1. Charcot's paradox
- Author
-
Maren de Moraes E Silva, Hélio A.G. Teive, Alex Tiburtino Meira, Carlos Henrique Ferreira Camargo, and Olivier Walusinski
- Subjects
Animal Experimentation ,congenital, hereditary, and neonatal diseases and abnormalities ,Psychoanalysis ,media_common.quotation_subject ,Neuropathology ,história ,0603 philosophy, ethics and religion ,lcsh:RC321-571 ,Neurologia ,03 medical and health sciences ,0302 clinical medicine ,Affection ,Animals ,Humans ,Animal species ,Jean-Martin Charcot ,lcsh:Neurosciences. Biological psychiatry. Neuropsychiatry ,media_common ,Human studies ,History, 19th Century ,06 humanities and the arts ,Neuroanatomy ,Neurology ,060301 applied ethics ,Neurology (clinical) ,history ,Psychology ,030217 neurology & neurosurgery - Abstract
Jean-Martin Charcot (1825-1893), considered the father of modern neurology, had a particular interest in pathology and learned to value anatomical findings. Among his main contributions is the use of the anatomo-clinical method in neurology. Although described as cold and impatient in his interpersonal relations, Charcot had a great affection for animals. He had two dogs in his home, which he called Carlo and Sigurd, and a little monkey, Rosalie. Despite his fascination with neuropathology and anatomo-clinical correlations, Charcot disapproved of studies using animal species other than humans, a seemingly paradoxical attitude. As a result, Charcot's human studies resulted in important advances in neurology as, prior to his research, anatomical observations of animals were extrapolated to humans, leading to conceptual errors. RESUMO Jean-Martin Charcot (1825-1893), considerado o pai da neurologia moderna, teve sua formação direcionada para a patologia, aprendendo a valorizar achados anatômicos. Entre as principais contribuições de Charcot está o uso do método anatomoclínico aplicado à neurologia. Descrito como frio e impaciente em suas relações interpessoais, Charcot mostrava, no entanto, um grande afeto pelos animais. Ele tinha dois cachorros em sua residência, a quem chamou de Carlo e Sigurd, e uma pequena macaca, Rosalie. Apesar de sua fascinação com a neuropatologia e as correlações anatomoclínicas, Charcot foi contra estudos com outras espécies de animais que não humanos, o que pode parecer um paradoxo. Entretanto, seus estudos trouxeram avanços importantes para a Neurologia, uma vez que, antes de suas descobertas, as observações anatômicas dos animais eram extrapoladas para os humanos, levando a erros conceituais.