1. Geography and "thing knowledge": Instrument epistemology, failure, and narratives of 19th‐century exploration.
- Author
-
Withers, Charles W. J.
- Subjects
THEORY of knowledge ,HUMAN geography ,GEOGRAPHY ,SCIENTIFIC apparatus & instruments ,PAPER arts ,NARRATIVES - Abstract
The paper examines the relationships between instrument epistemology, failure, and textual authority with reference to the place of scientific instruments in published narratives of 19th‐century exploration. The paper draws on Baird's work on instrument epistemology and "semantic ascent" and Gooday's work on failure and on the morality of measurement. Its empirical focus comes from examination of RGS manuscript AP 52, a list of instruments provided by the RGS for 31 explorers in the period c.1877 to c.1883. Instruments are shown to (do) work in the field, even as explorers admitted to failure, in the devices and in themselves. Narrative accounts, often compiled elsewhere, obscure the contingent nature of instruments' use. The findings have implications for assessing the agency of instruments in exploration, instrument epistemology, and narrative inscription, and for understanding failure in geographical work. The paper examines the work of instruments in 19th‐century exploration with reference to RGS MS AP 52, a list of 31 explorers at work between c.1877 and c.1883. Analysis shows that instruments failed to do the work expected and the paper explains why this was so and what authors did about it in producing printed narratives of exploration. The paper has implications for how instruments have active agency in doing geography and for how failure is considered in geography. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF