Forsome language educators, communicative-style language teaching, by definition, entails viewing the use of the learners’ first language (L1) as counterproductive to the learning process or as an unfortunate but sometimes necessary recourse. However, recent research has shown that L1 use can serve important cognitive, communicative, and social functions in communicative foreign and second language (L2) classrooms (Turnbull and Dailey-O’Cain, 2009; see also Butzkamm and Caldwell, 2009). The current article documentsanattitudinalsurveyof29‘native-Englishspeaker’teachersataJapaneseuniversitywhere theexclusiveuseofthetarget language is promoted as a key feature of the optimal foreign language learning environment. Results indicated that, contrary to the officialpolicy,manyteachersbelievedthatselectiveuseofthestudents’L1,bytheteacherorbystudents,couldenhanceL2learning in various ways within a communicative framework. The authors argue that teachers and students themselves are best placed to determine, based on the immediate context of the classroom, what constitutes optimal use of the target language and the L1. 2011 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.