1. A comparative study between rubber band ligation and local application of herbal caustic compound (pratisaraneeya kshara) in management of internal haemorrhoids
- Author
-
Ashish Sharma, S.J. Gupta, and M. Sahu
- Subjects
medicine.medical_specialty ,business.industry ,medicine.medical_treatment ,0211 other engineering and technologies ,Anal Region ,02 engineering and technology ,Anal canal ,01 natural sciences ,Rubber band ligation ,0104 chemical sciences ,Surgery ,010404 medicinal & biomolecular chemistry ,medicine.anatomical_structure ,Complementary and alternative medicine ,Internal haemorrhoids ,021105 building & construction ,Sclerotherapy ,medicine ,Cauterization ,Defecation ,business ,Kshara - Abstract
Haemorrhoid is one of the most common anorectal complaints1,2 reported in anorectal clinics with estimated prevalence of 4.4% in United States and 13–36% in the United Kingdom.3 It is one of the oldest ills known to mankind with accounts available in oldest literature like Atharwaveda (1500 BCE)4 from India and Egyptian Papyrus (1700BCE)5 from the west. Haemorrhoids are actually the vascular cushions that provide a physiological hermetic seal in the closure mechanism of anal canal and helps in maintenance of continence.6 Faulty dietary and toilet habits may cause the pathological enlargement of these cushions which create misery to the patient by producing bleeding, discomfort, prolapse and sometimes pain in the anorectal region. A modification in diet, lifestyle and defecation habits can alleviate the symptoms in many patients. For the rest, various surgical methods like haemorrhoidectomy, stapled haemorrhoidopexy etc. and the office procedures like rubber band ligation, sclerotherapy, photocoagulation, cryosurgery etc. are available with each having its own merits and limitations compared to other. Though haemorrhoidectomy is still considered as the ‘gold standard’ treatment for haemorrhoids,7 office treatments for symptomatic haemorrhoids are increasing8 over the last few decades. Rubber Band Ligation (RBL), as advocated by Barron,9 is one of the safe, simple, cost-effective and the most widely used office procedure by the surgeons which eliminate the pile mass by ischemic necrosis and promote submucosal fibrosis with subsequent fixation of anal epithelium to the underlying sphincter.10 In traditional Indian medicine i.e. Ayurveda, the term arsha is used to describe an abnormal fleshy growth originating in the anal region due to improper diet, lifestyle and defecation habits.11 By definition, the term arsha may broadly include sentinel tags, hypertrophied papillae, polyps and external as well as internal piles; however, to be very specific, haemorrhoidal disease may be corresponded with raktarsha (rakta means ‘blood’ and arsha means ‘fleshy mass’), a variety of arsha described in ancient texts. The management strategies for haemorrhoids include four modalities of treatments viz. medicinal treatment, chemical cauterization, thermal cauterization and surgical excision.12 While medical management is primarily advocated for uncomplicated haemorrhoids and focusses upon improvement of digestion, easy evacuation and correction of bowel habits; large and complicated piles are advised to be treated with thermal cauterization or excised surgically. Chemical cauterization is a form of parasurgical measure which is employed by local application of a caustic material, pratisaraneeya kshara (PK; pratisaraneeya means ‘to be applied locally’, kshara means ‘alkaline caustics’) in internal haemorrhoids. It is prepared from the ashes of medicinal plants by a special technique of preparation with addition of marine shells13 and, on application, brings about necrosis in the pile mass resulting into an ulcer which heals by fibrosis.14 Local application of PK, also known as kshara-karma, is one of the most widely practiced outpatient treatments for internal haemorrhoids by the Ayurveda surgeons in India. Thus, both RBL and local application of PK have a similar mode of action and are the office procedures of choice for internal haemorrhoids among the modern and Ayurveda surgeons respectively. So, the present study was designed to compare the efficacy of these two techniques in a prospective randomized trial.
- Published
- 2020