Search

During the past years many efforts have been made to elucidate the origin of the uncoupling mechanisms induced by hyperthyroidism in mitochondria. Two main mechanisms have been proposed: a classical protonophoric uncoupler mechanism, considering the action of thyroid hormones at the level of the lipid membrane bilayer, and a slipping mechanism with more localized effects at the level of the redox proton pumps. This short review is devoted to comparing and discussing the evidence against and in favour of these two mechanisms.

Hyperthyroid mitochondria show an increased Kmand Vmaxin the high affinity phase of cytochrome oxidase kinetics. During inhibitor titrations, cytochrome cshows a different redox behaviour in hyperthyroid with respect to protonophore-treated euthyroid mitochondria. The observations are discussed in terms of a different regulation of electron input and output into the respiratory chain during slip and leak types of uncoupling. In hyperthyroid mitochondria during inhibitor titrations, the pattern of the relationship between uncoupler-induced extra-respiration and membrane potential is highly non-linear. The complex nature of the respiratory stimulation in hyperthyroid mitochondria is discussed.

A new criterion is utilized for the interpretation of flow-force relationships in rat liver mitochondria. The criterion is based on the view that the nature of the relationship between the H+/O ratio and the membrane potential can be inferred from the relationship between ohmic-uncoupler-induced extra respiration and the membrane potential. Thus a linear relationship between extra respiration and membrane potential indicates unequivocally the independence of the H+/O ratio from the membrane potential and the leak nature of the resting respiration [Brand, Chien, and Diolez (1994) Biochem. J. 297, 27-29]. On the other hand, a non-linear relationship indicates that the H+/O ratio is dependent on the membrane potential. The experimental assessment of this relationship in the presence of an additional ohmic leak, however, is rendered difficult by both the uncoupler-induced depression of membrane potential and the limited range of dependence of the H+/O ratio on the membrane potential. We have selected conditions, i.e. incubation of mitochondria at low temperatures, where the extent of non-linearity is markedly increased. It appears that the nature of the resting respiration of mitochondria in vitro is markedly dependent on the temperature: at low temperatures the percentage of resting respiration due to membrane leak decreases and that due to intrinsic uncoupling of the proton pumps increases.

During the past years many efforts have been made to elucidate the origin of the uncoupling mechanisms induced by hyperthyroidism in mitochondria. Two main mechanisms have been proposed: a classical protonophoric uncoupler mechanism, considering the action of thyroid hormones at the level of the lipid membrane bilayer, and a slipping mechanism with more localized effects at the level of the redox proton pumps. This short review is devoted to comparing and discussing the evidence against and in favour of these two mechanisms.

Addition of bovine serum albumin to state 4 mitochondria results in a depression of the proton leak and of the resting respiration of 70 and 25%, respectively. The conductance membrane potential diagram, both in the ohmic and in the non-ohmic region, shows that in the presence of bovine serum albumin the level of ohmic conductance is lowered while that of non-ohmic conductance is increased toward higher delta psi values. The same effect is observed during operation of the different proton pumps. Addition of chloroform affects the conductance membrane potential diagram in the following manner: there is no effect in the ohmic region with all pumps, while there is an effect in the non-ohmic region either at site III or at sites II plus III but not at site II. This suggests a possible effect of chloroform at the level of the cytochrome oxidase proton pump. During titration with oligomycin of the ATPase proton pump the conductance potential diagram shows a region of non-ohmicity only in the presence but not in the absence of an ATP-regenerating system. Protonophoric uncouplers such as carbonyl cyanide p(trifluoromethoxy)phenylhydrazone and intrinsic uncouplers such as chloroform have different effects on the relationship between rates of charge translocation and of oxygen consumption, and thus on the pump stoichiometries, in that the slope of the diagram is modified by the latter but not by the former. The differential effects of protonophores and of intrinsic uncouplers on the stoichiometries have been analyzed by computer simulations and represent an additional criterion to distinguish between extrinsic and intrinsic mechanisms of uncoupling.

The effect of palmitic acid on the electrical potential difference ?? across the inner mitochondrial membrane appears to depend on the medium in which mitochondria are incubated. In medium A (cf. Luvisettoet al. (1987),Biochemistry,26, 7332–7338) ?? decreases much more than in medium B (cf. Rottenberg and Hashimoto (1986),Biochemistry,25, 1747–1755) at concentrations of fatty acid which equally stimulate the rate of respiration in state 4. Valinomycin and NaCl were both present in medium B and absent in medium A. However, in both media the pattern of the P/O ratio as a function of antimycin in the presence of a constant amount of palmitic acid or of FCCP shows similar behaviour. We conclude that in both media palmitic acid increases the membrane conductance to protons, but for unclear reasons the ?? assay fails to measure the decline of ?? in medium B. However, the increase in membrane conductance induced by palmitic acid does not quantitatively account for the stimulation of the rate of respiration.

Hyperthyroid mitochondria show an increased Kmand Vmaxin the high affinity phase of cytochrome oxidase kinetics. During inhibitor titrations, cytochrome cshows a different redox behaviour in hyperthyroid with respect to protonophore‐treated euthyroid mitochondria. The observations are discussed in terms of a different regulation of electron input and output into the respiratory chain during slip and leak types of uncoupling. In hyperthyroid mitochondria during inhibitor titrations, the pattern of the relationship between uncoupler‐induced extra‐respiration and membrane potential is highly non‐linear. The complex nature of the respiratory stimulation in hyperthyroid mitochondria is discussed.