Search

The factors controlling epitope selection in the T cell response to persistent viruses are not fully understood, and we have examined this issue in the context of four HLA-B*35-binding peptides from the pp65 antigen of human cytomegalovirus, two of which are previously undescribed. Striking differences in the hierarchy of immunodominance between these four epitopes were observed in healthy virus carriers expressing HLA-B*3501 versus B*3508, two HLA-B allotypes that differ by a single amino acid at position 156 (HLA-B*3501, (156)Leucine; HLA-B*3508, (156)Arginine) that projects from the alpha2 helix into the centre of the peptide-binding groove. While HLA-B*3501(+) individuals responded most strongly to the (123)IPSINVHHY(131) and (366)HPTFTSQY(373) epitopes, HLA-B*3508(+) individuals responded preferentially to (103)CPSQEPMSIYVY(114) and (188)FPTKDVAL(195). By comparing peptide-MHC association and disassociation rates with peptide immunogenicity, it was clear that dissociation rates correlate more closely with the hierarchy of immunodominance among the four pp65 peptides. These findings demonstrate that MHC micropolymorphism at positions outside the primary anchor residue binding pockets can have a major impact on determinant selection in antiviral T cell responses. Such influences may provide the evolutionary pressure that maintains closely related MHC molecules in diverse human populations.

The BZLF1 antigen of Epstein-Barr virus includes three overlapping sequences of different lengths that conform to the binding motif of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) B*3501. These 9-mer (56LPQGQLTAY64), 11-mer (54EPLPQGQLTAY64), and 13-mer (52LPEPLPQGQLTAY64) peptides all bound well to B*3501; however, the CTL response in individuals expressing this HLA allele was directed strongly and exclusively towards the 11-mer peptide. In contrast, EBV-exposed donors expressing HLA B*3503 showed no significant CTL response to these peptides because the single amino acid difference between B*3501 and B*3503 within the F pocket inhibited HLA binding by these peptides. The extraordinarily long 13-mer peptide was the target for the CTL response in individuals expressing B*3508, which differs from B*3501 at a single position within the D pocket (B*3501, 156Leucine; B*3508, 156Arginine). This minor difference was shown to enhance binding of the 13-mer peptide, presumably through a stabilizing interaction between the negatively charged glutamate at position 3 of the peptide and the positively charged arginine at HLA position 156. The 13-mer epitope defined in this study represents the longest class I-binding viral epitope identified to date as a minimal determinant. Furthermore, the potency of the response indicates that peptides of this length do not present a major structural barrier to CTL recognition., (Copyright 2004 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co.)

Fine specificity analysis of HLA B35-restricted Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones revealed a unique heterogeneity whereby one group of these clones cross-recognized an EBV epitope (YPLHEQHGM) on virus-infected cells expressing either HLA B*3501 or HLA B*3503, while another group cross-recognized this epitope in association with either HLA B*3502 or HLA B*3503. Peptide binding and titration studies ruled out the possibility that these differences were due to variation in the efficiency of peptide presentation by the HLA B35 alleles. Sequence analysis of the TCR genetic elements showed that these clonotypes either expressed BV12/AV3 or BV14/ADV17S1 heterodimers. Interestingly, CTL analysis with monosubstituted alanine mutants of the YPLHEQHGM epitope indicated that the BV12/AV3+ clones preferentially recognized residues towards the C terminus of the peptide, while the BV14/ADV17S1+ clones interacted with residues towards N terminus of the peptide. Molecular modelling of the MHC-peptide complexes suggests that the differences in two floor positions (114 and 116) of the HLA B35 alleles dictate different conformations of the peptide residues L3 and/or H7 and directly contribute in the discerning allele-specific immune recognition by the CTL clonotypes. These results provide evidence for a critical role for the selective interaction of the TCR with specific residues within the peptide epitope in the fine specificity of CTL recognition of allelic variants of an HLA molecule.

Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) nuclear antigen 1 (EBNA1) and latent membrane proteins (LMP) are the only antigens consistently expressed in malignancies such as nasopharyngeal carcinoma (NPC) and Hodgkin's disease (HD). Since EBNA1 is not recognized by EBV-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL), there is increasing interest in the identification of the potential target epitopes within LMP1. Although LMP1-specific CTL have been isolated from seropositive individuals, earlier attempts to identify the peptide epitopes recognized by these T cells have been unsuccessful. In the present report we used a novel protocol to identify CTL epitopes within LMP1 which can be recognized by both polyclonal and clonal CTL. Firstly, a computer-based program was employed to identify the potential HLA-binding peptides within LMP1. Polyclonal CD8+ CTL were then isolated from seropositive donors that recognized the peptide epitopes YLLEMLWRL and YLQQNWWTL from LMP1 in association with HLA A2. Limiting dilution analysis of the memory CTL response revealed that the LMP1-specific CTL response constitutes a minor component of the CTL response in healthy virus carriers. Interestingly, analysis of YLLEMLWRL-specific CTL revealed that these CTL were able to lyse EBV-infected B cells expressing different HLA A2 supertype alleles including A*0201, A*0202, A*0203, A*0204, A*0206, A*6802 and A*6901. These data strongly support the notion that HLA class I supertype-restricted CTL may be of significant use in the development of peptide-based immunotherapeutics against EBV-associated malignancies in different ethnic populations.

In the present report, cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clones are described that display dual specificity for one of two common human leukocyte antigens (HLA B14 or B35) as alloantigens, and an immunodominant epitope (FLRGRAYGL) from Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) that binds to HLA B8. These T cell clonotypes were isolated from several unrelated HLA B8+, EBV-exposed individuals, and each distinct cross-reactivity pattern was associated with a common, public T cell receptor (TCR). In some individuals, CTL cross-reactive with these alloantigens completely dominated the memory response to this EBV epitope. Moreover, these memory T cells to EBV could be reactivated as a significant component of the repertoire of CTL responding to allogeneic stimulator cells expressing either HLA B14 or B35. These data illustrate how a history of infection with an immunogenic virus such as EBV can augment responsiveness to particular alloantigens; such influences may underlie the observed clinical association between herpesvirus infection and both allograft rejection and graft-versus-host disease. We have also explored the molecular basis for T cell cross-reactivity with alloantigens using the HLA B35 allo-reactive CTL clonotype. To elucidate the structural features of peptides that may be cross-recognized by these T cells, mono-substituted analogs of the viral epitope were screened for recognition, revealing broad specificity for major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-bound peptide. Based on the particular amino acid changes tolerated by the CTL at each peptide position, the human protein sequence database was searched for possible sequences that were recognized in association with HLA B35. Four peptides were identified (MPEATVYGL, IPIAPVYGM, KPSPPYFGL, and KPIVVLHGY) that were powerful activating ligands for the CTL when presented on HLA B35 but not B8. Thus, equivalent epitopes, capable of fully activating a single TCR, were formed by peptides with minimal obvious sequence homology bound to either HLA B8 or B35. These data indicate that degenerate peptide recognition by TCR may play an important role in the vigorous response of self-MHC-restricted T cells to alloantigens.

The memory response to the immunodominant Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) epitope FLRGRAYGL, which associates with HLA B8, is exceptionally restricted, being dominated by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) with a single, public T cell receptor (TCR). CTL clones that express this receptor fortuitously cross-react with the alloantigen HLA B44. However, of the two major subtypes of this HLA, B*4402 and B*4403, that differ by a single amino acid, only the former is recognized by these mature CTL clones. Individuals heterozygous for HLA B8 and B*4402 use alternative TCR for the EBV determinant since the dominant TCR is potentially self-reactive. We now demonstrate that this clonotype is also essentially absent from the repertoire of CTL directed against the viral epitope in seven from seven unrelated individuals heterozygous for HLA B8 and B*4403. Thus immune tolerance of these CTL recognizing HLA B*4402 is associated with expression of either B*4402 or B*4403. This suggests that tolerance in the human T cell compartment requires a lower threshold of recognition than for effector function, thus providing a buffer zone minimizing the risk of autoimmunity. These data also illustrate the potential for non-restricting HLA molecules to bias dramatically the T cell repertoire used for specific immune responses. Such influences may be the basis of the "protective" effects of certain HLA alleles in susceptibility to autoimmune disorders.

Group I Burkitt lymphoma (BL) lines retaining the original BL tumor cell phenotype are unable to present endogenously expressed antigens to HLA class I-restricted cytotoxic T cells (CTL) but can be recognized if the relevant HLA class I/peptide epitope complex is reconstituted at the cell surface by exogenous addition of synthetic target peptide. Endogenous antigen-processing function is restored in BL lines that have undergone Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-induced drift in culture to the group III phenotype typically displayed by EBV-transformed lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) of normal B cell origin. We compared group I versus group III cells for their expression of proteasome components, transporter proteins and HLA-class I antigens, all of which are thought to be involved in the endogenous antigen processing pathway. By Western blot analysis, there were not consistent differences in the low molecular mass protein subunits of proteasomes (lmp)-2, lmp-7 and delta, although the mb-1 proteasome subunit was regularly present at higher levels in group I BL lines relative to group III lines or LCL. By contrast there were marked differences in the expression of peptide transporter-associated proteins (Tap), with down-regulation of Tap-1 and Tap-2 in 8/8 and 7/8 group I BL lines, respectively. Surface levels of HLA class I antigens were also consistently lower in group I cells; this was not associated with an intracellular accumulation of free HLA heavy chains, such as is seen in the Tap-deficient T2 processing-mutant line, but instead reflected a reduced rate of HLA class I synthesis in group I cells. Analysis of EBV gene transfectants of the B lymphoma lines BJAB and BL41 showed that the virus-encoded latent membrane protein-1 (LMP1), which is one of several EBV antigens expressed in group III but not in group I cells, was uniquely able to up-regulate expression both of the Tap proteins and HLA class I. Furthermore, this was accompanied by a restoration of antigen-processing function as measured by the ability of these cells to present an endogenously expressed viral antigen to CTL. These effects of LMP1 were similar to those induced in the same cell lines by interferon-gamma treatment. The results implicate both Tap and HLA class I expression as factors limiting the antigen-processing function of BL cells, and suggest that the accessibility of other EBV-associated malignancies to CTL surveillance may be critically dependent upon their LMP1 status.

An Epstein-Barr virus (EBV)-specific CD8+ cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) clone (LC13) was shown to recognize the minimal peptide determinant FLRGRAYGL from the EBNA 3 antigen of the BL74 strain of EBV. The equivalent epitope from the B95-8 strain (FLRGRAYGI) is not recognized when endogenously presented and the peptide is 15-fold less active than FLRGRAYGL. A replacement set of peptides was synthesized in which each residue within FLRGRAYGL was sequentially replaced with all other genetically coded amino acids. These peptides were tested for their ability to sensitize target cells to lysis by LC13. Of the 171 single-amino acid replacement peptides only 15 were more active than the peptide FLRGRAYGI. Five peptides had significantly greater activity than FLRGRAYGL and a peptide incorporating the most active of these single-amino acid substitutions (HIRGRAYSL) induced lysis at concentrations approximately 30-fold less than FLRGRAYGL. Simplified theoretical calculations based on this study suggest that CTL LC13 has a specificity for its target epitope of 1 in 4.7 x 10(10). This represents the first complete analysis of the role of single amino acids within a minimum epitope on the specificity of CTL recognition.