Search

Amyloid appearance is a rare event that is promoted in the presence of other aggregated proteins. These aggregates were thought to act by templating the formation of an assembly-competent nucleation seed, but we find an unanticipated role for them in enhancing the persistence of amyloid after it arises. Specifically, Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rnq1 amyloid reduces chaperone-mediated disassembly of Sup35 amyloid, promoting its persistence in yeast. Mathematical modeling and corresponding in vivo experiments link amyloid persistence to the conformationally defined size of the Sup35 nucleation seed and suggest that amyloid is actively cleared by disassembly below this threshold to suppress appearance of the [PSI + ] prion in vivo. Remarkably, this framework resolves multiple known inconsistencies in the appearance and curing of yeast prions. Thus, our observations establish the size of the nucleation seed as a previously unappreciated characteristic of prion variants that is key to understanding transitions between prion states.

The self-assembly of alternative conformations of normal proteins into amyloid aggregates has been implicated in both the acquisition of new functions and in the appearance and progression of disease. However, while these amyloidogenic pathways are linked to the emergence of new phenotypes, numerous studies have uncoupled the accumulation of aggregates from their biological consequences, revealing currently underappreciated complexity in the determination of these traits. Here, to explore the molecular basis of protein-only phenotypes, we focused on the Saccharomyces cerevisiae Sup35/[PSI(+)] prion, which confers a translation termination defect and expression level-dependent toxicity in its amyloid form. Our studies reveal that aggregated Sup35 retains its normal function as a translation release factor. However, fluctuations in the composition and size of these complexes specifically alter the level of this aggregate-associated activity and thereby the severity and toxicity of the amyloid state. Thus, amyloid heterogeneity is a crucial contributor to protein-only phenotypes.