Search

Context: Dominant activating mutations of the TSH receptor are the cause of familial nonautoimmune hyperthyroidism (FNAH) (inherited mutations affecting the whole gland since embryogenesis) and the majority of hyperfunctioning autonomous adenomas (AAs) (somatic mutations affecting only one cell later in the adulthood)., Objective: The objective of the study was defining the functional and molecular phenotypes of FNAH and comparing them with the ones of AA., Design: Functional phenotypes were determined in vitro and molecular phenotypes by hybridization on microarray slides., Patients: Nine patients with FNAH were investigated, six for functional in vitro study of the tissue and five for gene expression., Results: Iodide metabolism, H(2)O(2), cAMP, and inositol phosphate generation in FNAH slices stimulated or not with TSH were normal. The mitogenic response of cultured FNAH thyrocytes to TSH was normal but more sensitive to the hormone. Gene expression profiles of FNAH and AAs showed that among 474 genes significantly regulated in FNAH, 93% were similarly regulated in AAs. Besides, 783 genes were regulated only in AAs. Bioinformatic analysis pointed out common down-regulations of genes involved in immune response, cell/cell and cell/matrix adhesions, and apoptosis. Pathways up-regulated only in AAs mainly involve diverse biosyntheses. These results are consonant with the larger growth of AAs than FNAH tissues., Conclusions: Whether hereditary or somatic after birth, activating mutations of the TSH receptor have the same qualitative consequences on the thyroid cell phenotype, but somatic mutations in AAs have a much stronger effect than FNAH mutations. Both are variants of one disease: genetic hyperthyroidism.

The purpose of this study was to use the microarray technology to define expression profiles characteristic of thyroid autonomous adenomas and relate these findings to physiological mechanisms. Experiments were performed on a series of separated adenomas and their normal counterparts on Micromax cDNA microarrays covering 2400 genes (analysis I), and on a pool of adenomatous tissues and their corresponding normal counterparts using microarrays of 18,000 spots (analysis II). Results for genes present on the two arrays corroborated and several gene regulations previously determined by Northern blotting or microarrays in similar lesions were confirmed. Five overexpressed and 24 underexpressed genes were also confirmed by real-time RT-PCR in some of the samples used for microarray analysis, and in additional tumor specimens. Our results show: (1) a change in the cell populations of the tumor, with a marked decrease in lymphocytes and blood cells and an increase in endothelial cells. The latter increase would correspond to the establishment of a close relation between thyrocytes and endothelial cells and is related to increased N-cadherin expression. It explains the increased blood flow in the tumor; (2) a homogeneity of tumor samples correlating with their common physiopathological mechanism: the constitutive activation of the thyrotropin (TSH)/cAMP cascade; (3) a low proportion of regulated genes consistent with the concept of a minimal deviation tumor; (4) a higher expression of genes coding for specific functional proteins, consistent with the functional hyperactivity of the tumors; (5) an increase of phosphodiesterase gene expression which explains the relatively low cyclic AMP levels measured in these tumors; (6) an overexpression of antiapoptotic genes and underexpression of proapoptotic genes compatible with their low apoptosis rate; (7) an overexpression of N-cadherin and downregulation of caveolins, which casts doubt about the use of these expressions as markers for malignancy.

Objective: The cyclic AMP (cAMP) cascade is the main regulatory pathway in thyrocytes. Whilst activating mutations in the TSH receptor or in the Gs alpha-subunit, which increase cAMP levels, have been shown to be responsible for 80% of the autonomous adenomas, no such mutations have been observed in the other types of thyroid tumors, suggesting that other mechanisms exist. The discovery of Epac ('exchange nucleotide protein directly activated by cAMP'), a novel cAMP-binding protein, which is strongly expressed in the thyroid, raised the possibility of a role for this protein in the generation of the unexplained cold thyroid follicular adenomas. Thus, we investigated whether activating mutations in either Epac or Rap (the downstream target of Epac) could be responsible for the generation of these thyroid nodules., Design: Epac and Rap1 (Rap1A and Rap1B) cDNAs were sequenced in 10 patients. The sequencing of the cDNAs was realized on both strands in the cold nodule and the juxtanodular tissue of each patient., Results: No mutations in either Epac or Rap1 cDNAs were found. For five patients, a polymorphism in Epac at codon 332 (Gly--Ser) was observed., Conclusions: In this report, we show that the cAMP--Epac--Rap1 signaling pathway in the thyroid gland does not play a major role in the generation of cold thyroid follicular adenomas, since no mutations in either Epac or Rap1 could be observed in the 10 nodules studied.

Fifty-one in vivo characterized autonomous single adenomas have been studied for functional parameters in vitro, for gene and protein expression and for pathology, and have been systematically compared to the corresponding extratumoral quiescent tissue. The adenomas were characterized by a high level of iodide trapping that corresponds to a high level of Na+ /iodide symporter gene expression, a high thyroperoxidase mRNA and protein content, and a low H2O2 generation. This explains the iodide metabolism characteristics demonstrated before, ie, the main cause of the "hot" character of the adenomas is their increased iodide transport. The adenomas spontaneously secreted higher amounts of thyroid hormone than the quiescent tissue and in agreement with previous in vivo data, this secretion could be further enhanced by thyrotropin (TSH). Inositol uptake was also increased but there was no spontaneous increase of the generation of inositol phosphates and this metabolism could be further activated by TSH. These positive responses to TSH are in agreement with the properties of TSH-stimulated thyroid cells in vitro and in vivo. They are compatible with the characteristics of mutated TSH receptors whose constitutive activation accounts for the majority of autonomous thyroid adenomas in Europe. The number of cycling cells, as evaluated by MIB-1 immunolabeling was low but increased in comparison with the corresponding quiescent tissue or normal tissue. The cycling cells are observed mainly at the periphery; there was very little apoptosis. Both findings account for the slow growth of these established adenomas. On the other hand, by thyroperoxidase immunohistochemistry, the whole lesion appeared hyperfunctional, which demonstrates a dissociation of mitogenic and functional stimulations. Thyroglobulin, TSH receptor, and E-cadherin mRNA accumulations were not modified in a consistent way, which confirms the near-constitutive expression of the corresponding genes in normal differentiated tissue. On the contrary, early immediate genes expressions (c-myc, NGF1B, egr 1, genes of the fos and jun families) were decreased. This may be explained by the proliferative heterogeneity of the lesion and the previously described short, biphasic expression of these genes when induced by mitogenic agents. All the characteristics of the autonomous adenomas can therefore be explained by the effect of the known activating mutations of genes coding for proteins of the TSH cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) cascade, all cells being functionally activated while only those at the periphery multiply. The reason of this heterogeneity is unknown.

In somatic cells, telomeres shorten with population doubling, thus limiting their capacity to divide. Telomerase, which synthesizes telomeric repeats, can compensate for such shortening. Telomerase activity is known to be absent from most somatic differentiated cells but is present in germline cells, immortal cell lines, or a large majority of malignant tumors. Autonomous thyroid adenomas are benign tumors composed of highly differentiated cells characterized by TSH-independent function and growth. Telomere length and telomerase activity were measured in autonomous and hypofunctioning adenomas and their surrounding tissues. A significant decrease of 3.8+/-1.0 kilobases (kb) was observed in the length of the terminal restriction fragments (TRF) in 12 autonomous adenomas (8.6+/-1.1 kb), compared with the TRF length of their surrounding tissues (12.4+/-1.6 kb). The same kind of decrease, 3.5+/-1.2 kb, was also observed in 16 hypofunctioning adenomas (12.3+/-1.7 kb in surrounding tissue and 8.8+/-1.6 kb in the adenomas). No telomerase activity was detected either in the 12 autonomous adenomas studied or in most of the quiescent tissues (10 of 12). Most of the hypofunctioning adenomas tested (15 of 16) did not display telomerase activity. These results suggest that the cells have undergone a higher number of cell divisions in the adenomas than in the surrounding tissue. Moreover, there is a larger spread of the TRF length distribution in autonomous adenomas than in the collateral tissue. This could reflect the heterogeneity in proliferation status of the cells in the nodule, some of which have reached the end of their life span, whereas others are still proliferating (but with no malignant potential for the autonomous adenomas). In conclusion, benign adenomas exhibit a shorter and more variable telomere length than the normal collateral quiescent tissue, with no telomerase activity to compensate this loss in telomere length.

A total of 33 different autonomous hot nodules from 31 patients, originating mainly from Belgium, were investigated for the presence of somatic mutations in the TSH receptor and Gs alpha genes. This constitutes an extension of our previous study, including the first 11 nodules of the series. The complete coding sequence of the TSH receptor gene and the segments of Gs alpha known to harbor mutations impairing guanosinetriphosphotase activity were studied by direct sequencing of genomic DNA extracted from the nodules. DNA from the juxtanodular tissue or peripheral white blood cells was analyzed in all patients to confirm that the mutations identified were somatic. Twenty-seven mutations (82%) were found in the TSH receptor gene, affecting a total of 12 different residues or locations. All these mutations but 2 (see below) have been identified previously as activating mutations. Only 2 mutations were found in Gs alpha (6%). In 4 nodules, no mutation was detected. Five residues (Ser281, Ile486, Ile568, Phe631, and Asp633) were found mutated in 3 or 4 different nodules, making them hot spots for activating mutations. Phe631 and Asp633 belong to a cluster of 5 consecutive residues (629-633) in the N-terminal half of transmembrane segment VI; which harbor together 44% of the mutations identified in this cohort. Two novel mutations were identified: a point mutation causing substitution of Phe for Leu at position 629 (L629F); and a deletion of 12 bases removing residues 658-661 at the C-terminal portion of exoloop 3 (del658-661). When tested by transfection in COS-7 cells, both mutant receptors display increase in constitutive stimulation of basal cAMP accumulation. Although it is still capable of binding TSH, the del658-661 mutant has completely lost the ability to respond to the stimulation by the hormone. Our results demonstrate that, in a cohort of patients from a moderately iodine deficient area, somatic mutations increasing the constitutive activity of the TSH receptor are the major cause of autonomous hot nodules.

A series of somatic mutations of the TSH receptor gene have been demonstrated in hyperfunctioning thyroid adenomas. The mutations studied up to now cause constitutive (i.e. TSH-independent) activation of the cAMP-regulatory cascade only. As a follow-up to our original study, we have now completely sequenced exon number 10 of the TSH receptor gene in the same series of toxic adenomas. An activating mutation was found in nine of 11 tumors. In addition to the mutations already described, two isoleucine residues belonging to the first and second extracellular loops of the receptor (Ile486 and Ile568) were found mutated. Two different adenomas were found to harbor a different amino acid substitution at residue 486 (Ile486Phe, Ile486Met). Ile568 was mutated to threonine in one. When studied by transfection in COS-7 cells, all three mutations caused very strong activation of the cAMP-regulatory cascade. In addition, the Ile486Phe and, to a lesser extent, the Ile486Met and Ile568Thr mutants stimulated constitutively the inositol phosphate-diacylglycerol cascade. Our results demonstrate that 1) the first and second extracellular loops contribute to the silencing of the unliganded TSH receptor; 2) the two regulatory cascades normally under TSH control can be constitutively activated by somatic mutations of the receptor; 3) the TSH receptor can be activated by mutation of a large number of residues distributed over the first and second extracellular loops, the third intracellular loop, and the third, sixth, and seventh transmembrane segments; 4) activating mutations of the TSH receptor constitute the major cause of toxic adenomas, accounting for about 80% of the cases.

It has recently been shown that somatic and germ line mutations of the TSH receptor gene cause autonomous hyperfunctioning thyroid adenomas and nonautoimmune toxic thyroid hyperplasia by constitutive activation of the TSH receptor. A "saturated" map of these mutations is a prerequisite for a systematic screening for these clinically important mutations. In this context, it is also of interest to determine whether different amino acid substitutions at the same residue cause constitutive activation of the TSH receptor, as suggested by site-directed mutagenesis of the alpha 1 beta-adrenergic receptor. We, therefore, screened further hyperfunctioning autonomous adenomas of the thyroid for constitutively activating mutations. We identified two new somatic mutations, changing alanine in position 623 to valine (A623V) and threonine in position 632 to isoleucine (T632I). Both mutations constitutively activated cAMP when transiently expressed in COS cells. Together with neighboring mutations, the T632I mutation demonstrates the importance of transmembrane domain VI for the activation of the TSH receptor and characterizes it as a hot spot for constitutively activating mutations. The previously identified A623I and the newly identified A623V mutations demonstrate that several amino acid substitutions at the same residue can cause constitutive activation of the TSH receptor.

The pituitary hormone thyrotropin stimulates the function, expression of differentiation and growth of thyrocytes by cyclic AMP-dependent mechanisms. Tissue hyperplasia and hyperthyroidism are therefore expected to result when activation of the adenylyl cyclase-cAMP cascade is unregulated. This is observed in several situations, including when somatic mutations impair the GTPase activity of the G protein Gsa (ref 6, 7). Such a mechanism is probably responsible for the development of a minority of monoclonal hyperfunctioning thyroid adenomas. Here we identify somatic mutations in the carboxy-terminal portion of the third cytoplasmic loop of the thyrotropin receptor in three out of eleven hyperfunctioning thyroid adenomas. These mutations are restricted to tumour tissue and involve two different residues (aspartic acid at position 619 to glycine in two cases, and alanine at position 623 to isoleucine in one case). The mutant receptors confer constitutive activation of adenylyl cyclase when tested by transfection in COS cells. This shows that G-protein-coupled receptors are susceptible to constitutive activation by spontaneous somatic mutations and may thus behave as proto-oncogenes.

A follicular adenoma of the thyroid was 'hot' one hour after 99mTc pertechnetate administration, but 'cold' 24 h after 131I iodide administration. Incubation of the tissue in vitro demonstrated a defect in iodide binding to proteins that was abolished by addition of an H2O2 generating system. In this tissue iodide failed to inhibit TSH-induced cyclic AMP accumulation. The results show that iodide oxidation is required for its inhibitory action on cyclic AMP accumulation in human thyroid.

We have investigated the regulation of the human throid gland based on controls discovered in the dog thyroid gland. TSH and thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulin enhanced cAMP accumulation, which supports the validity of the Sutherland model for the action of TSH on the human thyroid. Iodide inhibited TSH- and thyroid-stimulating immunoglobulin-activated cAMP accumulation and this effect was reduced by methimazole, showing that, in this tissue, iodide, through an oxidized derivative, depresses the TSH-cAMP system. Contrary to the hypothesis of a short feedback loop of thyroid hormone, no thyroid effect of T3 or T4 was found. Adrenergic agents (norepinephrine and isoproterenol) enhanced cAMP accumulation; this effect was inhibited by dl-propranolol but not by d-propranolol or phentolamine. This suggests a positive control of the thyroid cAMP system by beta-adrenergic receptors. Histamine also increased cAMP accumulation. However, the role of these controls is unknown. Acetylcholine, by a muscarinic type effect, enhanced cGMP accumulation and prostaglandin E2 and prostaglandin F2 alpha release. These effects were mimicked by ionophore A23187 and abolished in a calcium-deprived medium, which suggests that they are secondary to a raised Ca++ influx. The results are summarized in a general working model of human thyroid regulation. These biochemical controls have been compared in normal tissue and autonomous nodules. No evidence of increased sensitivity to TSH of the nodular tissue was found. On the other hand, this tissue was less sensitive to acetylcholine (cGMP accumulation) and more sensitive to norepinephrine (cAMP accumulation).

Focuses on somatic and germline mutations of the TSH receptor and thyroid diseases. Proposed scheme for the evolution of radionuclide thyroid scans and thyroid hormone secretion in autonomous adenoma; Summary of known loss-of-function mutations of the TSH receptor gene with the extent of their effects on intracellular function and references.