1. Feasibility of an Assessment Tool as a Data-Driven Approach to Reducing Racial Bias in Biomedical Publications.
- Author
-
Wescott, Siobhan, Johnson, Ronn, Lamba, Sangeeta, Olson, Devon, Haywood, Yolanda, Meltzer, Carolyn C, and Correa, Ricardo
- Subjects
PREVENTION of racism ,MEDICAL literature -- History & criticism ,NATIONAL competency-based educational tests ,PILOT projects ,USER-centered system design ,PROFESSIONS ,HEALTH services accessibility ,SERIAL publications ,RESEARCH methodology ,EVALUATION research ,HEALTH status indicators ,CONCEPTUAL structures ,SURVEYS ,HUMAN services programs ,AUTONOMY (Psychology) ,TERMS & phrases ,DECISION making ,INFORMATION storage & retrieval systems ,MANAGEMENT ,MEDICAL research - Abstract
The editorial independence of biomedical journals allows flexibility to meet a wide range of research interests. However, it also is a barrier for coordination between journals to solve challenging issues such as racial bias in the scientific literature. A standardized tool to screen for racial bias could prevent the publication of racially biased papers. Biomedical journals would maintain editorial autonomy while still allowing comparable data to be collected and analyzed across journals. A racially diverse research team carried out a three-phase study to generate and test a racial bias assessment tool for biomedical research. Phase 1, an in-depth, structured literature search to identify recommendations, found near complete agreement in the literature on addressing race in biomedical research. Phase 2, construction of a framework from those recommendations, provides the major innovation of this paper. The framework includes three dimensions of race: 1) context, 2) tone and terminology, and 3) analysis, which are the basis for the Race Equity Vetting Instrument for Editorial Workflow (REVIEW) tool. Phase 3, pilot testing the assessment tool, showed that the REVIEW tool was effective at flagging multiple concerns in widely criticized articles. This study demonstrates the feasibility of the proposed REVIEW tool to reduce racial bias in research. Next steps include testing this tool on a broader sample of biomedical research to determine how the tool performs on more subtle examples of racial bias. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF