To provide an insight into the oxidation behavior of cysteines in myofibrillar proteins (MPs) during microwave heating (MW), a quantitative redox proteomic analysis based on the isobaric iodoacetyl tandem mass tag technology was applied in this study. MPs from silver carp muscles were subjected to MW and water bath heating (WB) with the same time-temperature profiles to eliminate the thermal differences caused by an uneven energy input. Altogether, 422 proteins were found to be differentially expressed after thermal treatments as compared to that with no heat treatment. However, MW triggered a larger number of proteins and cysteine sites for oxidation. Myosin heavy chain, myosin-binding protein C, nebulin, α-actinin-3-like, and titin were found to be highly susceptible to oxidation under microwave irradiation. Notably, MW caused such modifications at cysteine site 9 in the head of myosin, revealing the enhancement mechanism of MP gelation by excess cysteine cross-linking during microwave processing. Furthermore, Gene Ontology and functional enrichment analyses suggested that the two thermal treatments resulted in some differences in ion binding, muscle cell development, and protein-containing complex assembly. Overall, this study is the first to report the redox proteomic changes caused by MW and WB treatments, thus providing a further understanding of the microwave-induced oxidative modifications of MPs.