Search

Using standardized guidelines in preclinical research has received increased interest in light of recent concerns about transparency in data reporting and apparent variation in data quality, as evidenced by irreproducibility of results. Although the costs associated with supporting quality through a quality management system are often obvious line items in laboratory budgets, the treatment of the costs associated with quality failure is often overlooked and difficult to quantify. Thus, general estimations of quality costs can be misleading and inaccurate, effectively undervaluing costs recovered by reducing quality defects. Here, we provide examples of quality costs in preclinical research and describe how we have addressed misconceptions of quality management implementation as only marginally beneficial and/or unduly burdensome. We provide two examples of implementing a quality management system (QMS) in preclinical experimental (animal) research environments - one in Europe, the German Mouse Clinic, having established ISO 9001 and the other in the United States, the University of Kentucky (UK), having established Good Laboratory Practice-compliant infrastructure. We present a summary of benefits to having an effective QMS, as may be useful in guiding discussions with funders or administrators to promote interest and investment in a QMS, which ultimately supports shared, mutually beneficial outcomes.

Using standardized guidelines in preclinical research has received increased interest in light of recent concerns about transparency in data reporting and apparent variation in data quality, as evidenced by irreproducibility of results. Although the costs associated with supporting quality through a quality management system are often obvious line items in laboratory budgets, the treatment of the costs associated with quality failure is often overlooked and difficult to quantify. Thus, general estimations of quality costs can be misleading and inaccurate, effectively undervaluing costs recovered by reducing quality defects. Here, we provide examples of quality costs in preclinical research and describe how we have addressed misconceptions of quality management implementation as only marginally beneficial and/or unduly burdensome. We provide two examples of implementing a quality management system (QMS) in preclinical experimental (animal) research environments – one in Europe, the German Mouse Clinic, having established ISO 9001 and the other in the United States, the University of Kentucky (UK), having established Good Laboratory Practice-compliant infrastructure. We present a summary of benefits to having an effective QMS, as may be useful in guiding discussions with funders or administrators to promote interest and investment in a QMS, which ultimately supports shared, mutually beneficial outcomes.

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a disorder affecting dopamine neurons for which there is no cure. Glial cell line-derived neurotrophic factor (GDNF) and the closely related protein neurturin are two trophic factors with demonstrated neuroprotective and neurorestorative properties on dopamine neurons in multiple animal species. However, GDNF and neurturin Phase-2 clinical trials have failed to demonstrate a significant level of improvement over placebo controls. Insufficient drug distribution in the brain parenchyma has been proposed as a major contributing factor for the lack of clinical efficacy in the Phase-2 trial patients. To address this issue, a novel mammalian cell-derived variant form of GDNF (GDNFv) was designed to promote better tissue distribution by reducing its heparin binding to the extracellular matrix and key amino acids were substituted to enhance its chemical stability. Administration of this fully glycosylated GDNFv in the normal rat striatum increased dopamine turnover and produced significantly greater brain distribution than E. coli-produced wildtype GDNF (GDNFwt). Intrastriatal GDNFv also protected midbrain dopamine neuron function in 6-hydroxydopamine-lesioned rats. Studies conducted in normal adult rhesus macaques support that GDNFv was well tolerated in all animals and demonstrated a greater volume of distribution than GDNFwt in the brain following intrastriatal infusion. Importantly, favorable physiological activity of potential therapeutic value was maintained in this variant trophic factor with significant target activation in GDNFv recipients as indicated by dopamine turnover modulation. These data suggest that GDNFv may be a promising drug candidate for the treatment of PD. Additional studies are needed in non-human primates with dopamine depletion. This article is part of the Special Issue entitled ‘Drug Repurposing: old molecules, new ways to fast track drug discovery and development for CNS disorders’.