There are two basic methods of dealing with the alcoholic in Scotland--treatment in hospital and confinement in prison. The treatment an alcoholic receives in hospital varies with the kind of hospital. In a medical ward of a general hospital he receives treatment for the physical ill effects of chronic alcoholism. Alcoholics also form an important group in the admissions to the psychiatric units of general hospitals. Studies of such units in Glasgow do not show a high success rate with alcoholics. These units may have to contend with the negative attitude of the general medical staff to alcoholism as well as the patient's tendency "to use a hospital as a port of call during a storm rather than as a convenient site for major repairs". Their work is also hampered by insufficient trained staff for intensive treatment. A specialized "Alcoholism Unit" where alcoholics both live and receive treatment in a separate unit is less likely to have these particular difficulties. Follows up studies of the unit attached to the Royal Edinburgh Hospital show that 68 per cent were abstinent after 18 months. Most alcoholics in Scottish mental hospitals, however, are treated in the acute admission wards. McCance and McCance, from a comparison of the effects of psychotherapy, aversion therapy and ward routine, suggest these are less important in relation to outcome than certain characteristics which individual alcoholics have. The better success rates enjoyed by some hospitals may be a function of this. McCance and McCance found poor outcome was associated, among other factors, with the alcoholic who belonged to a heavy drinking subculture, lived alone, drank cheap wine, had unstable marital relations and police convictions and was of low social class. The situation of chronic drunkenness offenders is unique as they are held responsible and punished for acts which most of the medical profession would consider, in at least a high proportion of cases, to be the result of a disease. Compulsory treatment has been offered as an alternative in some States in the U.S.A. and has met with some success. The particular characteristics of this group-occupational instability, homelessness and personal isolation however must be considered in the development of an appropriate treatment. The establishment of "half-way houses" which have simple but firm rules and are run on "communal" lines is an attempt to provide a place where the Skid Row alcoholic can start to interact and resume social relations that have lapsed. Schemes attempting to return the Skid Row alcoholic to an independent life without resort to alcohol are particularly important because the Skid Row alcoholic shows many of the characteristics which occur in those who fail to benefit from hospital treatment. Alcoholism is a serious mental health problem in Scotland. It is in all probability becoming more serious. There is an urgent need for the development of adequate facilities, especially for those alcoholics with "less favourable features". Above all, and, most urgently, the treatment of the chronic draukenness offender must be removed from its present penal context. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]