1. A urgência da mitigação da publicidade na união estável homoafetiva: direito fundamental à privacidade e os precedentes do Tribunal de Justiça paulista.
- Author
-
Ghilardi, Dóris and Bellussi, Mariana Carvalho
- Subjects
- *
SAME-sex marriage , *RIGHT of privacy , *LEGAL judgments , *CIVIL rights , *OBEDIENCE (Law) , *LGBTQ+ rights , *SAME-sex relationships , *GAY couples - Abstract
The Brazilian Supreme Court rulings on the Arguição de Descumprimento de preceito fundamental (ADPF) n° 132 and the Ação Direta de Inconstitucionalidade (ADI) n° 4277 created the precedents responsible for the recognition of same-sex civil unions in Brazil, a breakthrough in the history of LGBT rights. However, with the legal obligation to meet the same requirements demanded for heterosexual civil unions, homosexual unions face a barrier: the need to prove the relationship's publicity. In fact, the requirement of notoriety, when applied by courts in cases where the bonds are not externalized due to fear of homophobic practices isn't adequate. Furthermore, this requirement must be pondered in order to ensure the fundamental right to privacy, as provided in the Constitution. In conclusion, the flexibilization of the legal requirement of publicity does not always occur in Brazilian courts and, when applied, it's not enough to ensure the recognition of homo-affective civil unions. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF