Search

This paper is a report of a systematic review to identify, critique and synthesize nursing studies of the measurement of empathy in nursing research. Background. The profound impact of empathy on quality nursing care has been recognized. Reported empathy levels among nurses range from low to well-developed and there is clearly debate about what constitutes empathy and how it can be measured and improved. Data sources. Searches were made of the CINAHL, MEDLINE and PsycINFO databases, using the terms 'empathy', 'tool', 'scale', 'measure', 'nurse', and 'nursing', singly or in combination to identify literature published in the English language between 1987 and 2007. Methods. A systematic review was carried out. The included papers were critically reviewed, relevant data were extracted, and a narrative synthesis was conducted. Results. Thirty papers representing 29 studies met the inclusion criteria. Three types of studies were identified: descriptive studies ( n = 12), studies of empathy and patient outcomes ( n = 6), and evaluational studies ( n = 11). Twenty scales were used, with more than one tool being applied in some studies, suggesting the need for a systematic review of empathy measures in nursing research. A range of settings were studied but some, such as genetic healthcare, have been neglected. Conclusion. Despite numerous tools being used in nursing research to assess empathy, there appears to be no consistency, suggesting the need to evaluate the rigour of empathy tools appropriately, either to inform education or for application in clinical settings. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The article presents a commentary on the paper "Being an intensive care nurse related to questions of withholding or withdrawing curative treatment," by R. Hov, B. Hedelin and E. Athlin. According to the author, the paper focuses on the distinction between the perceptions of physician and nurse. He notes that it provides further confirmatory evidence around issues tied up with the withdrawal or withholding of treatment on ICU wards.

Aim. This paper explores nurses' experiences 1 year after an organization's commitment to providing a client-centred and client-empowering partnering approach to care. Background. Historically, nurses' approach to providing care in all nursing contexts has been one of doing for clients, and previous studies have focused more on in-hospital care than on home care. However, the isolation inherent in in-home nursing and nurses' limited professional autonomy and power associated with physician control over patients in home care have been reported, as has their difficulty in finding the meaning and satisfaction of human connectedness and mutuality in nurse-client relationships. Overall, research to date does not inform us about how nurses might make a change toward a more client-centred and client-empowering approach to nursing. Methods. An interpretive phenomenological design was used to elicit in-depth understanding about Registered Nurses' experiences of providing care using this innovative empowerment model. A purposefully selected sample of eight Registered Nurses participated in in-depth interviews. Data were generated during 2002. Hermeneutic analysis was used to elicit themes and patterns emerging from the data. Findings. Caring, client-centredness and the context of in-home care were important in implementing the new partnering approach. Barriers encountered at system, organizational and personal levels distracted nurses from fully comprehending and enacting the approach. After a year, they had begun to contemplate potential strategies for partnering with clients, but had not yet explored the power of their professional autonomy. Conclusion. Nurses are inclined to practise within the expert model of service delivery. They need to work through issues of professional autonomy and rise to the challenge of exercising their autonomy within the current healthcare context if they are to attend more consistently to client-centred empowering partnering. The home care setting offers an excellent environment for achieving these aims. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

In this paper I explore the possibilities of nursing as safeguarding through a phenomenological description of a small sculpture by the German artist Käthe Kollwitz. My discussion will be grounded in Heidegger's understanding of technicity as a pervasive systematizing and aggressive challenging-out. The method is grounded in Merleau-Ponty's and Heidegger's contention that strong artworks are truth-disclosing and show up our precognitive contact with the world. Bringing nursing concerns to an encounter with single strong artworks can help us cultivate a more receptive openness to our patients. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Nursing is frequently described as a caring practice. What this concept means may be less clear. This paper considers nursing as a caring practice in three steps. First, the concept of practice based on Taylor's and MacIntyre's philosophical definitions of the term is described. Secondly, numerous notions of caring are presented; the call from some nurse researchers for quantification of the concept and why this is problematic is discussed; and an exposition of caring from a phenomenological perspective is provided. Finally, the notions of practice and caring are joined, and the concept of a caring practice is presented. Nursing as a public caring practice is illustrated with examples from an interpretive phenomenological study. In conclusion, it is claimed that a phenomenological view of caring combined with a comprehensive definition of practice is well suited to nursing, and allows for a description of nurses’ caring practices from both a nursing and patient perspective. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

PARKER JM.Nursing Inquiry2004;11: 210 –217Nursing on the medical wardThis paper considers some issues confronting contemporary medical nursing and draws upon psychoanalytic theories to investigate some seemingly straightforward and taken-for-granted areas of medical nursing work. I am arguing that the everyday work of medical nurses in caring for patients is concerned with bringing order to and placing boundaries around inherently unsettled and destabilized circumstances. I am also arguing that how nurses manage and organize their work in this regard stems from traditional practices that tend to be taken for granted and not explicitly thought about. It is therefore difficult for nurses to consider changing these practices that often have negative consequences for the nurses.I want to examine the impact upon nurses of the consequences of three taken-for-granted nursing practices: (i) the tendency of nurses to confine their reactions to what is going on so as to present a caring self; (ii) the tendency of nurses in their everyday talk to patients to confine, limit and minimize meaning; and (iii) the tensions and ambiguities that emerge for nurses in the policing function they perform in confining patients to the bed or the ward. Negative consequences on nurses of these practices potentially include stress and confusion regarding their ability to care for patients; an undervaluing of nursing skills; and a deterioration in the nurse–patient relationship. Clinical supervision for medical nurses is proposed as a means of facilitating greater understanding of the nature of nurses’ relationships with patients and the complex dimensions of their medical nursing role. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The paper explores consequences of applying the view that illness is negative first-person experience in caring practice. The main reason this is an important issue is that it is empirically documented that patients conceive of illness in different ways. Communicating about illness in caring practice can therefore involve difficulties. I argue that many of these difficulties can be avoided if nurses focus directly on the extension of the concept of illness – patients’ experiences like the state of being in pain – and not on how this extension is represented as (the intension) illness. This argument is compatible with different views on the nurse–patient relationship as a communicative process. All it requires is the acceptance of minimal assumptions about concepts and concept possession. The argument has a descriptive and a normative dimension. It is descriptive in the sense that it seeks to use concepts from philosophy of mind to explain how many nurses succeed in talking about illness without applying the concept of illness. It is normative in the sense that it provides a philosophical justification for this practice. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This paper develops an argument that the choice of occupational strategy for nursing in the last century still has implications today. Nurses have retained a hierarchical principle of organization and have, albeit reluctantly, retained an in-service pattern of training. They have been concerned about recurrent shortages of nurses and this has influenced modes of development. These factors contribute to a continuity which is apparent in both 'Salmon' and 'Briggs', the two most influential reports on British nursing in recent decades. Such continuities in nursing development tend to preclude the raising of fundamental questions about the nature of nursing work and the manner in which it might be changed. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Most definitions, or descriptions of nursing emphasize that it is an interpersonal activity focusing on the understanding of the patient as an individual. In addition, such descriptions highlight not only the caring aspect of the role of nursing but also the health maintenance and rehabilitation aspects. The paper discusses the fact that despite these definitions, nursing is still task orientated, largely based on the medical model and hidebound by tradition. Suggestions are made of ways in which this approach may be altered. The use of the nursing process, the concept of the primary nurse and the developing of empathetic understanding being some of the ways in which individualized care may become a reality. The adherence to tradition highlights that nurses are the greatest hindrance to progress in nursing. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

This paper describes the establishment and organization of the Joint Board of Clinical Nursing Studies. It outlines the philosophy which has developed since 1970 and which has formed the basis of the Board's work. The belief that ongoing clinical education should contribute to the quality of patient care, and to the personal and professional development of the nurse and midwife, has been fundamental to the formation of the Board's policies. Factual information is given on various aspects of the work of the Board. The difficulty of assessing the value of the work is recognized, but the importance of this activity is stressed. Formative evaluation is required as an integral part of every course. An attempt is made to assess the value of the Board's work to the patients, the nurses taking the courses, and to the nursing service. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Nurses' performance in written examinations often bears little relationship to their level of clinical proficiency in the ward. This paper describes a method of making written exatninations more relevant to the clinical situation. It describes the development of a case history test which confronts students with the kind of information they have to interpret and act upon in the ward, and which requires them to recall the principles of nursing care and apply them in a way similar to real life. Evidence is presented that tests of this type are more closely linked to clinical performance than are conventional written examinations, and guidehnes are given for constructing case history tests. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

The section presents the author's views on her article "Attitudes of Nursing Staff in General Medical Wards Towards Activation of Stroke Patients," which appeared in the 1982 issue of the "Journal of Advanced Nursing." It discusses the significance of the paper in the field of health care. It asserts that the attitudes of carers in society are as important as the attitudes of nursing staff. It also points out that the staff's attitudes matter in the care of stroke-patients.