Search

The use of electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) in mental retardation has been discussed in several case reports and case series. In this case, a 35-year-old patient with corpus callosum aplasia and severe therapy-resistant catatonia was treated with a series of unilateral ECT and improved considerably. Electroencephalographic recordings during ECT showed a complete interhemispheric synchronicity due to regular anterior and posterior commissural fibers. After ECT, the patient received long-term medication with quetiapine and lorazepam. Electroconvulsive therapy turned out to be a powerful tool for treating catatonic syndromes in patients with mental retardation and should be considered as a potent treatment option in otherwise therapy-resistant cases.

The determination that cocaine is directly responsible for the immediate cause of death should be considered only when there is a reasonably complete understanding of the circumstances or facts surrounding the death. Another, more obvious and immediate cause of death must be absent, or, at least cocaine must be shown to be a significant contributing factor in the chain of medical findings that lead directly to the immediate cause of death. Not all death investigation requires the sequential steps described in this paper, but these steps must be considered early on in the investigation whenever there is scene, investigational, medical or a historical basis to believe that cocaine is directly related to the cause of death. A relatively high profile death when cocaine is known to be involved, or a death involving unusual behavior on the part of the deceased with police involvement are examples where these considerations may well apply. Information needs to be obtained as soon as possible to have the highest chance of successfully documenting the toxicologic basis for the diagnosis. These facts would include, but would not necessarily be limited to, a scene investigation (whenever possible), a careful review of the investigative reports from all involved agencies, the initial core temperature of the body as well as that of the environment at the time of the collapse or death, the past medical history of the individual, and the results of a complete forensic autopsy and toxicologic studies. Knowledge of and an understanding of the current relevant forensic literature on this subject should be available to the reviewer prior to any interpretation of the significance of cocaine upon a specific death.

The National Association of Medical Examiners Committee on Cocaine-related Deaths recommends that the following guidelines be applied in the process of documenting, interpreting, and certifying potential cocaine-related fatalities. The committee cautions that the investigation of any drug-related death requires a complete investigation of the circumstances of death, the death scene, and past medical history. It is also necessary to have the results of the forensic toxicological analysis and those of a complete forensic autopsy examination prior to formulating an opinion as to the cause and manner of death. Cocaine should be considered the underlying cause of the death when 1 or more of the following is true: (1). the circumstances surrounding the death can be associated with an acute cocaine exposure and there are no supervening causes of death; (2). the immediate cause of death is directly due to a readily identifiable mechanism or disease such as a gunshot wound or a stroke, yet the acute use of cocaine was the direct underlying cause of the trauma or the disease process; and (3). chronic cocaine use leads to a disease that results in an ultimately fatal pathologic process leading to organ injury and death. The committee further cautions that reported drug levels may not directly relate to the toxic or lethal effects of the drug upon the patient. These guidelines are intended for use by practicing medical examiners and physicians who certify drug deaths, as well as providing education tools for students.

GHB can be produced either as a pre- or postmortem artifact. The authors describe two cases in which GHB was detected and discuss the problem of determining the role of GHB in each case. In both cases, NaF-preserved blood and urine were analyzed using gas chromatography. The first decedent, a known methamphetamine abuser, had GHB concentrations similar to those observed with subanesthetic doses (femoral blood, 159 microg/ml; urine, 1100 microg/ml). Myocardial fibrosis, in the pattern associated with stimulant abuse, was also evident. The second decedent had a normal heart but higher concentrations of GHB (femoral blood, 1.4 mg/ml; right heart, 1.1 mg/ml; urine, 6.0 mg/ml). Blood cocaine and MDMA levels were 420 and 730 ng/ml, respectively. Both decedents had been drinking and were in a postabsorptive state, with blood to vitreous ratios of less than 0.90. If NaF is not used as a preservative, GHB is produced as an artifact. Therefore, the mere demonstration of GHB does not prove causality or even necessarily that GHB was ingested. Blood and urine GHB concentrations in case 1 can be produced by a therapeutic dose of 100 mg, and myocardial fibrosis may have had more to do with the cause of death than GHB. The history in case 2 is consistent with the substantial GHB ingestion, but other drugs, including ethanol, were also detected. Ethanol interferes with GHB metabolism, preventing GHB breakdown, raising blood concentrations, and making respiratory arrest more likely. Combined investigational, autopsy, and toxicology data suggest that GHB was the cause of death in case 2 but not case 1. Given the recent discovery that postmortem GHB production occurs even in stored antemortem blood samples (provided they were preserved with citrate) and the earlier observations that de novo GHB production in urine does not occur, it is unwise to draw any inferences about causality unless (1) blood and urine are both analyzed and found to be elevated; (2) blood is collected in NaF-containing tubes; and (3) a detailed case history is obtained.

Diphenhydramine (DPH)-related deaths in adults are extremely rare, and detailed autopsy studies are rarer still. Toxicologic and anatomic findings in 4 cases of suicidal DPH overdose are described and compared with findings in a database of cocaine- and heroin-related deaths. Blood DPH levels were many times higher than those considered therapeutic (5000-35,000 ng/ml versus 50-100 ng/ml). Marked pulmonary edema with visceral congestion was a constant finding. Mean lung-body weight ratios for DPH, cocaine, heroin, and trauma controls were 0.015, 0.015, 0.019, and 0.013, respectively. When normalized for body weight in this fashion, edema in DPH-related deaths was comparable to that in cocaine-related deaths. Cardiac enlargement was apparent in 3 of the 4 DPH cases, 1 with marked myocardial fibrosis. The finding of increased heart size suggests that preexisting heart disease may provide the necessary substrate for lethal cases of DPH toxicity. Pulmonary edema in these cases remains unexplained, with edema in cases of heroin-related toxicity significantly worse than that produced by cocaine or DPH (p < .0001). Because DPH and cocaine can exert similar effects on the heart, a common mechanism may produce pulmonary edema in both. A different mechanism may account for heroin-related edema.

During the last several years, a clearer understanding of cocaine's effects on the body has emerged. Metabolism and tissue distribution are better understood. A diverse group of cocaine-related illnesses have been reported, but many appear to share the underlying mechanism of catecholamine toxicity. Knowledge of cocaine's metabolism makes possible certain conclusions about route of ingestion, time of use, and patterns of abuse in general. Knowledge of the histologic alterations known to be associated with cocaine use can pinpoint cocaine as the cause of death, even in cases where there are negligible blood levels. What follows is a brief review of recent observations that bear on the forensic aspects of cocaine abuse.

Prolonged resuscitation in adults produces a recognizable pattern of myocardial injury characterized by contraction band necrosis, focal hemorrhage, and coagulation necrosis. To rule out the possibility of these changes being due to ischemia and underlying coronary artery disease, autopsies of 26 children admitted to Stanford from 1981 to 1983 were reviewed. Seventeen had attempted resuscitation with catecholamines and defibrillation; the remainder did not. Sections of myocardium were graded by two observers. For controls, brain-dead heart donors otherwise disease-free and essentially untreated with either defibrillation or beta-active catecholamines were used. Defibrillation alone and catecholamines alone each produced equal amounts of destruction, but using these together resulted in a statistically significant increase in tissue destruction. This suggests that the damaging effects of these agents are synergistic, not additive.