Search

Among passive microwave frequencies, sensors operating at C- and X-band frequencies have been used with some success to estimate near-surface soil moisture from aircraft and satellite platforms. The objective of this paper is to quantify the sensitivities of soil moisture retrieved via a single-channel single-polarization algorithm to the observed brightness temperature and to retrieval algorithm parameters of surface roughness, vegetation B parameter, and single-scattering albedo. Examination of the regions within the parameter space that produce accurate soil moisture retrievals reveals that reasonably accurate retrievals can be made over a range of conditions using a fixed set of input parameters. Retrievals with horizontally polarized brightness temperature observations are more consistent than with vertically polarized observations. At horizontal polarization, sensitivity to the input parameters is much greater for wet soils than for dry soils, whereas for vertical polarization the moisture dependence is much weaker. At vertical polarization, sensitivities to variations in all parameters are much lower. To ensure that retrieval accuracy specifications are consistently met, high soil moisture conditions should be used in defining parameter accuracy requirements. Given the spatial and temporal variability of vegetation and soil conditions, it seems unlikely that, for regions with substantial rapidly growing vegetation, the accuracy requirements for model parameters in a single-frequency, single-polarization retrieval algorithm can be met with current satellite products. For such conditions, any soil moisture retrieval algorithm using parameterizations similar to those of this study may require multiple frequencies, polarizations, or look angles to produce stable, reliable soil moisture estimates. Index Terms--Microwave radiometry, parameter space methods, sensitivity, Soil Moisture Experiments in 2002 (SMEX02), soil moisture, vegetation.

Over the past two decades, successful estimation of soil moisture has been accomplished using L-band microwave radiometer data. However, remaining uncertainties related to surface roughness and the absorption, scattering, and emission by vegetation must be resolved before soil moisture retrieval algorithms can be applied with known and acceptable accuracy using satellite observations. Surface characteristics are highly variable in space and time, and there has been little effort made to determine the parameter estimation accuracies required to meet a given soil moisture retrieval accuracy specification. This study quantifies the sensitivities of soil moisture retrieved using an L-band single-polarization algorithm to three land surface parameters for corn and soybean sites in Iowa, United States. Model sensitivity to the input parameters was found to be much greater when soil moisture is high. For even moderately wet soils, extremely high sensitivity of retrieved soil moisture to some model parameters for corn and soybeans caused the retrievals to be unstable. Parameter accuracies required for consistent estimation of soil moisture in mixed agricultural areas within retrieval algorithm specifications are estimated. Given the spatial and temporal variability of vegetation and soil conditions for agricultural regions it seems unlikely that, for the single-frequency, single-polarization retrieval algorithm used in this analysis, the parameter accuracy requirements can be met with current satellite-based land surface products. We conclude that for regions with substantial vegetation, particularly where the vegetation is changing rapidly, any soil moisture retrieval algorithm that is based on the physics and parameterizations used in this study will require multiple frequencies, polarizations, or look angles to produce stable, reliable soil moisture estimates. Index Terms--Microwave radiometry, parameter space methods, sensitivity, soil moisture, vegetation.