Search

The introduction of immunotherapy with checkpoint receptor blockade has changed the treatment of advanced cancers, at times inducing prolonged remission. Nevertheless, the success rate of the approach is variable across patients and different tumor types, and treatment is often accompanied by severe immune-related side effects, suggesting the importance of co-inhibitory pathway for both prevention of autoimmunity and failure of tumor rejection. A better understanding of how to uncouple anti-tumor activity from loss of self-tolerance is necessary in order to increase the therapeutic efficacy of checkpoint immunotherapy. In this review, we describe basic concepts of T cell exhaustion that occur in cancer, highlighting the role of co-inhibitory receptors in contributing to this process while preventing immunopathology. By providing an overview of the current therapeutic success and immune-related burden of secondary effects of checkpoint immunotherapy, we illustrate the “double-edged sword” related to interference with immune-regulatory pathways. Finally, since achieving tumor rejection while preserving self-tolerance is particularly important for the central nervous system, we analyze the case for checkpoint immunotherapy in glioblastoma, the most common adult brain tumor.

T-cell immunoglobulin and mucin domain 3 (TIM-3) is an Ig-superfamily member expressed on IFN-γ-secreting Th1 and Tc1 cells and was identified as a negative regulator of immune tolerance. TIM-3 is expressed by a subset of activated CD4+ T cells, and anti-CD3/anti-CD28 stimulation increases both the level of expression and the number of TIM-3+ T cells. In mice, TIM-3 is constitutively expressed on natural regulatory T (Treg) cells and has been identified as a regulatory molecule of alloimmunity through its ability to modulate CD4+ T-cell differentiation. Here, we examined TIM-3 expression on human Treg cells to determine its role in T-cell suppression. In contrast to mice, TIM-3 is not expressed on Treg cells ex vivo but is upregulated after activation. While TIM-3+ Treg cells with increased gene expression of LAG3, CTLA4, and FOXP3 are highly efficient suppressors of effector T (Teff) cells, TIM-3− Treg cells poorly suppressed Th17 cells as compared with their suppression of Th1 cells; this decreased suppression ability was associated with decreased STAT-3 expression and phosphorylation and reduced gene expression of IL10, EBI3, GZMB, PRF1, IL1Rα, and CCR6. Thus, our results suggest that TIM-3 expression on Treg cells identifies a population highly effective in inhibiting pathogenic Th1- and Th17-cell responses.

Regulatory T cells are the central element for the maintenance of peripheral tolerance. Several subtypes of regulatory T (Treg) cells have been described, and most of them belong to the CD4(+) T-helper (Th) cell lineage. These specific subtypes can be discriminated according to phenotype and function. Forkhead box protein 3 (FoxP3)-expressing natural Treg cells (Tregs) and IL-10-producing, T-regulatory type 1 cells (Tr1) are the best-studied types of CD4(+) regulatory T cells in humans and experimental animal models. It was shown that they play a crucial role during autoimmune neuroinflammation. Both cells types seem to be particularly important for multiple sclerosis (MS). Here, we discuss the role of CD4(+) regulatory T cells in autoimmune neuroinflammation with an emphasis on Tregs and Tr1 cells in MS.

Regulatory T cells (Tregs) are critical to the human immune system, providing appropriately scaled immune responses and mediating peripheral tolerance. A central role for forkhead box protein 3 (FoxP3)(+) Tregs has been shown in the pathogenesis of mechanistically diverse central nervous system (CNS) diseases from autoimmune diseases such as multiple sclerosis to glioblastomas. Understanding how tumors induce Treg function to escape immune surveillance in marked contrast to autoimmune diseases, where there is loss of Treg function, will provide valuable lessons regarding Treg biology and potential therapeutic targets for CNS diseases.

Objective Intrathecal IgG synthesis, persistence of bands of oligoclonal IgG, and memory B-cell clonal expansion are well-characterized features of the humoral response in multiple sclerosis (MS). Nevertheless, the target antigen of this response remains enigmatic. Methods We produced 53 different human IgG1 monoclonal recombinant antibodies (rAbs) by coexpressing paired heavy- and light-chain variable region sequences of 51 plasma cell clones and 2 B-lymphocyte clones from MS cerebrospinal fluid in human tissue culture cells. Chimeric control rAbs were generated from anti-myelin hybridomas in which murine variable region sequences were fused to human constant region sequences. Purified rAbs were exhaustively assayed for reactivity against myelin basic protein, proteolipid protein, and myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein by immunostaining of transfected cells expressing individual myelin proteins, by protein immunoblotting, and by immunostaining of human brain tissue sections. Results Whereas humanized control rAbs derived from anti-myelin hybridomas and anti-myelin monoclonal antibodies readily detected myelin antigens in multiple immunoassays, none of the rAbs derived from MS cerebrospinal fluid displayed immunoreactivity to the three myelin antigens tested. Immunocytochemical analysis of tissue sections from MS and control brain demonstrated only weak staining with a few rAbs against nuclei or cytoplasmic granules in neurons, glia, and inflammatory cells. Interpretation The oligoclonal B-cell response in MS cerebrospinal fluid is not targeted to the well-characterized myelin antigens myelin basic protein, proteolipid protein, or myelin oligodendrocyte glycoprotein.

While suppressor T cells might have been the so-called “baby thrown out with the bath water” when molecular biology strongly influenced immunology in the 1980s, it was clear to investigators of autoimmune disease that adoptively transferred suppression by T cells could influence these diseases. Here, we will present an overview of T cells as regulators of immune responses from a human species point of view, beginning with a history of T cells as regulatory cells, followed by a discussion of how these cells critically influence human autoimmune disease. Twenty-five years ago, immunologists determined that two cellular mechanisms of dominant tolerance could mediate peripheral regulation and the phenomena of induced CD4+ T cell non-responsiveness. These two mechanisms were MHC-restricted T cell presentation of antigen to other T cells [1] and suppression via thymically derived ‘suppressor’ T cells [2]. Shortly after the discovery of MHC class II+ CD4+ T cells in human peripheral blood (these cells are present in most mammalian species excluding mice [3]) [4, 5], Kunkel and his colleagues observed that autoimmune patients have a higher percentage of these cells in peripheral blood than healthy patients [6]. Using the newly developed technique of CD4+ T cell cloning, researchers determined that MHC class II+ CD4+ T cell clones induce anergy when they present antigen to other CD4+ T cells [7]. Evidence from these studies was used to support the argument for the existence of anti-idiotypic T cell networks. ‘Suppressor’ T cells, too, were thought to recognize the antigen receptor of autologous CD4+ cells and prohibit activation with specificity directed against the suppressed cell. In the years to follow, the molecular or biochemical processes underlying these mechanisms could not be determined; MHC class II was relegated to a biomarker of late CD4+ T cell activation; many early studies of suppressor T cells were discredited or disproved; and the paradigm of idiotypic networks fell from fashion. Unfortunately, as Rolf Zinkernagel writes, “science (particularly immunology) undergoes periods of democratic, if not demagogic decisions … while populistic or experimentally biased views within science will eventually be corrected, if proven wrong this can take a long time” [8]. Although relegated to the list of immunological “not-so-good ideas” for almost fifteen years, ‘suppressor’ T cells have now been shown to play an essential role in preventing autoimmune disease and immunologists have begun to better characterize the now-called ‘regulatory’ T cells that can mediate suppression of autoimmunity. Not surprisingly, MHC class II+ CD4+ T cell have re-emerged as well, as expression of this immunomodulatory receptor was found to identify a functionally distinct subset of human ‘regulatory’ T cells (Tregs) expressing FoxP3. In this review we discuss recent advances in the characterization of human CD4+CD25high Tregs, with a focus on the impairment of these cells in human autoimmune disease.

The paradox of autoreactivity to self-peptides in physiological as opposed to pathological immune responses is not well understood. Here, we directly examined the human T cell response to endogenous self-peptides in a series of healthy subjects. CFSE-labeled T cells were stimulated with unmanipulated antigen-presenting cells containing endogenous self-antigen, and the resulting CD4+ populations entering into cell cycle (CFSE(low)) or non-proliferating CD4+ cells (CFSE(high)) were single-cell sorted, cloned and screened against a panel of self-antigens and microbial recall antigens to interrogate their antigen reactivity. The percentage of CD4+ T cells entering cell cycle in response to self-peptide/MHC was calculated to be 0.04%, and entry into cell cycle was dependent upon CD28 costimulation. Clones derived from CFSE(low) T cells exhibited significantly greater cross-reactivity to multiple antigens than CFSE(high) clones or other CD4+ clones generated after microbial antigen stimulation. Sequencing the TCRbeta chains indicated that CFSE(low) clones were indeed clonal. These data demonstrate that T cell clones generated on stimulation by endogenous self-peptides exhibit a high degree of multispecificity, and we speculate that their multispecificity is based upon recognition of shared-backbone MHC determinants.

As self-recognition is fundamental to the efficient operation of the immune system, a number of mechanisms have evolved to keep this potential pathologic self-reactivity in check. Thus, even though the majority of strongly self-reactive T cells are deleted in the thymus during T-cell maturation, a number of mature T cells that recognize self-antigens can be found in the peripheral circulation in healthy individuals as well as in patients with autoimmune disease. These self-reactive cells are kept in a non-responsive state in healthy individuals while they appear to be involved in the etiology of a number of autoimmune diseases in patients. The primary role of a relatively recently identified T-cell population, referred to as natural CD4+ CD25+ regulatory T cells, is to modulate the activity of these self-reactive cells. Although it is still unclear how these regulatory cells function, they can inhibit the activation of other potentially pathologic T cells in in vitro assays. Using such assays, regulatory T cells isolated from patients with a number of autoimmune diseases have been shown to exhibit reduced inhibitory function as compared with those isolated from healthy individuals. In this review, we discuss human natural regulatory T cells, what is known about their function, and their associations with specific autoimmune diseases.

We identified a novel population of human T cells, studied directly ex vivo, that co-express surface B7-1 and intracellular IL-4. These peripheral blood B7-1+/CD4+ T cells expressed cell surface molecules associated with differentiation including CD45RO and MHC class II, yet were CD69(-) and CD25(-). In short-term cultures, T cell receptor (TCR) cross-linking induced further IL-4 production with little IFN-gamma or TNF-alpha. In marked contrast, CD4+ T cells negative for B7-1 expressed intracellular IFN-gamma and high amounts of TNF-alpha but little IL-4 upon TCR cross-linking. The CD4+/B7-1+/IL-4-expressing T cells were of polyclonal origin based on their diverse TCR repertoire. To explore the biological significance of this B7-1+/IL-4+ T cell population and to assess its potential regulatory role in autoimmune disease, we examined whether these T cells isolated ex vivo were altered in subjects with multiple sclerosis (MS). While the frequency of B7-1+ T cells was enhanced in patients with MS as compared to normal subjects, there was a significant diminution of B7-1+/IL-4+ T cells in the patients. The decrease in these IL-4-producing T cells in patients with autoimmune disease is consistent with a possible role as immunoregulatory T cells.

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is postulated to be a Th1-type cell-mediated autoimmune disease. Thus therapies that decrease T cell interferon (IFN)-gamma production or increase interleukin (IL)-4 production would be expected to have an ameliorating effect on MS. Some progressive MS patients receiving pulse cyclophosphamide therapy developed peripheral blood eosinophilia. We investigated whether cyclophosphamide-treated patients had immune deviation toward Th2 responses. We measured cytokine production in patients receiving either monthly intravenous methylprednisolone (MP), intravenous cyclophosphamide plus methylprednisolone (CY/MP), methotrexate, IFN-beta1b, in untreated MS patients, and in healthy controls. Minimal IL-4 was secreted in untreated patients (129 +/- 62 pg/ml), methotrexate-treated patients (99 +/- 79 pg/ml), and healthy controls (50 +/- 13 pg/ml). A marked increase in IL-4 was observed in CY/MP patients (1,503 +/- 291 pg/ml). Patients treated with MP (418 +/- 160 pg/ml) or IFN-beta1b (425 +/- 167 pg/ml) showed small increases. Eosinophilia in CY/MP-treated patients (6.0 +/- 0.7%) correlated with increased IL-4. IL-10 production was also increased in CY/MP-treated patients. Both CY/MP- and MP-treated groups had decreased production of IFN-gamma compared with untreated MS. These findings demonstrate pronounced immune deviation favoring Th2-type responses after pulse cyclophosphamide therapy.

Multiple sclerosis is a presumed autoimmune disease, associated with inflammation in the CNS white matter, mediated by autoreactive T cells. We previously reported that oral myelin tolerization of relapsing-remitting MS patients resulted in fewer attacks, as compared to a placebo-fed group. Here, we examined whether oral tolerization with bovine myelin resulted in altered autoreactive T-cell populations or altered T-cell fraction. We generated 4,620 T-cell lines from 34 relapsing-remitting MS patients (17 were fed bovine myelin daily), and each line was examined for proliferation to MBP, PLP, and TT and for secretion of IL-4, IFN-gamma, and TGF-beta1. The frequency of TGF-beta1-secreting T-cell lines after MBP and PLP stimulation in fed patients was greater than that of nonfed patients. These experiments demonstrate that oral tolerization with autoantigen results in altered cytokine secretion in a human autoimmune disease with the generation of TGF-beta1-secreting T cells that may regulate the inflammatory response at the site of the demyelinating lesions in multiple sclerosis. These data provide the first evidence of antigen-specific modification of cytokine secretion in a human autoimmune disease.

Understanding the immune response to myelin antigens in regard to the peptide/MHC/TCR complex is important in defining pathogenesis of demyelinating autoimmune diseases and in developing antigen-specific therapies. We previously reported that individual multiple sclerosis patients may use certain dominant TCR V beta chains to recognize immunodominant MBP peptides. In examining the TCR beta chain usage, we observed repeated TCR VDJ sequences among different T-cell lines isolated from the same patient. This suggested that a few expanded T-cell clones may dominate the immune response to immunodominant MBP peptides. Here, we report experiments where TCR rearrangements were used as a probe for the clonal origin of MBP specific T-cells cultured from blood lymphocytes of MS patients and normal subjects. In two patients with the DR2 haplotype that were analyzed in detail, the T-cell response to MBP was focused on the MBP (84-102) peptide and in vivo expanded population(s) dominated the response to the MBP (84-102) peptide. Two MBP (84-102) specific T-cell clones from a normal subject with the DR2 haplotype were also found to have identical TCR sequences. Clonality was proven by demonstrating that independent clones had identical TCR alpha and beta chain sequences as well as identical sequences of a TCR gamma chain or of a second TCR alpha chain rearrangement. These data suggest that the response to human MBP is dominated in at least some subjects by expanded clones that may persist in vivo for relatively long periods of time.

Oral administration of proteins is a long-recognized method of inducing antigen-specific peripheral immune tolerance. We previously showed that oral administration of myelin basic protein suppresses monophasic experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis in the Lewis rat when it is given in association with immunization and prior to disease onset. As a potential therapy for human autoimmune disease, it is crucial to determine whether oral tolerance can ameliorate an ongoing immune response. We therefore asked whether oral administration of myelin antigens, after sensitization and disease expression has occurred, could affect immunological, clinical, or pathological features of experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis. Chronic relapsing experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis was induced in the Lewis rat and strain 13 guinea pig by immunization with whole guinea pig cord homogenate, complete Freund's adjuvant, and Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Following recovery from the first attack, animals were orally given bovine myelin, guinea pig myelin, or guinea pig myelin basic protein three times per week for up to 3 months. Animals receiving myelin products orally had decreased severity and frequency of clinical relapses, decreased delayed-type hypersensitivity responses to myelin antigens, diminished inflammation in the central nervous system (CNS), and decreased areas of CNS demyelination. In the rat, guinea pig myelin basic protein was as effective as guinea pig myelin in ameliorating the disease and also resulted in decreased serum anti-myelin basic protein antibody levels. No exacerbation of disease or worsening of pathological findings occurred in the animals given myelin products. These results demonstrate that oral administration of myelin antigens can suppress chronic relapsing experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis and have direct relevance to therapy of human demyelinating disorders such as multiple sclerosis.

A consistent immunological finding in patients with progressive multiple sclerosis is a loss of functional suppression. We have recently found decreases in suppressor inducer T cells in progressive multiple sclerosis as measured by two-color immunofluorescence using differentiation markers CD4 and 2H4. In the present study, we examined the relationship between functional suppression and circulating CD4+ 2H4+ T cells using a two-stage assay. (1) T cells were stimulated for 7 days with irradiated non-T cells (autologous mixed lymphocyte reaction [AMLR]) and harvested. It has previously been shown that suppressor T cells are generated during the course of the AMLR. (2) The AMLR-generated suppressor T cells were then incubated with mononuclear cells plus pokeweed mitogen, and immunoglobulin (Ig) synthesis was measured. There was less AMLR-induced suppression of IgG synthesis in patients with progressive multiple sclerosis as compared with normal subjects and patients with other neurological diseases. More importantly, there were significant correlations between decreases in circulating CD4+ 2H4+ cells and the AMLR (p = 0.009). Thus, the decreases in functional suppression and the decreases in the AMLR in multiple sclerosis appear tightly linked to CD4+ 2H4+ cells, and their measurement provides a means to monitor suppressor function phenotypically. Decreases in suppressor inducer T cells may in part explain immunoregulatory abnormalities observed in multiple sclerosis.

Based on the assumption that multiple sclerosis is an autoimmune disease, a number of clinical trials designed to suppress the immune system or to restore immune balance in multiple sclerosis have been attempted. Depending on the disease category, the clinical goals of immunotherapy differ. Therapeutic goals include improving recovery from acute attacks, preventing or decreasing the number of relapses, and halting the disease in its progressive stage. The ultimate goal of multiple sclerosis therapy is the early treatment of patients in an attempt to halt the onset of progression. Specific strategies of immunotherapy include generation of a suppressor influence, removal of helper/inducer cells, manipulation of activated T cells, manipulation of class II major histocompatibility complex-bearing cells, alteration of lymphocyte traffic, extracorporeal removal of serum factors or cells, and manipulation of antigen-specific cells. Present treatment modalities are beginning to show some efficacy of nonspecific immunosuppression, but these treatments are limited by their toxicities. As the immunotherapy of multiple sclerosis moves to the next stage in the coming years, patients at an earlier stage of their disease will have to be treated, nontoxic forms of therapy developed, clinical trials lengthened, and a laboratory monitor of the disease developed. Given the positive effects of immunotherapy seen thus far in the disease, it is possible that appropriate immunotherapeutic intervention may provide effective treatment for the disease in the future.

It has long been recognized that T cells in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and other inflammatory compartments cannot be stimulated by mitogen and the reason for this has remained unknown. This question was investigated using mononuclear cells (MNC) isolated from the CSF of subjects with multiple sclerosis and other inflammatory brain diseases which predominantly express the CD4 and CDw29 but not CD45RA determinants. CSF and blood cells were stimulated by either the CD3/T cell receptor complex, the CD2 activation pathway, calcium ionophore, or an activator of protein kinase C, phorbol myristate acetate (PMA). CSF MNC proliferated less than blood MNC following stimulation by phytohemagglutinin in subjects with inflammation in the CSF, but not in subjects with non-inflammatory CNS diseases. Moreover, CSF MNC were not induced to proliferate through stimulation of the CD2 pathway by anti-T11(2) + anti-T11(3) monoclonal antibodies (mAb). This was not due to defects in either interleukin 2 receptors, interleukin 2 secretion, or to T cell pre-activation in vivo. Instead, the refractory activation state of inflammatory CSF T cells was corrected by PMA. That CSF contains predominantly CD4+CDw29+CD45RA- cells suggests that PMA may be co-stimulatory with anti-CD2 mAb to activate this population of T cells. This was confirmed in experiments with sorted T cells from normal subjects. These data suggest that the inability of mitogens or anti-CD2 mAb to stimulate inflammatory CSF T cells, which can be corrected by an inducer of protein kinase C, is related to the relative absence of CD4+CD45RA+ cells in the CSF. Alterations of protein kinase C and protein phosphorylation may exist in inflammatory T cell populations that regulate the immune response.

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is an inflammatory disease of the central nervous system (CNS). In MS patients being treated with anti-T11, a murine monoclonal antibody which recognizes the sheep red blood cell receptor, it was found that peripheral blood T cells were labeled in vivo by the antibody. Furthermore, anti-T11 did not lyse cells or enter the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). In CSF specimens obtained by serial lumbar punctures from patients with progressive MS who received five daily infusions of anti-T11, 70 +/- 12% of the T cells had mouse antibody bound to their surface by 72 to 96 hours. No in vivo staining of CSF T cells was observed in patients infused with anti-T4, a murine monoclonal antibody that was not found to label T cells in vivo. These results demonstrate that there is rapid movement of lymphocytes from the peripheral blood to the CNS in patients with progressive MS. This rapid trafficking of T cells suggests that the ongoing pathological process within the CNS may be closely linked to the peripheral immune system and may have implications for the monitoring and treatment of MS.

Splenic lymphocytes from adult C57BL/6 mice infected with purified reovirus type 1 or 3 particles were fused with NS1 myeloma cells. Approximately 300 clones were obtained from each fusion (type 1 or type 3) and the supernatants from these clones were screened by radioimmunoassay for their ability to bind virus, T lymphocytes, brain, liver, lung tissues and isolated oligodendrocytes and ependymal cells. Approximately 10% of clones (33 and 26 clones, respectively) were positive for each fusion. For reovirus type 1:21% of positive clones bound only virus, 64% bound one of the normal tissues but not virus, and 15% bound both virus and one or more of the normal tissues. For reovirus type 3: 19% of positive clones bound only virus, 73% bound normal tissue only, and 8% bound both virus and normal tissue. Only 3 positive clones were obtained from uninfected control animals. These experiments demonstrate that (a) during the course of an immune response to a virus, autoantibodies are generated which react with a large variety of normal tissues and that (b) there are shared antigenic structures between viral determinants and normal tissue that can be identified by monoclonal antibodies. Although these results suggest two mechanisms by which an autoimmune response may develop following viral infection, the biological significance of these autoreactive monoclonal antibodies remains to be elucidated.

A single-cell cloning technique was used to analyze both phenotype and function of individual T cells in patients with multiple sclerosis (MS). Blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) lymphocytes were plated at 1 cell per well, stimulated with phytohemagglutinin followed by interleukin 2, and expanded to 3 X 10(6) cells per "clone." More than 90% of the T8 clones generated from patients with MS and controls in both blood and CSF were cytotoxic precursors. There was also a slight decrease in cytotoxic T4 clones in the blood of patients with MS. The cytotoxic precursor frequencies of T cells in the CSF generally reflected those in the blood. In separate experiments, antigen reactivity was examined in lines established from blood or CSF. No reactivity to myelin basic protein or white matter was found in patients with MS or controls. Myelin basic protein-reactive clones could, however, be generated after first stimulating lymphocytes with antigen before cloning. These results suggest that changes in the T8 population from the blood of patients with MS involve cytotoxic as well as suppressor cells. Sequestration of myelin basic protein- or white matter-reactive T cells was not seen in the CSF of patients with MS, unlike reports of viral meningoencephalitis, in which large numbers of antigen-specific cells were found in the CSF. Direct single-cell clonal analysis of the CSF should provide a more sophisticated approach to the study of T cell abnormalities in patients with MS.