1. Preschool Instruction in Letter Names and Sounds: Does Contextualized or Decontextualized Instruction Matter?
- Author
-
Roberts, Theresa A., Vadasy, Patricia F., and Sanders, Elizabeth A.
- Abstract
This study investigated the influence of teaching letter names and sounds in isolation or in the context of storybook reading on preschool children's early literacy learning and engagement during instruction. Alphabet instruction incorporated paired associate learning of correspondences between letter names and sounds. In Decontextualized treatment activities, children practiced saying the letter names and sounds that matched printed single letters presented on cards and in letter books, and speeded recognition of taught letters. In Contextualized treatment activities, letter names and sounds were taught and practiced during oral reading of storybooks, recognizing letters in children's printed names, and speeded recognition of taught letters in words. Subjects were 127 preschool children in five public schools with low-income eligibility thresholds, including 48 dual language learners (DLLs). Children were randomly assigned within classroom to small groups randomly assigned to one of the two treatments. Research assistants provided 10 weeks of instruction, 12-15 minutes/day, and four days/week. Both groups made significant growth from pretest to posttest on measures of alphabet learning and phoneme awareness. Children in the Decontextualized treatment small groups had significantly higher gains than children in the Contextualized treatment small groups on taught letter sounds and phonemic awareness measured by identification of initial sounds in spoken words. There were no treatment differences between DLL and non-DLL children. Children's engagement during instruction was significantly higher in the Decontextualized treatment. Findings support explicit decontextualized alphabet instruction emphasizing the relationship between verbal letter labels and letter forms that enlists PAL processes. [This paper is published in "Reading Research Quarterly."]
- Published
- 2019
- Full Text
- View/download PDF