Search

Antigen engagement of the TCR may lead to activation of mature T cells while inducing deletion or positive selection of immature thymocytes. Using thymocytes from TCR transgenic mice recognizing the allo-antigen H-2Kb we investigated whether double-positive CD4+CD8+ (DP) thymocytes constitute a particular developmental stage where signals originating from surface receptor engagement will lead to distinct nuclear signaling. We show that the developmental control of transcription factors is apparent, at least at two levels. First, NF-AT binding activity was not induced in response to either antigen or phorbol myristate acetate (PMA)/lonomycin in DP thymocytes, whereas it was induced in single-positive CD8 thymocytes. Second, antigen induced a different pattern of transcription factor binding activities than PMA/lonomycin in DP thymocytes, AP-1 activity being selectively induced by antigen and NF-kappa B by PMA/lonomycin. Further we show that the transcription factors found to be induced in the DP thymic population were not susceptible to the inhibitory effect of cyclosporin A.

We have studied tolerance induction in transgenic CBA mice expressing H-2Kb genes under the influence of guinea-pig alpha-lactalbumin (KAL) or human beta-globin gene promoter (K beta). KAL radio-resistant cells, but not bone marrow derived cells, induce tolerance to H-2Kb in chimeric mice. In contrast, bone marrow derived and radio-resistant cells of K beta mice induce tolerance. Although appropriate, tissue-specific, expression of H-2Kb molecules occurs in KAL and K beta mice, H-2Kb is expressed at low levels in thymus of transgenic mice. In addition, dendritic cells and macrophages express H-2Kb molecules when K beta, but not when KAL bone marrow is cultured in vitro. The mode of tolerance induction was examined in double transgenic mice by mating KAL or K beta mice to mice expressing TCR transgenes (Tg-TCR) derived from a H-2Kb specific, CD8-independent cytotoxic T cell clone. In both cases, a large number of Tg-TCR+ CD8+CD4+ thymocytes develop but mature CD8+CD4- thymocytes fail to appear suggesting that thymocytes are eliminated late in development. Some CD8-CD4- and CD8-CD4+ Tg-TCR+ T cells develop in double transgenic mice and respond to activation through their TCR-CD3 complex in vitro, although no responses to stimulation with H-2Kb expressing cells were detected. Thus, tolerance induction in KAL and K beta mice proceeds via a deletional mechanism that is inefficient due either to low numbers of H-2Kb expressing thymic cells or to the low levels of H-2Kb expressed by thymic cells, or to a combination of these factors.

Immature thymocytes expressing TCRs which confer reactivity to self-MHC molecules are subject to efficient elimination as a result of negative selection. Previously, we have identified a lineage of H-2Kb Tg mice, CD2Kb-3, which fails to reject skin grafts from mice expressing H-2Kb even though H-2Kb-specific cytotoxic T cells can be generated in vitro. We now show that bone marrow derived cells are responsible for tolerance induction and that tolerance is acquired, at least in part, by negative selection in CD2Kb-3 mice. Thymocytes expressing two different transgenic TCR (TCR-Tg) clonotypes conferring reactivity to H-2Kb are eliminated prior to the CD8+CD4+ stage of differentiation in double Tg (CD2Kb-3 x TCR-Tg)F1 mice. As in other cases where thymocytes from TCR-Tg mice develop in the presence of deleting ligands, large numbers of TCR+ CD8-CD4- T cells accumulate in double Tg mice. However, these T cells fail to respond to H-2Kb in vitro but can be activated with immobilized anti-clonotypic antibody. Consequently, thymocytes expressing these types of TCR molecules represent a fraction of H-2Kb-reactive thymocytes which are unable to mature into T cells capable of mounting H-2Kb-specific cytotoxic responses. Presumably, precursors of H-2Kb-specific cytotoxic T cells found in the periphery of CD2Kb-3 mice express a distinct repertoire of TCR molecules conferring reactivity to H-2Kb. We consider potential explanations to account for this discrepancy and their wider implications, including the possibility that the repertoire of thymocytes able to recognize self-H-2Kb molecules in CD2Kb-3 mice is divided into distinct subsets; those which are, and those which are not, subject to negative selection.

The extent of peripheral clonal deletion of the T cell antigen receptor (TCR) from a CD8-dependent cytotoxic T lymphocyte of H-2k origin with alloreactivity for H-2Kb was measured in a TCR transgenic (Tg) model by use of a clonotype-specific mAb (anti-Ti mAb). Deletion varied depending on whether the TCR Tg was expressed in mice heterozygous (H-2k x b) or homozygous (H-2b x b) for the H-2Kb antigen. CD8 surface staining and functional analyses of peripheral T cells stimulated with polyclonal activators in bulk culture or by limiting dilution confirmed that in the H-2b x b mice few Ti+ cells were generated as measured by anti-Ti mAb-dependent target cell killing; while such cells could readily be detected in the H-2k x b mice. The latter maintained non-responsiveness to H-2Kb, as measured by cytolysis of H-2Kb-expressing tumor target cells, due to their down-regulation of surface CD8 expression. The question of whether the difference between H-2b x b and H-2k x b mice was due to the influence of positive selection imposed by the k haplotype in the H-2k x b hybrid, or to the lower antigen density in heterozygous than homozygous mice was addressed by analysis of H-2b x d Tg mice, H-2d being a non-selecting haplotype. Results obtained were similar for H-2b x d and H-2k x b Tg mice, suggesting that the density of the H-2Kb antigen may be one of the parameters controlling the extent of clonal deletion in the thymus.

Activation of mature lymphocytes requires in addition to the TCR contact with the corresponding antigen the binding of the CD8 or CD4 co-receptors to MHC class I or class II proteins respectively. To investigate the contribution of the CD8-class I interaction to the elimination of autoreactive T cells during negative selection in the thymus we generated two types of transgenic mice. One set expressed a modified Kb molecule which contained a human HLA-A2 alpha 3 domain, thereby missing the binding residues for the murine CD8 molecules. The second set of mice expressed an anti-Kb specific TCR. Both lines were crossed and in the resulting double transgenic mice the development of Kb-reactive T cells was followed with an anti-clonotypic antibody. Surprisingly, efficient clonal deletion in the thymus was still observed, although the reduced CD8-class I adhesion abrogated effector functions in vivo and in vitro. These results imply that even T cells with intermediate affinity for self are negatively selected in the thymus despite the fact that they are not able to react against self antigens in the periphery. Thus a safety window is created which decreases the risk of autoaggression.