1. Consent for Genetics Studies Among Clinical Trial Participants: Findings from Action for Health in Diabetes (Look AHEAD)
- Author
-
W. Jack Rejeski, Deborah F. Tate, Ray Carvajal, Renee Davenport, Shandiin Begay, Peter B. Jones, Roque M. Murillo, Laurie Bissett, Valerie Goldman, Maria G. Montez, Karen C. Johnson, Lynne E. Wagenknecht, Ann V. Schwartz, Alain G. Bertoni, Sharon D. Jackson, Virginia Harlan, Jeffrey M. Curtis, E. S. Kahn, Paula Bolin, K. Dotson, Erica Ferguson, Abbas E. Kitabchi, Donald A. Williamson, Elizabeth Bovaird, Renee Bright, Patricia E. Hogan, Barbara Bancroft, Richard S. Crow, Elizabeth Tucker, Maureen Malloy, Kathy Lane, Tricia Skarphol, Julie Currin, Anne E. Mathews, Linda M. Delahanty, Jennifer Gauvin, Mara Z. Vitolins, Theresa Michel, Shiriki K. Kumanyika, Mark A. Espeland, Jennifer Rush, Kristina P. Schumann, Anna Bertorelli, Allison Strate, Denise G. Simons-Morton, David E. Kelley, Carrie Combs, Nita Webb, Eva Obarzanek, Wei Lang, Rebecca S. Reeves, M. Patricia Snyder, Douglas A. Raynor, Susan Green, Robert Kuehnel, Richard Ginsburg, John P. Bantle, Gary D. Miller, L. Christie Oden, Richard Carey, Sarah Michaels, Rebecca Danchenko, Linda Foss, Gary D. Foster, Caitlin Egan, Jeanne Carls, Brenda Montgomery, Carlos Lorenzo, Lori Lambert, Medhat Botrous, Sarah Bain, Minnie Roanhorse, Heather McCormick, Michael T. McDermott, Edward W. Lipkin, Jane Tavares, Jason Maeda, Kathryn Hayward, Ann Goebel-Fabbri, Ann McNamara, Sandra Sangster, Cathy Roche, Cecilia Farach, David M. Nathan, Cathy Manus, Donna Wolf, William H. Herman, Paulette Cohrs, Patricia Lipschutz, P. J. Foreyt, Kara I. Gallagher, Thomas A. Wadden, Ronald J. Prineas, Kristi Rau, Tina Killean, Kerrin Brelje, Jennifer Perault, Justin Glass, George L. Blackburn, Edward W. Gregg, Anthony N. Fabricatore, Charles Campbell, Vicki A. Maddy, Steven E. Kahn, Emily A. Finch, Janet Bonk, Lauren Lessard, C. W. Knowler, M. Montez, Barbara Harrison, Barbara J. Maschak-Carey, Stephen P. Glasser, Molly Gee, Brandi Armand, Tatum Charron, Kristin Wallace, Jennifer Patricio, John A. Shepherd, Monica Mullen, Robert H. Knopp, Heather Chenot, Connie Mobley, Richard R. Rubin, Elizabeth J. Mayer-Davis, David M. Reboussin, Judith G. Regensteiner, Bernadette Todacheenie, Alan McNamara, Amelia Hodges, Mary Anne Holowaty, S. M. Haffner, Robert S. Schwartz, Paul M. Ribisl, B. Montgomery, Carol Percy, B. D. W. Harrison, Mohammed F. Saad, Frank L. Greenway, Osama Hamdy, Van S. Hubbard, Dace L. Trence, Magpuri Perpetua, Mandy Shipp, Sharon Hall, Kim Landry, William C. Knowler, Christian Speas, Louise Hesson, Ruby Johnson, Deborah Maier, David F. Williamson, Deborah Robles, Zhu Ming Zhang, Janelia Smiley, Jennifer Mayer, Henry J. Pownall, Andrea M. Kriska, A. S. Jaramillo, Nancy Scurlock, Vicki DiLillo, Karen T. Vujevich, S. Terry Barrett, James O. Hill, Amy Dobelstein, Clara Smith, Heather Turgeon, Sarah Ledbury, Kathy Dotson, JoAnn A. Phillipp, Carmen Pal, A. Enrique Caballero, Natalie Robinson, Jonathan Krakoff, Debi Celnik, Sheikilya Thomas, J. P. Massaro, Mary Lou Klem, Ellen J. Anderson, Amy A. Gorin, Stanley Schwartz, Jeanne M. Clark, Enrico Cagliero, Leigh A. Shovestull, Didas Fallis, Siran Ghazarian, Lawton S. Cooper, Kathy Horak, Pamela Coward, Carolyn Thorson, Diane Hirsch, Robert I. Berkowitz, Stanley Heshka, Matthew L. Maciejewski, Salma Benchekroun, Erin Patterson, Rita Donaldson, La Donna James, Tina Morgan, Robert W. Jeffery, Monika M. Safford, John P. Foreyt, Xavier Pi-Sunyer, Barbara Steiner, Michelle Chan, Leeann Carmichael, Barb Elnyczky, Charlotte Bragg, Delia S. West, Jacqueline Wesche-Thobaben, Canice E. Crerand, Lisa Palermo, Tammy Monk, Amy Keranen, April Hamilton, Patrick Reddin, Helen Chomentowski, Peter H. Bennett, Kati Szamos, Cynthia Hayashi, Kerry J. Stewart, Kerry Ovalle, Judy Bahnson, Pat Harper, John M. Jakicic, Janet Krulia, J. Bruce Redmon, Vincent Pera, Michaela Rahorst, Trena Johnsey, Maureen Daly, Susan Z. Yanovski, George A. Bray, Lindsey Munkwitz, Birgitta I. Rice, Edward S. Horton, Lawrence J. Cheskin, Daniel Edmundowicz, Marsha Miller, Therese Ockenden, Rena R. Wing, Christos S. Mantzoros, Santica M. Marcovina, Greg Strylewicz, Carolyne Campbell, Ken C. Chiu, Cora E. Lewis, Richard F. Hamman, Staci Gilbert, Don Kieffer, Frederick L. Brancati, Brent VanDorsten, Lynne Lichtermann, Juliet Mancino, Jeanne Charleston, Helen Lambeth, Suzanne Phelan, Cara Walcheck, Kimberley Chula-Maguire, Michael C. Nevitt, Donna H. Ryan, Hollie A. Raynor, Lewis H. Kuller, Ashok Balasubramanyam, Rob Nicholson, and Loretta Rome
- Subjects
Research design ,Male ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Genetic Research ,Alternative medicine ,Type 2 diabetes ,01 natural sciences ,Article ,Ethics, Research ,010104 statistics & probability ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Patient Education as Topic ,Weight loss ,Informed consent ,Medicine ,Humans ,Multicenter Studies as Topic ,030212 general & internal medicine ,0101 mathematics ,Aged ,Pharmacology ,Genetics ,Research ethics ,Clinical Trials as Topic ,Informed Consent ,business.industry ,General Medicine ,Middle Aged ,medicine.disease ,humanities ,Clinical trial ,Diabetes Mellitus, Type 2 ,Research Design ,Female ,medicine.symptom ,business ,Risk Reduction Behavior ,Cohort study ,Ethics Committees, Research - Abstract
Background Increasingly, genetic specimens are collected to expand the value of clinical trials through study of genetic effects on disease incidence, progression or response to interventions. Purpose and methods We describe the experience obtaining IRB-approved DNA consent forms across the 19 institutions in the Action for Health in Diabetes (Look AHEAD), a clinical trial examining the effect of a lifestyle intervention for weight loss on the risk of serious cardiovascular events among individuals with type 2 diabetes. We document the rates participants provided consent for DNA research, identify participant characteristics associated with consent, and discuss implications for genetics research. Results IRB approval to participate was obtained from 17 of 19 institutions. The overall rate of consent was 89.6% among the 15 institutions that had completed consenting at the time of our analysis, which was higher than reported for other types of cohort studies. Consent rates were associated with factors expected to be associated with weight loss and cardiovascular disease and to affect the distribution of candidate genes. Non-consent occurred more frequently among participants grouped as African-American, Hispanic, female, more highly educated or not dyslipidemic. Limitations The generalizabilty of results is limited by the inclusion/exclusion criteria of the trial. Conclusions Barriers to obtaining consent to participate in genetic studies may differ from other recruitment settings. Because of the potentially complex associations between personal characteristics related to adherence, outcomes and gene distributions, differential rates of consent may introduce biases in estimates of genetic relationships.
- Published
- 2006