1. ДЕЯКІ ПРОБЛЕМИ ПРАВОВОГО РЕГУЛЮВАННЯ АЛЬТЕРНАТИВНОЇ (НЕВІЙСЬКОВОЇ) СЛУЖБИ В УКРАЇНІ
- Author
-
П. Ю., Скарга
- Subjects
MILITARY service ,RELIGIOUS communities ,EUROPEAN law ,MILITARY law ,CIVIL rights - Abstract
The article analyzes the problems of legal regulation of alternative (non-military) service in Ukraine. The main objective of the article is to determine the procedure of serving alternative service in Ukraine, to outline the main gaps in laws on the regulation of non-military service, to identify the problems of interpretation of regulatory prescriptions by courts and to find ways of solving these problems. Based on the analysis of the provisions of the Constitution of Ukraine, the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, Law of Ukraine «On Alternative (Non-military) Service», the Law of Ukraine «On General Military Duty and Military Service» and other legal acts, case law of the European Court of Human Rights and national courts, the author makes proposals for improving the legal regulation of alternative (non-military) service in Ukraine. The author concludes that in order to fill the gaps in the legal regulation of alternative service, the following steps should be taken: a) to bring the provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Alternative (Non-military) Service» in line with the provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On General Military Duty and Military Service» (it is required to replace the concept of «conscript military service» with «basic military service»); b) to clarify the possibility of a person missing the deadline for submitting an application for alternative service for valid reasons; c) to specify and clarify the meaning of the concept of «truth of religious beliefs». The author notes that there are practical difficulties associated with proving the truthfulness of religious beliefs by a person. In this regard, it seems advisable to transfer the legislative provisions from the subjective plane to a more objective one. This can be done by, among other things: replacing the condition of confirming the truth of beliefs with the requirement to confirm active participation in the activities of a religious community (this will allow assessing not the subjective attitude of a person to certain religious views, but his or her actual involvement in «religious life») / establishing specific criteria to be taken into account by authorized entities when assessing the truth of reli gious beliefs of a person. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF