1. Methods for a blind analysis of isobar data collected by the STAR collaboration
- Author
-
J. K. Adkins, J. Porter, H. Z. Huang, Nasim, R. Fatemi, S. Vokal, Y. Hong, G. Xie, D. N. Svirida, J. C. Dunlop, L. Wen, Todd Kinghorn, K. Krueger, M. S. Daugherity, A. Pandav, M. U. Ashraf, C. Jena, Zubayer Ahammed, Y. J. Sun, Zebo Tang, J. C. Webb, M. Sergeeva, T. J. Humanic, I. Kisel, Z. J. Zhang, M. Tokarev, J. Putschke, Mate Csanad, C. J. Feng, Y. Li, Xuan Zhang, Siwei Luo, R. Seto, W. He, M. Kelsey, B. S. Page, Q. Y. Shou, N. Xu, P. Filip, M. Cherney, Xiangming Sun, D. P. Kikola, M. I. Nagy, S. Choudhury, Z. Yang, B. Stringfellow, T. Edmonds, Hanna Paulina Zbroszczyk, S. He, Jaroslav Bielcik, D. Kapukchyan, R. Pak, Hua Pei, A. S. Nunes, I. Vassiliev, N. Kulathunga Mudiyanselage, C. Perkins, I. G. Alekseev, J. L. Drachenberg, Olga Evdokimov, Y. Hu, T. Nonaka, M. A. Lisa, R. Kunnawalkam Elayavalli, R. Reed, Wei Li, Shize Yang, I. Upsal, Wei Xie, T. D. S. Stanislaus, F. Videbæk, L. K. Kosarzewski, A. Jentsch, J. D. Nam, Tong Liu, He Xinzhong, J. M. Nelson, W. J. Llope, A. Aparin, O. V. Rogachevskiy, H. H. Wieman, A. Quintero, B. J. Summa, Maria Zurek, P. Sorensen, A. V. Brandin, J. Adam, S. Lan, F. Seck, H. W. Ke, G. Odyniec, C. Zhong, S. Harabasz, K. Kauder, S. K. Radhakrishnan, M. Zyzak, N. Schmitz, J. D. Brandenburg, Yicheng Feng, Y. Shi, M. Posik, E. Shahaliev, A. Attri, Arkadiy Taranenko, P. Huo, Frank Jm Geurts, T. Galatyuk, Y. Yu, S. Ramachandran, H. M. Spinka, C. Li, J. Engelage, O. Eyser, L. Didenko, I. Chakaberia, R. Witt, Z. Chen, L. V. Nogach, J. L. Romero, S. Mioduszewski, G. Nigmatkulov, K. N. Barish, Diana Pawlowska, C. Zhou, B.R. Schweid, Lukas Kramarik, Sujit Kumar Tripathy, Sanjeev Kumar, Madan M. Aggarwal, Y. He, E. Finch, Robert Licenik, Anthony Robert Timmins, Isaac Mooney, Fuqiang Wang, J. B. Singh, Prithwish Tribedy, B. K. Srivastava, Joseph Kwasizur, Susumu Sato, J. H. Thomas, Shengli Huang, D. A. Morozov, J. M. Landgraf, Xiaofeng Luo, Roland Laszlo Pinter, Takafumi Niida, Hao Qiu, W. Solyst, D. Chen, Guo-Liang Ma, X. Sun, M. Shao, G. Van Buren, Daniel Nemes, Yinina Ma, Jie Zhao, S. Horvat, M. Strikhanov, Li Yi, S. S. Shi, X. Huang, A. A. Derevschikov, A. Kechechyan, H. Caines, D. Kalinkin, F-H. Chang, Q. Yang, J. Sandweiss, Yawen Wang, Xiaoyu Liu, Sergey Voloshin, Xinyue Ju, G. Agakishiev, P. Kravtsov, K. Jiang, D. Cebra, D. Zhang, Jing-Han Chen, Zhanwen Zhu, Yanjun Wu, S. Fazio, Xuliang Chen, T. G. Dedovich, A. Hamed, S. Esumi, Maria Stefaniak, G. S. Averichev, W. Zha, Vitaly Okorokov, J. R. Adams, R. Lacey, Bernd Surrow, N. Elsey, Alexander Kiselev, D. G. Underwood, Z. Chang, D. Kincses, W. B. Schmidke, X. Gou, C. A. Gagliardi, Gary Westfall, E. G. Judd, J. Chen, J. Jia, V. Bairathi, Peter Q. Liu, Nilay Shah, Lokesh Kumar, Lawrence Pinsky, Lukas Holub, Bedangadas Mohanty, D. Tlusty, A. Ewigleben, A. Francisco, G. Eppley, K. Yip, J. S. Wang, A. I. Sheikh, W. Guryn, J. Pluta, P. Chaloupka, N. Chankova-Bunzarova, Skipper Kagamaster, L. Ma, Y. Xu, Ting Lin, Z. J. Xu, R. E. Tribble, Y. Lin, J. Fedorisin, Z. Liu, Yunlan Ji, S. Trentalange, Y. H. Leung, W. Christie, B. Pawlik, Subhash Singha, Andrey Vasiliev, A. Gibson, B. K. Chan, Michal Sumbera, A. A. P. Suaide, S. Zhang, Catherine Tomkiel, Hank Crawford, X.G. Li, S. W. Wissink, D. Neff, Janet Elizabeth Seger, Y. Zhang, I. M. Deppner, Anju Bhasin, P. V. Shanmuganathan, Z. Zhang, K. Kang, Arabinda Behera, A. Lebedev, L. Adamczyk, N. K. Pruthi, L. C. Bland, Y. F. Xu, S. Kabana, R. S. Longacre, Chi Yang, M. Calderon De La Barca Sanchez, A. I. Hamad, M. L. Kabir, Sedigheh Jowzaee, Arghya Chatterjee, D. Mallick, G. Igo, J. Butterworth, M. Nie, Z. Ye, N. G. Minaev, F. Liu, Zuojia Wang, Miroslav Simko, Mariusz Przybycien, Q. H. Xu, X. Chu, Y. Yang, P. Seyboth, J. W. Harris, R. D. Majka, N. S. Lukow, Jan Vanek, Hiroyuki Sako, L. Fulek, Chi Zhang, Chong Kim, A. H. Tang, Pengdong Wang, H. G. Ritter, P. Federic, Jianping Cheng, N. R. Sahoo, E. Hoffman, Rafal Sikora, R. Bellwied, Xiaofeng Zhu, Ying Liang, G. Wang, A. Ogawa, N. Herrmann, I. G. Bordyuzhin, J. A. Mazer, Y. Fisyak, Christina Markert, H. S. Matis, Z. Moravcova, W. W. Jacobs, J. Lauret, P. Szymanski, Yevheniia Khyzhniak, R. Lednicky, L. Kochenda, T. Tarnowsky, Z. Tu, Zhigang Xiao, T. Huang, M. Chevalier, Yunpeng Liu, Derek Anderson, Y. Panebratsev, D. Grosnick, Jongmin Lee, R. L. Ray, B. Kimelman, R. Ma, D. Isenhower, J. Rusnak, M. Kocan, L. Ruan, T. Ljubicic, Samuel Heppelmann, Jana Bielcikova, K. Nayak, Niseem Magdy, F. G. Atetalla, O. D. Tsai, E. P. Sichtermann, Seongshik Oh, P. C. Weidenkaff, W. Q. Shen, K. Gopal, T. Ullrich, H. S. Xu, H. Liu, David Stewart, E. C. Aschenauer, S. Margetis, X. Dong, Sevil Salur, D. Keane, and Nikolai Smirnov
- Subjects
Physics ,Nuclear and High Energy Physics ,010308 nuclear & particles physics ,Star (game theory) ,Order (ring theory) ,FOS: Physical sciences ,01 natural sciences ,High Energy Physics - Experiment ,Combinatorics ,High Energy Physics - Experiment (hep-ex) ,Nuclear Energy and Engineering ,Reference sample ,0103 physical sciences ,Isobar ,Magnetic effect ,Experimental methods ,Nuclear Experiment (nucl-ex) ,010306 general physics ,Nuclear Experiment - Abstract
In 2018, the STAR collaboration collected data from $$_{44}^{96}{\mathrm{Ru}}+_{44}^{96}{\mathrm{Ru}}$$ and $$_{40}^{96}{\mathrm{Zr}}+_{40}^{96}{\mathrm{Zr}}$$ at $$\sqrt{s_\text {NN}}=200$$ GeV to search for the presence of the chiral magnetic effect in collisions of nuclei. The isobar collision species alternated frequently between $$_{44}^{96}{\mathrm{Ru}}+_{44}^{96}{\mathrm{Ru}}$$ and $$_{40}^{96}{\mathrm{Zr}}+_{40}^{96}{\mathrm{Zr}}$$ . In order to conduct blind analyses of studies related to the chiral magnetic effect in these isobar data, STAR developed a three-step blind analysis procedure. Analysts are initially provided a “reference sample” of data, comprised of a mix of events from the two species, the order of which respects time-dependent changes in run conditions. After tuning analysis codes and performing time-dependent quality assurance on the reference sample, analysts are provided a species-blind sample suitable for calculating efficiencies and corrections for individual $$\approx 30$$ -min data-taking runs. For this sample, species-specific information is disguised, but individual output files contain data from a single isobar species. Only run-by-run corrections and code alteration subsequent to these corrections are allowed at this stage. Following these modifications, the “frozen” code is passed over the fully un-blind data, completing the blind analysis. As a check of the feasibility of the blind analysis procedure, analysts completed a “mock data challenge,” analyzing data from $${\mathrm{Au}}+{\mathrm{Au}}$$ collisions at $$\sqrt{s_\text {NN}}=27$$ GeV, collected in 2018. The $${\mathrm{Au}}+{\mathrm{Au}}$$ data were prepared in the same manner intended for the isobar blind data. The details of the blind analysis procedure and results from the mock data challenge are presented.
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF