Search

Ralph HB Benedict,1 Pamela Vo,2 Nicholas Adlard,2 Olwyn Grennan,3 Ashley Enstone,4 Daisy Bridge,4 Robin Wyn,4 Stanley L Cohan5 1Department of Neurology, Jacobs School of Medicine and Biomedical Sciences, Buffalo, NY, USA; 2Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, Switzerland; 3Novartis Ireland, Dublin, Ireland; 4Adelphi Values PROVE, Bollington, UK; 5Providence Brain and Spine Institute, Providence St. Joseph Health, Portland, OR, USACorrespondence: Pamela Vo, Email pamela.vo@novartis.comIntroduction: Cognitive impairment, especially relating to cognitive processing speed, is a major cause of disability in people with multiple sclerosis (MS). Utility values are quantitative estimates of the quality of life experienced in specific health states and are a key component of cost-effectiveness modelling. However, existing health state utility values in MS typically focus on physical ability and are generally derived using generic (not disease-specific) measures of quality of life. The objective of the current study was to generate health state utility values for levels of cognitive impairment. We used a direct utility elicitation approach called the time trade-off (TTO) methodology.Materials and Methods: Health state descriptions were created following interviews with healthcare professionals, patients, and caregivers in the United States (n=35), and with healthcare professionals in the UK (n=5). Three health states (mild, moderate, and severe impairment) were defined based upon a well-established and validated test for cognitive dysfunction called the Symbol Digit Modalities Test (SDMT) and described using qualitative interview findings. Next, interviews with members of the general public in the UK were conducted to estimate utility values for each health state using the TTO methodology. The procedure was based on the established Measurement and Valuation of Health (MVH) protocol, which generates values on a scale from 0.0 to 1.0.Results: Mean health state utility values were 0.77 ± 0.24 in “mild impairment” (SDMT 43-40), 0.57 ± 0.26 in “moderate impairment” (SDMT 39-32), and 0.34 ± 0.28 in “severe impairment” (SDMT ≤ 31).Discussion: Results indicate that the public perceives that health states of cognitive slowing (as observed in MS) are associated with a substantial reduction in affected individuals’ health-related quality of life, quantified using the TTO methodology. Future economic modeling should consider how utility impacts of both cognitive and physical disability can be appropriately incorporated.Keywords: cognitive impairment, processing speed, health state utility, health-related quality of life, multiple sclerosis, time trade-off

Paul O’Brien,1 Ashley Enstone,2 Daisy Bridge,2 Robin Wyn,2 Judit Banhazi3 1Novartis Ireland, Dublin, Ireland; 2Adelphi Values PROVE, Bollington, UK; 3Novartis Pharma AG, Basel, SwitzerlandCorrespondence: Paul O’Brien, Email paul-2.obrien@novartis.comIntroduction: Retinitis pigmentosa (RP) is an inherited retinal pathology associated with “night blindness” and progressive loss of peripheral vision, in some cases leading to complete blindness. Health state utility values are required for activities such as modelling disease burden or the cost-effectiveness of new interventions. The current study aimed to generate utility values for health states of varying levels of functional vision in RP, with members of the general public in the UK.Methods: Five health states were defined according to standard clinical measures of visual ability. Health state descriptions were developed following interviews with patients with RP in the UK (n=5). Further interviews were conducted for confirmation with healthcare professionals with specific experience of managing patients with RP in the UK (n=2). Interviews with members of the general public in the UK were conducted to value health states. A time trade-off (TTO) process based on the established Measurement and Valuation of Health (MVH) protocol was used. Due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic, all interviews were web-enabled and conducted 1:1 by a trained moderator.Results: In total, n=110 TTO interviews were conducted with members of the UK general public. Mean TTO utility values followed the logical and expected order, with increasing visual impairment leading to decreased utility. Mean values varied between 0.78 ± 0.20 (“moderate impairment”), and 0.33 ± 0.26 (“hand motion” to “no light perception”). Supplementary visual analogue scale (VAS) scores also followed the logical and expected order: mean VAS values varied between 47.95 ± 15.38 (“moderate impairment”) and 17.22 ± 12.49 in (“hand motion” to “no light perception”).Discussion: These data suggest that individuals living with RP have substantially impaired quality of life. Utility values for RP have been elicited here using a method and sample that is suitable for economic modelling and health technology assessment purposes.Keywords: retinitis pigmentosa, inherited retinal disease, health state utility, health-related quality of life, time trade-off, vignette study