Search

It is suggested that it makes sense for dentists providing care for individual patients to take account of caries risk (as assessed by presentation of active, non-cavitated lesions) when deciding how to allocate time and effort of themselves and their staff. However, there is a question as to how realistic it is to ask the dental team to provide a full diagnostic assessment and all the preventive treatment required for a patient for the payment provided by 1 UDA. It is to be hoped that one or more of the Steele pilots will come up with a practical solution for controlling caries in NHS practice.

Since the invention and application of rotary instruments, the operative treatment of carious lesions has often resulted in considerable removal of tooth structure. More recently, newer techniques for removal of carious dentine have been developed in an attempt to minimise this excessive tissue loss. The following article reviews and discusses some of the techniques available to excavate demineralised dentine clinically. These methods can be classified as mechanical and non-mechanical, rotary and non-rotary and include: dental handpieces/burs, manual excavators, air-abrasion, air-polishing, ultrasonication, sono-abrasion, chemo-mechanical methods, lasers and enzymes. The advantages and disadvantages of each technique are discussed.

Objective: The objectives of this study were: to evaluate carers' knowledge of oral health; to provide a high quality, consistent, oral health training programme for carers in residential homes; to evaluate the quality of this programme by examining both carers' changes in knowledge and any changes in carers' behaviour as reported by residents and to assess any changes in the oral health of the elderly residents after one year., Design: A cross-sectional, multi-centre study using a carer training programme, evaluated by both a questionnaire conducted with carers and residents and oral examination of residents., Setting: In August 1996, 20 (20%) of the residential/nursing homes, in West Hertfordshire were chosen at random and all managers contacted and offered an oral examination for all their residents. Ten (10%) of the homes were also offered an oral health training programme for their carers. Eighteen homes accepted the oral examination for all consenting residents and 7 of the 10 homes offered accepted the carer training., Subjects: Thirty-nine carers from 7 of the residential homes attended an oral health training course and 213 elderly residents in the 18 homes were examined both at baseline and after 12 months., Results: Carers' baseline knowledge about oral health was poor; the oral health training programme was enjoyed and their knowledge gain after one week was high. However, the elderly residents perceived no change in the oral care given by carers either after one week or after one year and there was no measurable improvement in the oral health of residents after carer training, except for an increase in filled coronal surfaces. Few of the carers originally trained were still working in the same residential homes after one year., Conclusion: Although the carer training programme was well received, no changes in oral health practice resulted. Barriers to practice of oral care by carers remained and training, even when including practical skills, evaluation by peers and a high knowledge gain, failed to reduce these barriers.

Objective: The aim of this study was to investigate the attitudes of elderly residents to using an antimicrobial chewing gum as an aid to oral health, and the opinion of their carers on such a procedure., Design: A cross-sectional, multi-centre survey using a structured interview/questionnaire conducted with elderly residents and their carers., Setting: In January 1998, 9 residential/nursing homes were chosen at random from all the homes in West Hertfordshire, 207 residents were asked to chew two pieces of gum twice daily for 7 days., Subjects: The participants, 148 women and 59 men, were aged between 53-100 years (mean age 82.23 +/- 9.62 years). 47 carers, all female, were involved in distributing and collecting the gum., Results: 122 residents (58.9%) were edentulous and 85 (41%) of the participants were partially dentate. Of those with teeth 23 (27%) had 21 teeth or more. 73 (35.2%) residents found that chewing the gum was difficult with 37 (17.9%) of this group being unable to chew (P < 0.0001 for those residents with no teeth/dentures or dentures unopposed by teeth or other dentures). 32 (18.6%) subjects disliked the flavour of the gum. Of the 170 residents who chewed the gum 99 (57.2%) found it reduced oral dryness and 78 (45.1%) reported it made their mouth feel healthy. 34 (53.6%) of the dentate and 47 (40.9%) of the edentate residents wished to keep using the gum (P < 0.05). 35 (74.5%) of the carers found it easy to distribute the gum and 29 (61.7%) thought that chewing gum was an acceptable method of maintaining oral health for residents., Conclusion: The antimicrobial gum investigated in this study was acceptable to many elderly occupants and their carers, significantly improving perceived oral health and oral dryness of residents.

Objective: An in-vitro study to examine the correlation between the distribution of the autofluorescent signal emitted from carious dentine (detected using confocal laser scanning microscopy) and its microhardness, within the depths of human dentine lesions., Materials and Methods: Twelve carious teeth were sectioned longitudinally, the cut faces marked with a grid reference line system and colour photomicrographs taken. The same samples were imaged using confocal laser-scanning microscopy for autofluorescence and then subjected to microhardness testing using a Knoop microhardness indenter. Adjacent sound dentine was used as a control reference. Digital image superimposition allowed direct comparisons to be made between the colour, autofluorescence and microhardness of each lesion., Results: Sound enamel and dentine did not autofluorescence. Autofluorescence distribution from carious dentine correlated with the highly softened tissue (detected using the Knoop indenter) and terminated at a level superficial to the translucent zone. This zone was still pigmented. Normal, sound dentine hardness levels were found deep to the translucent zone., Conclusions: A correlation existed between the zone of autofluorescence and carious dentine that was markedly softened by the carious process. These findings highlighted a possibility that the autofluorescence might be used as an in-vitro, objective histological marker for the softened, carious dentine requiring clinical excavation.

Aim: To compare diagnostic yield in caries diagnosis from D- and E-speed films., Design: A laboratory study., Setting: A UK dental school between 1992 and 1994., Materials and Methods: 96 extracted teeth containing approximal and occlusal lesions, but representing a low caries prevalence sample, were set in occluding dental arches. Bitewing radiographs were taken and interpreted by 5 examiners for the presence or absence of caries. Each examiner was also asked which film image he or she subjectively liked best., Main Outcome Measures: The teeth were subsequently sectioned and histologically examined to validate diagnostic decisions., Results: For all film types the percentage of lesions with caries histologically in dentine correctly identified radiologically (sensitivity) was low (approximal caries 8-22%; occlusal caries 0-30%). The number of sound dentine sites correctly identified (specificity) was high (approximal caries 98-100%; occlusal caries 79-100%). There were no significant differences between D- and E-speed films. Sensitivity was unaffected by each examiner's subjective preference for a particular film. The variation in sensitivity of diagnosis was due to differences between examiners., Conclusions: The reluctance of many GDPs to use E-speed film because they 'do not like the image' cannot be endorsed or supported. Both E-speed film types examined can be recommended for use in general practice.

In the UK cavity preparation at the enamel-dentine junction (EDJ) is considered complete when all soft and/or stained tissue is removed. The aim of the present work was to link the clinical criteria of dentine consistency and dentine colour with the microbiological status of the tissue. Cavities were prepared in 564 teeth. Under rubber dam, access to the EDJ was gained and the sample sites selected (n = 847). Their consistency was noted as hard or soft and wet or dry when probed. The colour of the site was noted as stain-free or stained. Dentine was sampled using a round bur. After microbiological processing the total anaerobic count and counts of mutans streptococci and lactobacilli were expressed as log10 [CFU per sample]. Soft sites harboured significantly more bacteria than hard sites (P < 0.001). Soft and wet sites harboured significantly more bacteria than soft and dry sites (P < 0.001). Stained and hard sites harboured more bacteria than stain-free and hard sites (P < 0.05) but this difference was not considered to be clinically relevant. The relatively simple clinical criteria used here correlated significantly with the microbial findings. All soft dentine must be removed at the EDJ to ensure minimal infection of the underlying hard dentine. However, it may not be necessary to continue preparation until the EDJ is also stain-free.

The diagnosis of occlusal caries depends upon the correct identification of demineralised enamel and dentine. However, tissue demineralisation precedes bacterial infection so that dentine may be demineralised but uninfected. The presence of a bacterial infection of dentine may be a more relevant factor to be considered when planning to restore a carious lesion. The aim of this clinical study was to validate three techniques for the diagnosis of occlusal caries as demineralised tissue and as infected demineralised tissue during cavity preparation. The study sample was 82 non-cavitated occlusal lesions, judged by various dentists to be in need of operative care. The diagnostic techniques used by the single operator were vision, bitewing radiography and electronic caries diagnosis. The validating techniques were a caries detector dye to stain demineralised tissue, microbiological sampling to determine the level of infection of the dentine and clinical assessment of the dentine at operation. The caries detector dye showed demineralised dentine in 96% of the referred lesions. This demineralisation was reliably predicted by the electronic readings. However, the dentine samples from many teeth yielded only small numbers of bacteria indicating no, or only a very low level of bacterial infection. Neither vision nor electronic readings reliably predict heavily infected dentine. Radiographic evidence of dentine demineralisation was significantly associated with heavily infected dentine and this dentine was soft and wet at operation.

Clinical and radiographic diagnosis of occlusal caries is difficult. Resistance measurements in pits and fissures have shown better sensitivity compared with the more conventional methods of diagnosis. Two machines have been manufactured for this purpose: the Vanguard and the Caries Meter L. The aims of this study were to calibrate the readouts of these machines against a variable standard resistance box and use the Vanguard to compare readings taken in vivo and in vitro after extraction of the teeth. The diagnostic accuracy of clinical, radiographic, Vanguard and Caries Meter L diagnoses were also assessed. One hundred occlusal sites in 40 teeth of 20 patients were investigated in vivo with the Vanguard, noting clinical and radiographic appearances. The teeth were then extracted and the Vanguard readings repeated in vitro, together with Caries Meter L readings. The in vivo/in vitro comparison between Vanguard readings showed excellent reproducibility (Cohen's Kappa = 0.80). The sensitivity and specificity for the different examination techniques at the enamel level of diagnosis were 27% and 89% for visual, 6% and 100% for radiographic, 81% and 78% for the Vanguard and 74% and 74% for the Caries Meter L. In conclusion, this study supports the renewed interest in resistance measurements as a diagnostic technique and indicates that the in vitro model used gives results comparable to those in vivo.

This paper describes the use of a questionnaire designed to enable students to comment on aspects of the teaching they received from their tutor during the preclinical course in Conservative Dentistry. The information was subsequently used by the teachers themselves, to modify their performance.

Secondary caries is difficult to diagnose accurately. The purpose of this laboratory study was to investigate various non-invasive clinical and radiographic criteria which might predict the presence of carious dentine beneath the margin of the filling. A total of 331 sites, each 3 mm in length on the tooth restoration margin, were selected on 112 extracted and filled teeth. Thirty of these sites showed obvious carious cavities. Ditching was apparent in a further 70 sites, while 231 sites were clinically intact. Staining of the margin of the filling was recorded and radiographs were taken of posterior teeth. Restorations were then removed and the enamel-dentine junction (EDJ) immediately below the sites was examined for its consistency (hard/soft) and colour (stained/stain-free). Results showed that staining around a filling is not a reliable predictor of softening or discolouration of the dentine beneath. A clinical carious cavity and radiographic evidence of demineralisation indicate soft and discoloured dentine and should trigger operative intervention, while ditching alone should not.

During cavity preparation conventional tactile and optical criteria are used to assess the caries status of the enamel-dentine junction, cavity preparation being considered complete when this area is hard to a sharp probe and stain free. In the present study 201 cavities were prepared under rubber dam. When caries removal was considered complete using the conventional tactile and optical criteria, a caries detector dye (1% acid red in propylene glycol), which is claimed to stain 'infected' tissue red, was applied. Fifty-two per cent of cavities showed caries dye stain in some part of the enamel-dentine junction. Subsequent microbiological sampling of dye-stained and dye-unstained sites resulted in the recovery of low numbers of bacteria and revealed no difference in the level of infection of the two sites. It is concluded that the conventional tactile and optical criteria are satisfactory assessments of the caries status of tissue during cavity preparation and that subsequent use of a caries detector dye on hard and stain-free dentine will result in unnecessary tissue removal.

This 'personal view' makes recommendations on the use of the bitewing radiograph in the diagnosis of dental caries on the basis of published evidence about the disease and available diagnostic methods. It suggests that posterior bitewing radiographs are required for all new patients if the approximal surfaces of the teeth cannot be examined directly. At this initial visit, an assessment of the caries risk of the individual patient should be made. Subsequent radiographic recall intervals are suggested, which are determined on the basis of this risk assessment. It should be appreciated that risk status may change over time and that, in the future, an individual's radiographic recall interval may have to be changed.

The purpose of this study was to examine histologically teeth containing 27 tooth-coloured restorations with both stained and unstained margins for comparison of their caries status. Histological examination of 56 cavity margins showed that early caries lesions were present adjacent to many stained and unstained margins, but were more likely to be present in the outer enamel and the enamel of the cavity wall where the margin was stained. Thus, the development of staining at the margin of the restoration is likely to indicate caries and the appropriate preventive measures should be instituted.

The aim of this paper was to re-assess the available literature examining the value of the bitewing radiograph in the diagnosis of approximal caries and to compare the relative values of radiographic and clinical examinations. To this end, results from 29 research studies have been re-presented and tabulated. These results show that the use of the bitewing radiograph is essential if much approximal caries is not to be missed. It is particularly important in the detection of the small lesion which may be managed preventively rather than operatively. Although there is a proper need to ensure that radiographic exposures are minimised, the evidence suggests that both clinicians and epidemiologists must balance this need with the ethical issues associated with failing to employ an established diagnostic aid.

The aim of this study was to compare the conventional visual and tactile method of detecting carious dentine during cavity preparation using a mirror, probe and excavator with a visual method enhanced by a dye. The dye, 1% acid red in propylene glycol, was used on 100 cavities prepared by dental students and passed as clinically satisfactory by their teachers. Results showed dye stain at the enamel-dentine junction in 57 cavities (57%) which had been assessed as caries-free in this area using conventional visual and tactile means. Subsequent laboratory work on extracted carious teeth confirmed histologically that the dye stains demineralised dentine. If clinicians consider it important to render the enamel-dentine junction caries-free, it might be prudent to use the dye as an aid to diagnosis in this area.