1. Remediating Cambridge: Human and Horse Co-Relationality in a Culture of Mis-Re-Presentation.
- Author
-
Brady, Francesca A. and McDonell, Jennifer
- Subjects
- *
ANIMAL welfare , *FEMINIST ethics , *ELECTRONIC newspapers , *INTERSECTIONALITY , *AGENT (Philosophy) - Abstract
Simple Summary: The medical treatment of Cambridge, an Anglo-Arab stallion, was misrepresented in the Australian media. His carers were trolled on the Cyberhorse website in Victoria, Australia, in the 1990s. Emotive misrepresentations, some anonymous, led to public misogynistic and racist labelling of his owners as 'wogs' and witches. Other misrepresentations maligned the reputation of the vets and farrier (blacksmith) who treated Cambridge and led the Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (RSPCA) to publicly doubt the expertise of the practicing equine veterinarian and consulting specialist. Real-world harm was caused and claims based on media representations were investigated by the Veterinary Practitioners Registration Board of Victoria. The Victorian Supreme Court passed an injunction to restrain the Executive Officer, or any RSPCA inspector, from 'killing, touching, or otherwise interfering' with Cambridge. Another writ was obtained preventing the Werribee Park Equestrian Centre (WPEC) from forcibly moving Cambridge or his companion horses while Cambridge was undergoing veterinary treatment for laminitis. The Centre stopped advising Cambridge's carers of changes to his environment that would adversely affect him, yet transporting Cambridge elsewhere would have been a death sentence. Media reportage of Cambridge's welfare and treatment failed to consider the co-relationality that distinguished his treatment, or accord the horse agency in this process. Throughout, Cambridge proved an exceptional horse and patient, exhibiting what appeared to be agential adaptations to circumstances and his overall health and wellbeing. Cambridge's story urges us to consider that when making decisions about the lives of animals we should not make decisions for them, but with them. This case study aims to problematise concepts of equine and human co-relational agency in the context of 'mis-re-presentations' in the Australian media of harms experienced by the Anglo Arab stallion, Cambridge, following his development of laminitis and his consequent confinement at a leading national Equestrian centre. Autoethnographic narrative is used to retrospectively and selectively narrate the evolving relationship between Cambridge and his owners, farrier, and treating veterinarians within the dominant housing and veterinary practices and welfare paradigms in equestrian culture of 1990's Australia. Structured author/owner autoethnographic vignettes are framed by newspaper and internet reportage to highlight a productive tension between the public mediation of the case, and what it means to be fully embodied in relationship with an equine companion agent within a particular, racialised, gendered, and biopoliticised location. Adopting a phenomenologically informed intersectional feminist ethics of care perspective, a counternarrative to the gendered, racialised and essentialising rights-based judgements about Cambridge's illness and eventual death that dominated the popular media is provided. Crucially, the autoethnographic vignettes are chosen to capture the corporeal reciprocity and rapport of forces that produced a co-created agentivity that characterised the horse's birth, training, and treatment. The embodied interspecies knowledge that informs the training and care of equines (and all animal species) is always historically situated within permeable, dynamic worlds of self and other that are fluid, contextual, and always in relation. It is suggested that the case of Cambridge illustrates how competing stakeholder investments in animal welfare can play out in the public mediation of particular cases in ways that exclude their historical and interspecies situatedness and serve to reinforce dominant ideologies governing human and animal relationships. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2025
- Full Text
- View/download PDF