Search

Gene expression profiling may provide leads for investigations of the molecular basis of functional declines associated with aging. In this study, high-density oligonucleotide arrays were used to probe the patterns of gene expression in skeletal muscle of seven young women (20-29 years old) and eight healthy older women (65-71 years old). The older subjects had reduced muscle mass, strength, and peak oxygen consumption relative to young women. There were approximately 1000 probe sets that suggested differential gene expression in younger and older muscle according to statistical criteria. The most highly overexpressed genes (>3-fold) in older muscle were p21 (cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor 1A), which might reflect increased DNA damage, perinatal myosin heavy chain, which might reflect increased muscle fiber regeneration, and tomoregulin, which does not have a defined function in muscle. More than 40 genes encoding proteins that bind to pre-mRNAs or mRNAs were expressed at higher levels in older muscle. More than 100 genes involved in energy metabolism were expressed at lower levels in older muscle. In general, these results support previous observations on the differences in gene expression profiles between younger and older men.

Studies of gene expression related to aging of skeletal muscle have included few subjects or a limited number of genes. We conducted the present study to produce more comprehensive gene expression profiles. RNA was extracted from vastus lateralis biopsies obtained from healthy young (21-27 yr old, n = 8) and older men (67-75 yr old, n = 8) and was analyzed with high-density oligonucleotide arrays. Of the approximately 44,000 probe sets on the arrays, approximately 18,000 yielded adequate signals for statistical analysis. There were approximately 700 probe sets for which t-tests or rank sum tests indicated a difference (P

Muscle concentrations of mRNAs encoded by mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) decline with aging. To determine whether this can be explained by diminished mtDNA levels, we measured the relative concentrations of mtDNA and a representative mtDNA transcript [encoding cytochrome-c oxidase, subunit 2 (COX-2)] in muscle of young (21-27 yr) and older subjects (65-75 yr). The amount of COX-2 mRNA (relative to 28S rRNA) was 22% lower (P = 0.04) in older muscle, and the amount of mtDNA (relative to nuclear DNA) was 38% lower (P = 0.0002). The average level of mitochondrial transcription factor A (Tfam), a protein essential for mtDNA replication, was similar in younger and older muscle. Tfam mRNA, nuclear respiratory factor-1 mRNA, and several mRNAs encoding proteins required for mtDNA replication were expressed at similar levels in younger and older muscle. The mtDNA concentrations were only weakly related to age-adjusted aerobic fitness (maximal oxygen consumption) and self-reported physical activity levels. We conclude that the lower concentration of mitochondrial mRNAs in older muscle can be explained by a reduced concentration of mtDNA.

The present study was done to determine the effect of age on muscle concentrations of mRNAs encoding two growth factors that are thought to be important regulators of muscle mass: insulin-like growth factor-1 (IGF-1) and myostatin. Quantitative RT-PCR assays indicated that the mean IGF-1 mRNA concentration in older muscle (62-77 yr, n=15 men) was approximately 25% less, per ng total RNA (P<0.005), than in young adult muscle (21-31 yr, n=12 men). One third of the older men had IGF-1 mRNA levels below the lowest concentration observed in young muscle. Myostatin mRNA concentrations were similar in young and old muscle. Muscle mass and myofibrillar protein synthesis rates among eight older men did not correlate with either IGF-1 or myostatin mRNA levels. We conclude that IGF-1 gene expression in muscle tends to decline with normal aging. The functional significance is uncertain.

Advances in biotechnology have led to methods for quantifying the relative concentrations of thousands of mRNAs in parallel. While these are powerful methods that can be used for both hypothesis testing and hypothesis generation, gene transcript profiling has some limitations as a tool to study aging. These include the difficulty in separating effects of aging from analytical and biological variability, statistical problems associated with simultaneous determination of so many different gene transcripts, and uncertainty about the functional significance of changes in mRNA concentrations. In this review, these issues are discussed with a focus on two methods for profiling mRNAs--serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) and DNA arrays.

Sarcopenia, the decline in muscle bulk and performance associated with normal aging, is an important component of frailty in the elderly. The gradual loss of both motor nerves and muscle fibers during senescence appears to be the major problem. Atrophy (especially in fast-twitch fibers) and impaired function of the surviving cells also contribute to sarcopenia. Although skeletal muscle has the capacity to regenerate itself, this process is not activated by the gradual age-related loss of muscle fibers. The endocrine, autocrine, and paracrine environment in old muscle is less supportive of protein synthesis, reinnervation of muscle fibers, and satellite cell activation, proliferation, and differentiation. Lifelong exposure of DNA to free radical damage results in accumulation of somatic mutations in nerves and muscle fibers. Reduced protein synthesis leads to atrophy, and slower fractional protein turnover contributes to longer retention of proteins that may have been damaged by free radicals. Many genes are differentially expressed in young and old muscle, but additional research is needed to determine which of these genes have a significant role in the pathogenesis or adaptation to sarcopenia.

A microarray study of the effect of senescence in mice on gene expression in muscle has been published recently. The present analysis was done to evaluate the extent to which the age-related differences in gene expression in murine muscle are also evident in human muscle. RNA extracted from muscle of young (21-24 yr) and old men (66-77 yr) was studied both by serial analysis of gene expression (SAGE) and by oligonucleotide microarrays. SAGE tags were detected for 61 genes homologous to genes reported to be differentially expressed in young and old murine muscle. The microarray had probe sets for 70 homologous genes. For 17 genes, there was evidence for a similar age-related change in expression in muscles of mice and men. For 32 other genes, there was evidence that the effect of age on the level of expression is not the same in mice and men. There was no evidence that older human muscle has increased expression of the stress response genes that are increased in old murine muscle.

Background: Previous research has shown that resistance training induces muscle hypertrophy in older subjects, but has not clarified whether the degree of hypertrophy is affected by age. The present study was done to test the hypothesis that men and women over 60 years old have a smaller hypertrophic response to resistance training than young adults., Methods: Cross-sectional areas (CSA) of muscle in the thigh and upper arm were determined before and after 3 months of progressive resistance training by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) in 9 young (22-31 yr, 5 male and 4 female) and 8 old (62-72 yr, 4 male and 4 female) subjects. Strength was determined by 3-repetition-maximum (3RM) testing. The amount of weight lifted during the training program was proportional to baseline strength., Results: Mean pretraining 3RM strength, per cm2 CSA, was less in the older group for all muscle groups examined (16 +/- 6% for elbow flexors, p < .02; 40 +/- 7% for knee flexors, p < .001; 19 +/- 9% for knee extensors, p < .05). Mean training-induced increases in muscle CSA were less in the older group for elbow flexors (22 +/- 4% in young, 9 +/- 4% in old, p < .05) and knee flexors (8 +/- 2% in young, 1 +/- 2% in old, p < .01), but not for knee extensors (4 +/- 1% in young, 6 +/- 2% in old). Mean training-induced increases in specific tension (ratio of 3RM strength to CSA) were similar in young and old groups for elbow flexors (21 +/- 5% in young, 19 +/- 5% in old) and knee extensors (38 +/- 6% in young, 32 +/- 14% in old), but were greater in the older group for knee flexors (28 +/- 5% in young, 64 +/- 13% in old, p < .02)., Conclusions: Aging can attenuate the hypertrophic response of muscle groups to resistance training, when the training load is proportional to baseline strength. However, aging does not impair training-induced increases in specific tension.

The rate of synthesis of myofibrillar proteins is slower in muscle of healthy subjects over 60 yr old than it is in young adults. Previous research suggests that reduced activity of the GH/insulin-like growth factor-I system could be a determinant of this slowing of protein synthesis. To test the hypothesis that GH could rejuvenate the rate of myofibrillar protein synthesis, we studied healthy subjects over 60 yr old, after a single injection (0.03 mg/kg.sc) of recombinant human GH (n = 6 males/2 females) or placebo (n = 6 males/2 females), or after 3 months of either GH (0.03 mg/kg, sc, 3 x /week, n = 5 males) or placebo (n = 5 males) treatment. Myofibrillar protein synthesis and whole-body protein metabolism were evaluated with the tracer L-[1-13C]leucine. GH reduced whole-body leucine oxidation by 36% (P < 0.01) in the single injection study. There was no effect of GH on whole-body protein breakdown or synthesis, or on myofibrillar protein synthesis in the quadriceps, either acutely or after 3 months of treatment. GH treatment for 3 months increased lean body mass (3.3 +/- 0.7 kg, P < 0.01, as evaluated by 40K counting), muscle mass (3.3 +/- 1.1 kg, P < 0.02, as evaluated by urinary creatinine excretion), and thigh strength (14 +/- 5%, P < 0.05, as evaluated by isokinetic dynamometry). We conclude that GH can increase muscle mass and strength in healthy men over 60 yr old, but does not restore a youthful rate of myofibrillar protein synthesis.

The myofibrillar protein synthesis rate in old human skeletal muscle is slower than that in young adult muscle. To examine whether this difference in protein synthesis rate is explained by reduced availability of the mRNAs that encode the most abundant myofibrillar proteins, we determined relative hybridization signals from probes for actin mRNA, myosin heavy chain mRNA, and total polyadenylated RNA in vastus lateralis muscle biopsies taken from young (22- to 31-yr-old) and old (61- to 74-yr-old) human subjects. The mean fractional rate of myofibrillar synthesis was 38% slower in the older muscles, as determined by incorporation of a stable isotope tracer. Total actin and myosin heavy chain mRNAs, and polyadenylated RNA, were determined using slot-blot assays. Isoform-specific determinations of alpha-actin mRNA, type I myosin heavy chain mRNA, and type IIa myosin heavy chain mRNA were done with ribonuclease protection assays. Hybridization signals were expressed relative to tissue DNA content. There was no difference between age groups in total polyadenylated RNA or in any of the specific mRNAs. We conclude that the slower myofibrillar synthesis rate in older muscle is not caused by reduced mRNA availability.

This study evaluated whether aging alters the usefulness of creatinine excretion as an index of lean body mass (LBM) or muscle mass in healthy men and women. Creatinine excretion was determined while 24 young (15 men and 9 women aged < 32 y) and 38 older (23 men and 15 women aged > 60 y) healthy volunteers stayed at a clinical research center for 3 d. Total LBM was determined by 40K counting in all subjects, and cross-sectional areas of upper arm and thigh muscles were determined in some subjects (10 young, 20 old) by magnetic resonance imaging. The slopes and intercepts of the regression equations relating LBM to average daily creatinine excretion were the same in the younger and older groups, and the precision with which LBM could be determined from creatinine excretion was not diminished by aging. Creatinine excretion was closely correlated with cross-sectional areas of upper arm (r = 0.85) and thigh (r = 0.88) muscles, and the slopes and intercepts of the regression equations were not significantly affected by age. The older group had a mean LBM smaller than that of the younger group, which was accounted for entirely by a smaller muscle mass. Mean resting metabolic rate (RMR), whole-body protein turnover rate, and thigh strength were lower in the older group than in the young group. Adjustment of RMR and protein turnover for creatinine excretion or LBM eliminated the age effects. Strength was lower in the older group even after adjustment for creatinine excretion or LBM. This study indicates that creatinine excretion is useful for evaluating body composition in both young and old subjects.

Muscle protein synthesis is slower in healthy older men and women than in young adults, but whether this results from relative disuse rather than aging is unclear. The present study was done to examine rates of myofibrillar protein synthesis before and after a 3-mo progressive resistance exercise program in young and old men and women. Protein synthesis was determined by incorporation of the tracer L-[1-13C]leucine into myofibrillar proteins obtained from the vastus lateralis muscle by needle biopsy. Before exercise, mean fractional myofibrillar synthesis was 33% slower (P < 0.01) in nine older subjects (62-72 yr old, 5 men and 4 women) than in 9 young subjects (22-31 yr old, 5 men and 4 women). Initial strength, as determined by three-repetition-maximum tests, was significantly less in the older group. Strength and training weights increased similarly in young and old groups, when expressed in relation to baseline values. Posttraining myofibrillar synthesis was determined on the day after the final training session. There was not a significant change in fractional myofibrillar synthesis in either the young or the old group after training, and the rate in the older group remained 27% slower (P < 0.05). Whole body protein turnover increased approximately 10% only in the younger group, and 24-h urinary 3-methylhistidine excretion (an index of myofibrillar proteolysis) was not significantly affected by training. These data suggest that the slower myofibrillar synthesis rate in older subjects cannot be explained by disuse.

Ragged red fibers are an important marker for mitochondrial disease. To evaluate the hypothesis that mitochondrial dysfunction may play a role in the pathogenesis of aging and inclusion body myositis, we studied the frequency of ragged red fibers in muscle biopsy specimens from 15 young and 13 old normal adults, and from 27 patients with inclusion body myositis, polymyositis, or dermatomyositis. Serial transverse cryostat sections were stained with modified Gomori trichrome, modified succinic dehydrogenase, and cytochrome c oxidase. The frequency of ragged red fibers, determined by measuring the percent number of succinic dehydrogenase-positive ragged red fiber equivalents, was significantly higher in old compared to young normal subjects (0.33 vs. 0.02%, p < 0.0001). With the exception of a single polymyositis biopsy specimen showing a large number of ragged red fibers, the frequency of ragged red fibers in patients with polymyositis or dermatomyositis was similar to that of age-matched normal control subjects. The frequency of ragged red fibers was more than 1% in 7 of 8 patients with inclusion body myositis (maximum, 15%). The modified succinic dehydrogenase stain was more sensitive than the modified Gomori trichrome in detecting accumulation of mitochondria in muscle fibers. Cytochrome c oxidase activity was deficient in most ragged red fibers. We conclude that the number of ragged red fibers increases with normal aging and may reflect an age-related decline in muscle mitochondrial oxidative metabolism. The frequent occurrence of ragged red fibers in inclusion body myositis suggests that mitochondrial function may be impaired in this disease.

Rates of incorporation of leucine (using L-[1-13C]leucine as a tracer) into myofibrillar and whole body proteins were determined in healthy old (> 60 yr old, n = 7) and young (< 30 yr old, n = 9) men and women who were fed small meals (4% of daily energy) every 30 min. There was no difference in whole body incorporation of leucine into proteins in the young (148 +/- 5 mumol.h-1.kg lean body mass-1, means +/- SE) and old groups (150 +/- 3 mumol.h-1.kg lean body mass-1). However, the fractional myofibrillar protein synthesis in the vastus lateralis muscle was 28% slower in the older group (0.063 +/- 0.004 vs. 0.088 +/- 0.003 %/h, P < 0.001). Extrapolation of these results to whole body myofibrillar synthesis (fractional rate x myofibrillar mass estimated by creatinine excretion) indicated that, in the older group, total myofibrillar synthesis was 43% slower (1.8 +/- 0.2 vs. 3.1 +/- 0.2 g/h, P < 0.01) and that their myofibrillar synthesis was a smaller portion of whole body protein synthesis (15 +/- 1 vs. 23 +/- 1%, P < 0.001). Compared with age-matched postabsorptive subjects, whole body protein synthesis was approximately 25% faster, and fractional myofibrillar synthesis was approximately 50% faster in these fed subjects, both young and old. We conclude that myofibrillar synthesis is slower in older subjects during both postabsorptive and postprandial conditions but that aging does not impair the stimulatory effect of feeding on protein synthesis.

We tested the hypothesis that healthy older men (> 60 yr old) have a slower rate of myofibrillar protein synthesis than young men (< 35 yr old). Myofibrillar protein synthesis was determined by the in vivo incorporation of L-[1-13C]leucine into myofibrillar proteins obtained by muscle biopsy. Subjects were eight young (21-31 yr) and eight older (62-81 yr) men, all healthy and moderately active. There was no significant difference in the mean height and weight of the two age groups, but the older group had 12% less lean body mass (determined by 40K counting) and 21% less muscle mass (estimated by urinary creatinine excretion). Upper leg strength was approximately one-third lower in the older subjects according to isokinetic dynamometry. The fractional rate of myofibrillar protein synthesis was 28% slower in the older group (0.039 +/- 0.009 vs. 0.054 +/- 0.010 %/h, mean +/- SD, P < 0.01). Total myofibrillar protein synthesis, estimated as total myofibrillar mass (from creatinine excretion) times the fractional synthesis rate, was 44% slower in the older group (1.4 vs. 2.5 g/h, P < 0.001). Whole body protein synthesis, assessed as the difference between leucine disappearance rate and leucine oxidation, was marginally slower (8%, P = 0.10) in the older group, but not when the data were adjusted for lean body mass. Myofibrillar protein synthesis was a smaller fraction of whole body protein synthesis in the older group (12 vs. 19%). Reduced myofibrillar protein synthesis may be an important mechanism of the muscle atrophy associated with aging.