The author comments on how George Bush described Russia as a democracy when its president, Vladimir Putin, visited Camp David two weeks ago. As two elections this week have confirmed, Russian democracy is a cynical joke. In Chechnya, serious challengers to the Kremlin's preferred candidate, Akhmad Kadyrov, were encouraged or forced out of the race; voters and electoral officials were bribed or threatened; opposition supporters were intimidated and sometimes even killed; and, just to make sure, the vote itself was a fraud of a kind befitting an African dictatorship. Meanwhile, Valentina Matvienko won the governorship of St Petersburg after an election campaign that was wholly biased in her favour. Mr Putin himself publicly endorsed her, a breach of election law that the head of the federal elections commission blamed on the media--after all, they had reported his remarks. The prosecutors' attacks on Mikhail Khodorkovsky, Russia's richest man, that began this summer have made one thing clear: in Russia, the rule of law is that those who rule are the law. There is, of course, another picture of Russia, one painted by the investors flooding in at a rate not seen since its economic collapse five years ago. To thrive in the long term, Russia will have to be democratic, but for now this is the best one can expect. But if western leaders can ignore such issues as Chechnya and accept that Russia is not a democracy, they should at least stop pretending that it is.