1. Comparison of HPV-positive triage strategies combining extended genotyping with cytology or p16/ki67 dual staining in the Italian NTCC2 studyResearch in context
- Author
-
Maria Benevolo, Guglielmo Ronco, Pamela Mancuso, Francesca Carozzi, Laura De Marco, Elena Allia, Simonetta Bisanzi, Raffaella Rizzolo, Daniela Gustinucci, Annarosa Del Mistro, Helena Frayle, Massimo Confortini, Jessica Viti, Anna Iossa, Elena Cesarini, Simonetta Bulletti, Basilio Passamonti, Silvia Gori, Laura Toniolo, Laura Bonvicini, Francesco Venturelli, Nicolas Wentzensen, Paolo Giorgi Rossi, Alessandra Barca, Francesco Quadrino, Francesca Rollo, Gabriele Carlinfante, Teresa Rubino, Francesca Maria Carozzi, Cristina Sani, Andrea Baldini, Giampaolo Pompeo, Alessandra Mongia, Giulia Fantacci, Donella Puliti, Carmelina Di Pierro, Luigia Macrì, Teresa Pusiol, Mattia Barbareschi, Emma Bragantini, Gabriella Penon, Natalina Marchi, Manuel Zorzi, Elena Narne, and Anna Turrin
- Subjects
Human papillomavirus ,HPV genotyping ,Cervical cancer screening ,Triage ,HPV DNA testing ,Accuracy ,Medicine ,Medicine (General) ,R5-920 - Abstract
Summary: Background: Each high-risk HPV genotype has different oncogenic potential, and the risk of CIN3+ varies according to genotype. We evaluated the performance of different strategies of HPV-positivity triage combining cytology, p16/ki67 dual staining (DS), and extended genotyping. Methods: Samples from 3180 consecutive women from the NTCC2 study (NCT01837693) positive for HPV DNA at primary screening, were retrospectively analyzed by the BD Onclarity HPV Assay, which allows extended genotyping. Genotypes were divided into three groups based on the risk of CIN3+. HPV DNA-positive women were followed up for 24 months or to clearance. Findings: Combining the three groups of genotypes with cytology or DS results we identify a group of women who need immediate colposcopy (PPV for CIN3+ from 7.8 to 20.1%), a group that can be referred to 1-year HPV retesting (PPV in those HPV-positive at retesting from 2.2 to 3.8), and a group with a very low 24-month CIN3+ risk, i.e. 0.4%, composed by women cytology or DS negative and positive for HPV 56/59/66 or 35/39/68 or negative with the Onclarity test, who can be referred to 3-year retesting. Interpretation: Among the baseline HPV DNA positive/cytology or DS negative women, the extended genotyping allows to stratify for risk of CIN3+, and to identify a group of women with a risk of CIN3+ so low in the next 24 months that they could be referred to a new screening round after 3 years. Funding: Italian Ministry of Health (grant number RF-2009-1536040). Hologic-Genprobe, Roche Diagnostics, and Becton & Dickinson provided financial and non-financial support.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF