-aspartyl shifts at distant Asn-Gly structures. Second the ll and hl forms differ in enzymatic properties, having 5-fold different K(m) values for NAD+ at pH 8, different K(m) values for S-(hydroxymethyl)glutathione (10 versus 150 microM), and different specific activities (4.5 versus 41 units/mg), with ll resembling and hl deviating from human and other class III alcohol dehydrogenases. However, functional residues lining substrate and coenzyme pockets in the known conformations of homologous forms are largely identical in the two isozymes [only minor conservative exchanges of Val/Leu116, Val/Leu203, Ile/Val224, and Ile/Val269 (numbering system of the human class I enzyme)], again indicating effects from distantly positioned h-chain replacements. Third, the two isozymes differ a surprising amount in amino acid sequence (18%, the same as the piscine/ human difference), reflecting a remarkably old isozyme duplication or, more probably, discordant accumulation of residue exchanges with greater speed of evolution for one of the subunits (h chain) than is typical for the slowly evolving class III alcohol dehydrogenase.

A plant class III alcohol dehydrogenase (or glutathione-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase) has been characterized. The enzyme is a typical class III member with enzymatic parameters and substrate specificity closely related to those of already established animal forms. Km values with the pea enzyme are 6.5 microM for NAD+, 2 microM for S-hydroxymethylglutathione, and 840 microM for octanol versus 9, 4, and 1200 microM, respectively, with the human enzyme. Structurally, the pea/human class III enzymes are closely related, exhibiting a residue identity of 69% and with only 3 of 23 residues differing among those often considered in substrate and coenzyme binding. In contrast, the corresponding ethanol-active enzymes, the long-known human liver and pea alcohol dehydrogenases, differ more (47% residue identities) and are also in functionally important active site segments, with 12 of the 23 positions exchanged, including no less than 7 at the usually much conserved coenzyme-binding segment. These differences affect functionally important residues that are often class-distinguishing, such as those at positions 48, 51, and 115, where the plant ethanol-active forms resemble class III (Thr, Tyr, and Arg, respectively) rather than the animal ethanol-active class I forms (typically Ser, His, and Asp, respectively). Calculations of phylogenetic trees support the conclusions from functional residues in subgrouping plant ethanol-active dehydrogenases and the animal ethanol-active enzymes (class I) as separate descendants from the class III line. It appears that the classical plant alcohol dehydrogenases (now called class P) have a duplicatory origin separate from that of the animal class I enzymes and therefore a paralogous relationship with functional convergence of their alcohol substrate specificity. Combined, the results establish the conserved nature of class III also in plants, and contribute to the molecular and functional understanding of alcohol dehydrogenases by defining two branches of plant enzymes into the system.

The glutathione-dependent formaldehyde dehydrogenase gene (gfd) of Drosophila melanogaster encodes an enzyme that is active toward S-hydroxymethylglutathione, an adduct of formaldehyde with glutathione, and also with long-chain primary alcohols, both properties typical of class III alcohol dehydrogenases, gfd hybridizes at the 86D division of the third chromosome, in agreement with the known location of the Drosophila octanol dehydrogenase gene (odh), gfd/odh was isolated from a lambda EMBL-4 genomic library and consists of three exons (with coding segments of 21, 90 and 1029 bp) and two introns (69 bp and 70 bp, respectively). The introns are small in size like the Drosophila interrupting sequences and are located at the 5' end of the coding region. Comparisons with the homologous genes of Saccharomyces, Candida and humans provide information on the evolution of the class III alcohol dehydrogenases. Moreover, results from analysis of exon/intron distributions in eleven dehydrogenases are compatible with the hypothesis of intron loss accounting for aspects of the present structure of these genes.

Alcohol dehydrogenases of classes I (the classical liver enzyme) and III (formaldehyde dehydrogenase) constitute a pair of moderately related enzymes (63% residue identity between the human forms) that differ fundamentally in many respects. To elucidate the nature of the differences, we have characterized alcohol dehydrogenase from the most primitive vertebrate line (a cyclostome, Atlantic Hagfish), related that to the multiplicity of the human enzyme, and submitted the enzymes to in vitro hybridization for evaluation of subunit interactions. Three findings illustrate important principles of the enzyme system. First, the alcohol dehydrogenase purified from cyclostomes is a class-III protein, compatible with the facts that cyclostomes constitute the earliest extant vertebrate line and that class III has a distant pre-vertebrate origin. Second, the hagfish enzyme shows multiplicity, with acidic forms in decreasing yield and with amino acid sequences identical between two major isoforms, both aspects constituting properties similar to those of the corresponding human forms. The chemically different subunits are present as homodimers and heterodimers of unmodified and modified subunits, suggesting that the class-III multiplicity derives from modification of a type common to lines as divergent as mammals and cyclostomes. Third, the human enzyme can form cross-species hybrid dimers in vitro with the cod and hagfish or Drosophila class-III enzymes (positional identity with the human form of 82, 76 and 70%, respectively). Hence, the results provide experimental evidence for little class-III divergence in the segments of subunit interactions. The extent of conservation of residues directly involved in the formation of the subunit interface also reveals a clearly different pattern between classes I and III. This highlights separation of divergent forms in an enzyme system, with the constant form (class III) resembling house-keeping enzymes, and exhibiting a correlation between subunit-interacting and substrate-interacting segments.

Analysis of the activity and structure of lower vertebrate alcohol dehydrogenases reveals that relationships between the classical liver and yeast enzymes need not be continuous. Both the ethanol activity of class I-type alcohol dehydrogenase (alcohol:NAD+ oxidoreductase, EC 1.1.1.1) and the glutathione-dependent formaldehyde activity of the class III-type enzyme [formaldehyde:NAD+ oxidoreductase (glutathione-formylating), EC 1.2.1.1] are present in liver down to at least the stage of bony fishes (cod liver: ethanol activity, 3.4 units/mg of protein in one enzyme; formaldehyde activity, 4.5 units/mg in the major form of another enzyme). Structural analysis of the latter protein reveals it to be a typical class III enzyme, with limited variation from the mammalian form and therefore with stable activity and structure throughout much of the vertebrate lineage. In contrast, the classical alcohol dehydrogenase (the class I enzyme) appears to be the emerging form, first in activity and later also in structure. The class I activity is present already in the piscine line, whereas the overall structural-type enzyme is not observed until amphibians and still more recent vertebrates. Consequently, the class I/III duplicatory origin appears to have arisen from a functional class III form, not a class I form. Therefore, ethanol dehydrogenases from organisms existing before this duplication have origins separate from those leading to the "classical" liver alcohol dehydrogenases. The latter now often occur in isozyme forms from further gene duplications and have a high rate of evolutionary change. The pattern is, however, not simple and we presently find in cod the first evidence for isozymes also within a class III alcohol dehydrogenase. Overall, the results indicate that both of these classes of vertebrate alcohol dehydrogenase are important and suggest a protective metabolic function for the whole enzyme system.