1. Statistical comparison of DEC and DEC+J is identical to comparison of two ClaSSE submodels, and is therefore valid.
- Subjects
- *
JUMP processes , *STATISTICAL models , *BIOGEOGRAPHY , *BIOLOGICAL extinction , *GENETIC speciation - Abstract
Aim: Statistical model comparison has become common in historical biogeography, enabled by the R package BioGeoBEARS, which implements several models in a common framework, allowing models to be compared with standard likelihood‐based methods of statistical model comparison. Ree and Sanmartín (Journal of Biogeography, 45, 741–749, 2018) critiqued the comparison of Dispersal–Extinction–Cladogenesis (DEC) and a modification of it, DEC+J, which adds the process of jump dispersal at speciation. DEC+J provides highly significant improvements in model fit on most (although not all) datasets. They claim that the comparison is statistically invalid for a variety of reasons. I analyse the key claims made by the critique. Location: Simulated data. Taxon: Simulated data. Methods: Likelihood calculations are checked by comparison between programs and by‐hand calculations, and by summing likelihoods across all possible datasets. Model adequacy of DEC versus DEC+J is checked by a simulation/inference experiment. Results: Mistakes in the critique's example likelihood calculations are demonstrated. DEC+J fits better on datasets because the DEC model is statistically inadequate in the common situation when most species have geographical ranges of single areas; the DEC model requires long residence times of multi‐area ranges, and when these are not observed, a model that does produce such data patterns, such as DEC+J, prevails. More fundamentally, statistical comparison of DEC and DEC+J produces identical log‐likelihood differences to statistical comparison of two submodels of ClaSSE where extinction rates are fixed to 0. Main Conclusions: DEC fails a basic model adequacy check for understandable reasons, while DEC+J does not. As Ree and Sanmartín recommend ClaSSE models as valid for comparison, the comparison of DEC and DEC+J is statistically valid according to their own criteria. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF