1. A continuing controversy: magnesium sulfate in the treatment of eclamptic seizures
- Author
-
Kaplan, Peter W., Lesser, Ronald P., Fisher, Robert S., Repke, John T., and Hanley, Daniel F.
- Subjects
Eclampsia -- Drug therapy ,Magnesium sulphate -- Evaluation ,Magnesium sulphate -- Health aspects ,Convulsions -- Drug therapy ,Pregnancy, Complications of -- Care and treatment ,Phenytoin -- Health aspects ,Health - Abstract
Preeclampsia, also called toxemia of pregnancy, is a condition of hypertension, proteinuria, and edema that usually occurs in the third trimester of pregnancy. The condition may progress to eclampsia, or seizures and coma. The physiological mechanisms underlying eclampsia are not understood, and therapy is limited to treating symptoms. Many clinicians advocate the continued use of magnesium sulfate in the treatment of eclamptic seizures, but this has led to some confusion. Magnesium sulfate is not an anticonvulsant. Magnesium sulfate has found some use in the treatment of selected cases of cerebral ischemia (decreased blood flow in the brain), and it may turn out that its value in eclampsia results from a similar ''anti-brain damage'' effect. However, the authors state that when seizures occur, anticonvulsant therapy must be initiated. Since eclamptic seizures are electrophysiologically indistinguishable from generalized tonic-clonic seizures, it does not seem unreasonable to apply similar treatment. Such treatment includes, of course, drugs such as phenytoin (dilantin). Compared with magnesium sulfate, phenytoin causes fewer side effects, is better tolerated by patients, and has a lower incidence of hypotonic contractions. The authors emphasize that they are not addressing the use of magnesium sulfate in the treatment of preeclampsia, or whether magnesium sulfate might modify some of the physiological factors leading to eclampsia. They suggest, however, that rather than continue to accept without challenge the preeminence of magnesium sulfate in the treatment of eclampsia, the effectiveness of different agents in the control of eclamptic seizures should be evaluated by controlled clinical trials. (Consumer Summary produced by Reliance Medical Information, Inc.)
- Published
- 1990