1. Discussion on 'Analysis of Bingham fluid radial flow in smooth fractures' [J Rock Mech Geotech Eng 12 (2020) 1112–1118]
- Author
-
Jang Min Park, Van Thanh Hoang, and Wankun Liu
- Subjects
Mass flux ,Mass conservation equation ,Analytical solution ,0211 other engineering and technologies ,Engineering geology. Rock mechanics. Soil mechanics. Underground construction ,02 engineering and technology ,Mechanics ,010502 geochemistry & geophysics ,Geotechnical Engineering and Engineering Geology ,01 natural sciences ,Rock grouting ,Bingham fluid ,TA703-712 ,Radial flow ,Bingham plastic ,Conservation of mass ,Geology ,021101 geological & geomatics engineering ,0105 earth and related environmental sciences - Abstract
Recently, Zou et al. (2020a) published a theoretical analysis on the radial flow of a Bingham fluid, where they argued that the classical analysis by Dai and Bird (1981) violates the mass conservation. The present discussion aims to clarify this conflict between those two studies. It is noted that Zou et al. (2020a) presumed the gap-wise mass flux is negligible in the mass conservation equation, while Dai and Bird (1981) did not require so in their model, and this is found to be the origin of the conflict. In fact, Dai and Bird (1981)’s model is shown to not violate the mass conservation. Therefore, those two models should be viewed as separate models derived from different perspectives. Details of the major difference between the two models are discussed.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF