1. The anatomy of unbelief : a critical assessment of the cognitive science of (non)religion
- Author
-
Ovsepyan, Mari and McGrath, Alister
- Subjects
Secularism ,Philosophy and cognitive science ,Theology ,Religion ,Humanities - Abstract
A number of scholars of (non)religion and secularity have argued in recent years for the need to get beyond the neat binaries and the negative identities signalled by atheism and agnosticism (e.g., Taves, Asprem and Ihm 2018). However, these binaries are deeply ingrained in the landscape of ideas that have shaped the way we do scholarship. In this thesis, I critically investigate the approach called cognitive science of religion (CSR), which Justin Barrett and Emily Burdett describe as "the scientific approach to the study of religion that combines methods and theory from cognitive, developmental and evolutionary psychology with the sorts of questions that animate anthropologists and historians of religion" developed to further the understanding of "the reasons for initial acquisition, recurrence, and continued transmission of religious concepts and behaviour" (2011: 252). My main focus is the way CSR defines and studies nonreligion. This work consists of the two moves: the deconstructive and the reconstructive. In the deconstructive part, I challenge the "C" (cognition) and the "R" (religion and nonreligion) models employed by this field. In the reconstructive part, I propose a biocultural approach that replaces the computational paradigm with 4E cognition theories, and the belief/unbelief binary with material religion and secularisms. One of the "umbrella" problems I focus on in this thesis is the issue of disembodiment that I have discovered to be central to the majority of the CSR approaches to nonreligion. Therefore, the word "anatomy" in the title of this thesis is meant to highlight the theoretical and methodological concern of my approach, which is focused on materialising the field of CSR. My focus on the "anatomy of unbelief" aims to challenge the current CSR approach by bringing the body and the culture back into the scientific study of nonreligion.
- Published
- 2022