Search

Abstract Background Accurate detection of human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) gene amplification via fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) is necessary to determine HER2 status. Although many attempts have been made to increase the consistency of the results, the actual situation still needs to be determined. To investigate the latest interlaboratory variability of HER2 FISH testing for breast cancer, a multicenter proficiency-testing ring study was conducted in China. Methods A total of ten samples, each exhibiting distinct HER2 signal patterns and genetic heterogeneity, were distributed to 169 laboratories for HER2 FISH analysis. Data comprising both the results of the tests and feedback from questionnaires were compiled for comprehensive evaluation. Results The overall agreement among the participating laboratories was substantial to almost perfect, with a Fleiss’ kappa value of 0.765–0.911. However, it is important to note that cases with characteristics of HER2 signals near the critical cutoff range or with genetic heterogeneity showed lower congruence, poorer reproducibility, and higher variability (Fleiss’ kappa: 0.582). Our questionnaire showed that 52.2% (86/168) of the participants did not perform validation after their operation procedures or interpretation criteria were updated, and 75.6% (121/160) of the participants did not establish standard interpretation procedures. Since these laboratories showed worse performance (P

ABSTRACT Chlamydia trachomatis (CT) is a significant sexually transmitted pathogen known to evoke severe complications, including infertility. Nucleic acid amplification tests (NAATs) are recommended by the World Health Organization to detect CT infection. Furthermore, the establishment of methods, performance validation, internal quality control, and external quality assessment for CT NAATs necessitate the utilization of quality control materials (QCs). QCs are specimens or solutions that are analyzed for quality control purposes in a test system. In this study, we established a novel cell line that stably integrates CT amplification target sequences for producing QCs for CT NAATs. Utilizing clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats/CRISPR-associated protein 9 technology, we integrated the CT plasmid-mediated sequence (comprising the full length of the cryptic plasmid and the major outer membrane protein gene, 9,136 bp) into the MUC4 gene of HEK293T cells. Positive clones were screened through flow cytometric sorting, single-cell culture, and PCR-based identification, followed by the establishment of stable cell lines. These cells were then processed using optimized cell preservation procedures to prepare QCs. The sequence insertion copy number was confirmed by real-time quantitative PCR. This novel CT QCs demonstrate excellent clinical applicability, non-infectiousness, quantifiability, and stability. With an integrated sequence exceeding 9 kb in length, it offers exceptional flexibility for adapting to new kit developments. Furthermore, maintaining a well-defined copy number and stable shelf life, the QCs closely aligns with the quality control requirements of CT NAATs. This study presents an innovative method for preparing QCs for CT nucleic acid detection, making a valuable contribution to improving the performance of CT NAATs.IMPORTANCEUntreated CT infections impose significant burdens on individuals and communities, underscoring the importance of early and accurate testing via CT NAATs for disease control. QCs are instrumental in identifying testing process issues. Hence, we developed a cell line integrating CT-amplified target sequences as readily accessible non-infectious QCs. These QCs boast several advantages: the integration of over 9 kb of CT sequence allows for broad applicability, allowing flexible adaptation to the development of new kits. Confirming the CT sequence copy number provides a reliable basis for QC concentration preparation and kit detection limit evaluation. Optimized preservation protocol enhances QC stability during storage, facilitating convenient shipment to clinical laboratories at ambient temperatures. In summary, our novel CT QCs offer a powerful tool for improving CT NAAT performance and present a fresh perspective on QC preparation for detecting nucleic acids from intracellular parasitic pathogens.

Abstract Targeted panel-based tumor mutation burden (TMB) assays are widely employed to guide immunotherapy for patients with solid tumors. However, the accuracy and consistency of this method can be compromised due to the variability in technical details across different laboratories, particularly in terms of panel size, somatic mutation detection and TMB calculation rules. Currently, systematic evaluations of the impact of these technical factors on existing assays and best practice recommendations remain lacking. We assessed the performance of 50 participating panel-based TMB assays involving 38 unique methods using cell line samples. In silico experiments utilizing TCGA MC3 datasets were performed to further dissect the impact of technical factors. Here we show that the panel sizes beyond 1.04 Mb and 389 genes are necessary for the basic discrete accuracy, as determined by over 40,000 synthetic panels. The somatic mutation detection should maintain a reciprocal gap of recall and precision less than 0.179 for reliable psTMB calculation results. The inclusion of synonymous, nonsense and hotspot mutations could enhance the accuracy of panel-based TMB assay. A 5% variant allele frequency cut-off is suitable for TMB assays using tumor samples with at least 20% tumor purity. In conclusion, this multicenter study elucidates the major technical factors as sources of variability in panel-based TMB assays and proposed comprehensive recommendations for the enhancement of accuracy and consistency. These findings will assist clinical laboratories in optimizing the methodological details through bioinformatic experiments to enhance the reliability of panel-based methods.

Abstract Background Genomic DNA reference materials are widely recognized as essential for ensuring data quality in omics research. However, relying solely on reference datasets to evaluate the accuracy of variant calling results is incomplete, as they are limited to benchmark regions. Therefore, it is important to develop DNA reference materials that enable the assessment of variant detection performance across the entire genome. Results We established a DNA reference material suite from four immortalized cell lines derived from a family of parents and monozygotic twins. Comprehensive reference datasets of 4.2 million small variants and 15,000 structural variants were integrated and certified for evaluating the reliability of germline variant calls inside the benchmark regions. Importantly, the genetic built-in-truth of the Quartet family design enables estimation of the precision of variant calls outside the benchmark regions. Using the Quartet reference materials along with study samples, batch effects are objectively monitored and alleviated by training a machine learning model with the Quartet reference datasets to remove potential artifact calls. Moreover, the matched RNA and protein reference materials and datasets from the Quartet project enables cross-omics validation of variant calls from multiomics data. Conclusions The Quartet DNA reference materials and reference datasets provide a unique resource for objectively assessing the quality of germline variant calls throughout the whole-genome regions and improving the reliability of large-scale genomic profiling.

As a biomarker that affects treatment decisions of immune checkpoint inhibitors, the accuracy, reliability, and comparability of tumor mutational burden (TMB) estimation is of paramount importance. To improve the consistency and reliability of these tests, qualified reference materials providing ground-truth data are crucial. In this study, we developed a set of formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded (FFPE) samples with different TMB values as the novel reference materials for TMB estimation. By introducing several clinically relevant variants in MutS Homolog 2 (MSH2) gene and DNA polymerase epsilon (POLE) gene into human cell lines using CRISPR/Cas9 technology, we first constructed four typical cell lines which verified with hypermutator or ultramutator phenotype. Followed by cell mixing and paraffin embedding, the novel FFPE samples were prepared. It was confirmed that our novel FFPE samples have sufficient quantity of cells, high reproducibility, and they can provide matched wild type sample as the genetic background. The double-platform whole exome sequencing validation showed that our FFPE samples were also highly flexible as they containing different TMB values spanning a clinically relevant range (2.0–106.1 mut/Mb). Without limitations on production and TMB values, our novel FFPE samples based on CRISPR/Cas9 editing are suitable as candidate reference materials. From a practical point of view, these samples can be used for the validation, verification, internal quality control, and proficiency testing of TMB assessment.

This study aimed to evaluate inter-laboratory classification concordance for copy number variants (CNVs) with a semiquantitative point-based scoring metric recommended by the American College of Medical Genetics and Genomics (ACMG) and Clinical Genome Resources (ClinGen). A total of 234 CNVs distributed by the National Center of Clinical Laboratories (NCCLs), and 72 CNVs submitted by different laboratories, were distributed to nine clinical laboratories performing routine clinical CNV testing in China and independently classified across laboratories. The overall inter-laboratory complete classification concordance rate of the 234 distributed CNVs increased from 18% (41/234) to 76% (177/234) using the scoring metric compared to the laboratory's previous method. The overall inter-laboratory complete classification concordance rate of the 72 submitted CNVs was 65% (47/72) using the scoring metrics. The 82 variants that initially did not reach complete concordance classification and 1 additional CNV deletion were reviewed; 34 reached complete agreement, and the overall post-review complete concordance rate was 85% (260/306). Additionally, the overall percentage of classification discordance possibly impacting medical management [i.e., pathogenic (P) or likely pathogenic (LP) vs. variant of uncertain significance (VUS)] was 11% (35/306). The causes of initial and final discordance in the classification were identified. The ACMG-ClinGen framework has promoted consistency in interpreting the clinical significance of CNVs. Continuous training among laboratories, further criteria and additional clarification of the standards, sharing classifications and supporting evidence through public database, and ongoing work for dosage sensitive genes/regions curation will be beneficial for harmonization of CNVs classification.