1. Reliability of clinical outcome measures in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease
- Author
-
Solari, A, Laurà, M, Salsano, E, Radice, D, Pareyson, D, CMT TRIAAL, Sg, Marelli, C, Scaioli, V, Ciano, C, Rimoldi, M, Lauria, G, Rizzetto, E, Camozzi, F, Schenone, Angelo, Grandis, Marina, Narciso, E, Nobbio, L, Benedetti, L, Rizzuto, N, Fabrizi, Gm, Cavallaro, T, Bertolasi, L, Casano, A, Santoro, L, Manganelli, F, Pisciotta, C, Nolano, M, Vita, G, Mazzeo, A, Di Leo, R, Girlanda, P, Majorana, G, Aguennouz, M, Ciranni, A, Lanzano, N, Quattrone, A, Valentino, P, Nisticò, R, Pirritano, D, Clodomiro, A, Canino, M, Padua, L, Pazzaglia, C, Mignogna, T, Gemignani, F, Brindani, F, Vitetta, F, Visioli, F, Bogani, P, Hughes, Ra, Schenone, A, Mancardi, GIOVANNI LUIGI, Cavaletti, G, Galimberti, S, Calabrese, D, Ferrari, G, Sereda, Mw, Lauria, G., Solari, A, Laurà, M, Salsano, E, Radice, D, Pareyson, D, The CMT TRIAAL Study, G, Cavaletti, G, Marelli, C, Scaioli, V, Ciano, C, Rimoldi, M, Lauria, G, Rizzetto, E, Camozzi, F, Schenone, A, Grandis, M, Narciso, E, Nobbio, L, Benedetti, L, Rizzuto, N, Fabrizi, G, Cavallaro, T, Bertolasi, L, Casano, A, Santoro, L, Manganelli, F, Pisciotta, C, Nolano, M, Vita, G, Mazzeo, A, Di Leo, R, Girlanda, P, Majorana, G, Aguennouz, M, Ciranni, A, Lanzano, N, Quattrone, A, Valentino, P, Nisticò, R, Pirritano, D, Clodomiro, A, Canino, M, Padua, L, Pazzaglia, C, Mignogna, T, Gemignani, F, Brindani, F, Vitetta, F, Bogani, P, Hughes, R, Visioli, F, Mancardi, G, Galimberti, S, Calabrese, D, Ferrari, G, and Sereda, M
- Subjects
Male ,instrumentation/methods ,Predictive Value of Test ,Isometric exercise ,Ascorbic Acid ,Outcome measures ,Randomised clinical trial ,Tooth disease ,Disability Evaluation ,Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease ,Medicine ,Genetics (clinical) ,Reliability (statistics) ,Reliability ,Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease ,Observer Variation ,Neurologic Examination ,Muscle Weakness ,innervation/physiopathology ,Skeletal ,Middle Aged ,Treatment Outcome ,Neurology ,Predictive value of tests ,Arm ,Muscle ,Female ,medicine.symptom ,Foot (unit) ,Human ,Muscle Weakne ,Muscle Contraction ,Restraint, Physical ,Adult ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Adolescent ,Movement ,education ,Reproducibility of Result ,diagnosis/etiology/therapy ,Restraint ,Adolescent, Adult, Aged, Arm ,innervation/physiopathology, Ascorbic Acid ,therapeutic use, Charcot-Marie-Tooth Disease ,diagnosis/drug therapy/physiopathology, Disability Evaluation, Female, Humans, Leg ,physiopathology, Male, Middle Aged, Movement ,physiology, Muscle Contraction ,physiology, Muscle Weakness ,diagnosis/etiology/therapy, Muscle ,innervation/physiopathology, Neurologic Examination ,instrumentation/methods, Observer Variation, Placebo Effect, Predictive Value of Tests, Reproducibility of Results, Restraint ,Physical ,instrumentation/methods, Treatment Outcome ,Physical medicine and rehabilitation ,Predictive Value of Tests ,Humans ,Muscle, Skeletal ,Aged ,Leg ,business.industry ,Muscle weakness ,Reproducibility of Results ,Ascorbic acid ,Placebo Effect ,diagnosis/drug therapy/physiopathology ,body regions ,therapeutic use ,Pediatrics, Perinatology and Child Health ,physiology ,Physical therapy ,Neurology (clinical) ,physiopathology ,business - Abstract
We assessed inter- and intra-rater reliability of outcome measures in Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease (CMT) patients. In 40 CMT patients, we assessed reliability of Overall Neuropathy Limitations Scale (ONLS), 10-m timed walk (T10MW), 9-hole-peg test (9-HPT), maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) of arm (elbow flexion, hand-grip, and three-point pinch) and leg (knee extension, foot dorsiflexion/plantar flexion). Reliability was substantial for ONLS, excellent for T10MW and 9-HPT. For MVIC, inter and intra-rater reliability was excellent for hand contractions; for leg contractions, intra-rater agreement was moderate to substantial, whereas inter-rater agreement was poor. An ad hoc device was produced to immobilize the foot and MVIC reliability was re-assessed in 26 CMT patients, resulting in excellent inter-rater and intra-rater reliability for foot dorsiflexion, and clear inter-rater improvement for foot plantar flexion. All outcome measures appear adequate for CMT assessment. Use of an immobilization device improves foot MVIC reliability, preventing biased findings in patients with greater strength.
- Published
- 2008