1. A multi-society Delphi consensus statement on new fatty liver disease nomenclature
- Author
-
Mary E, R, Jeffrey V, L, Vlad, R, Sven M, F, Arun J, S, Fasiha, K, Diana, R, Manal F, A, Quentin M, A, Juan Pablo, A, Marco, A, Ramon, B, Ulrich, B, Jerome, B, Elisabetta, B, Christopher, B, Graciela E, C, Abhijit, C, Helena, C, Donna, C, Kenneth, C, Mohamed, E, Samuel, K, Wayne, E, Jiangao, F, Samer, G, Cynthia D, G, Stephen A, H, Seung Up, K, Bart, K, Marko, K, Kris, K, Florence, L, Rohit, L, Robert, M, Timothy R, M, Elisabeth, P, Michael, R, Manuel, R, Marcelo, S, Shivaram Prasad, S, Silvia C, S, C Wendy, S, Dina, T, Luca, V, Miriam B, V, Vincent, W, Stavra, X, Yusuf, Y, Zobair, Y, Ansley, H, Marcela, V, Newsome, NVeeral Ajmeral, P, Alazawi, W, Alkhatry, M, Alkhouri, N, Allen, A, Allison, M, Alswat, K, R Alvares-da-Silva, M, Alves-Bezerra, M, J Armstrong, M, Arufe, D, Aschner, P, Baffy, G, Bansal, M, Bedossa, P, Belfort, R, Berg, T, Berzigotti, A, Betel, M, Bianco, C, Brass, C, L Brosgart, C, Matthews Brunt, E, Buti, M, Caldwell, S, Carr, R, Casanovas, T, Castera, L, Caussy, C, Cerda, E, Chalasani, N, Kheong Chan, W, Charatcharoenwitthaya, P, Charlton, M, Cheung, A, Chiodi, D, Chung, R, Cohen, D, Corey, K, P Cotrim, H, Crespo, J, Dassanayake, A, Davidson, N, De Knegt, R, De Ledinghen, V, Demir, M, Diaz, S, Mae Diehl, A, Dimmig, B, Dirchwolf, M, Duseja, A, Dvorak, K, Ekstedt, M, El Wakil, R, Lucía Ferraz, M, Friedman, S, Fuchs, M, Gastaldelli, A, Geerts, A, Geier, A, Girala, M, Goh, G, Goossens, N, Graupera, I, Hagström, H, Henry, Z, Hunyady, B, Hutchison, A, Isaacs, S, Jornayvaz, F, Kemp, C, Kile, D, Kim, W, Kleiner, D, Kohli, R, Kugelmas, M, Lavine, J, Lazo, M, Leite, N, Lozano, A, Luukkonen, P, Macedo, P, Mansour, D, Mantzoros, C, Marchesini, G, Marciano, S, Martinez, K, Vladimirova Mateva, L, M Mato, J, Mccary, A, Miele, L, Mikolasevic, I, Miller, V, Moreno, R, Moylan, C, Nakajima, A, Charles Nault, J, Norris, S, Noureddin, M, P Oliveira, C, Ong, A, Padilla, M, Pais, R, Panduro, A, K Panigrahi, M, Papatheodoridis, G, Pelusi, S, Pérez, M, Perez Escobar, J, Perseghin, G, Pessoa, M, Petta, S, Pinzani, M, Platon Lupsor, M, Rabiee, A, Romeo, S, Rotman, Y, Rowe, I, Salupere, R, Satapathy, S, M Schattenberg, J, Schaufert, W, Schnabl, B, Seim, L, Serfaty, L, Shapiro, D, K Singal, A, Skladany, L, Stefan, N, Stine, J, Sundaram, S, Svegliati-Baroni, G, Szabo, G, Tacke, F, Tanwandee, T, Targher, G, Terrault, N, Tetri, B, Thiele, M, Tisthammer, B, Torre Delgadillo, A, Trauner, M, Tsochatzis, E, Van Kleef, L, Van Mil, S, Vanwagner, L, Antonio Velarde Ruiz Velasco, J, Vesterhus, M, Vilar-Gomez, E, Watt, K, Wattacheril, J, Wilkins, F, Willemse, J, Zekry, A, Zelber-Sagi, S, Rinella, Mary E, Lazarus, Jeffrey V, Ratziu, Vlad, Francque, Sven M, Sanyal, Arun J, Kanwal, Fasiha, Romero, Diana, Abdelmalek, Manal F, Anstee, Quentin M, Arab, Juan Pablo, Arrese, Marco, Bataller, Ramon, Beuers, Ulrich, Boursier, Jerome, Bugianesi, Elisabetta, Byrne, Christopher, Castro Narro, Graciela E, Chowdhury, Abhijit, Cortez-Pinto, Helena, Cryer, Donna, Cusi, Kenneth, El-Kassas, Mohamed, Klein, Samuel, Eskridge, Wayne, Fan, Jiangao, Gawrieh, Samer, Guy, Cynthia D, Harrison, Stephen A, Kim, Seung Up, Koot, Bart, Korenjak, Marko, Kowdley, Kris, Lacaille, Florence, Loomba, Rohit, Mitchell-Thain, Robert, Morgan, Timothy R, Powell, Elisabeth, Roden, Michael, Romero-Gómez, Manuel, Silva, Marcelo, Singh, Shivaram Prasad, Sookoian, Silvia C, Spearman, C Wendy, Tiniakos, Dina, Valenti, Luca, Vos, Miriam B, Wai-Sun Wong, Vincent, Xanthakos, Stavra, Yilmaz, Yusuf, Younossi, Zobair, Hobbs, Ansley, Villota-Rivas, Marcela, Philip NVeeral Ajmeral, William Alazawi, Maryam Alkhatry, Naim Alkhouri, Alina Allen, Michael Allison, Khalid Alswat, Mario R Alvares-da-Silva, Michele Alves-Bezerra, Matthew J Armstrong, Diego Arufe, Pablo Aschner, Gyorgy Baffy, Meena Bansal, Pierre Bedossa, Renata Belfort, Thomas Berg, Annalisa Berzigotti, Michael Betel, Cristiana Bianco, Clifford Brass, Carol L Brosgart, Elizabeth Matthews Brunt, Maria Buti, Steve Caldwell, Rotonya Carr, Teresa Casanovas, Laurent Castera, Cyrielle Caussy, Eira Cerda, Naga Chalasani, Wah Kheong Chan, Phunchai Charatcharoenwitthaya, Michael Charlton, Amanda Cheung, Daniela Chiodi, Ray Chung, David Cohen, Kathleen Corey, Helma P Cotrim, Javier Crespo, Anuradha Dassanayake, Nicholas Davidson, Robert De Knegt, Victor De Ledinghen, Münevver Demir, Sebastian Diaz, Anna Mae Diehl, Bruce Dimmig, Melisa Dirchwolf, Ajay Duseja, Karel Dvorak, Mattias Ekstedt, Reda El Wakil, María Lucía Ferraz, Scott Friedman, Michael Fuchs, Amalia Gastaldelli, Anja Geerts, Andreas Geier, Marcos Girala, George Goh, Nicolas Goossens, Isabel Graupera, Hannes Hagström, Zachary Henry, Bela Hunyady, Alan Hutchison, Scott Isaacs, François Jornayvaz, Cynthia Kemp, Denise Kile, Won Kim, David Kleiner, Rohit Kohli, Marcelo Kugelmas, Joel Lavine, Mariana Lazo, Nathalie Leite, Adelina Lozano, Panu Luukkonen, Paula Macedo, Dina Mansour, Christos Mantzoros, Giulio Marchesini, Sebastián Marciano, Kim Martinez, Lyudmila Vladimirova Mateva, Jose M Mato, Alexis McCary, Luca Miele, Ivana Mikolasevic, Veronica Miller, Rosalba Moreno, Cynthia Moylan, Atsushi Nakajima, Jean Charles Nault, Suzanne Norris, Mazen Noureddin, C P Oliveira, Arlin Ong, Martín Padilla, Raluca Pais, Arturo Panduro, Manas K Panigrahi, George Papatheodoridis, Serena Pelusi, Marlene Pérez, Juanita Perez Escobar, Gianluca Perseghin, Mario Pessoa, Salvatore Petta, Massimo Pinzani, Monica Platon Lupsor, Atoosa Rabiee, Stefano Romeo, Yaron Rotman, Ian Rowe, Riina Salupere, Sanjaya Satapathy, Jörn M Schattenberg, Wendy Schaufert, Bernd Schnabl, Lynn Seim, Lawrence Serfaty, David Shapiro, Ashwani K Singal, Lubomir Skladany, Norbert Stefan, Jonathan Stine, Shikha Sundaram, Gianluca Svegliati-Baroni, Gyonzgi Szabo, Frank Tacke, Tawesak Tanwandee, Giovanni Targher, Norah Terrault, Brent Tetri, Maja Thiele, Baron Tisthammer, Aldo Torre Delgadillo, Michael Trauner, Emmanuel Tsochatzis, Laurens Van Kleef, Saskia Van Mil, Lisa VanWagner, Jose Antonio Velarde Ruiz Velasco, Mette Vesterhus, Eduardo Vilar-Gomez, Kymberly Watt, Julia Wattacheril, Fonda Wilkins, José Willemse, Amany Zekry, Shira Zelber-Sagi, Mary E, R, Jeffrey V, L, Vlad, R, Sven M, F, Arun J, S, Fasiha, K, Diana, R, Manal F, A, Quentin M, A, Juan Pablo, A, Marco, A, Ramon, B, Ulrich, B, Jerome, B, Elisabetta, B, Christopher, B, Graciela E, C, Abhijit, C, Helena, C, Donna, C, Kenneth, C, Mohamed, E, Samuel, K, Wayne, E, Jiangao, F, Samer, G, Cynthia D, G, Stephen A, H, Seung Up, K, Bart, K, Marko, K, Kris, K, Florence, L, Rohit, L, Robert, M, Timothy R, M, Elisabeth, P, Michael, R, Manuel, R, Marcelo, S, Shivaram Prasad, S, Silvia C, S, C Wendy, S, Dina, T, Luca, V, Miriam B, V, Vincent, W, Stavra, X, Yusuf, Y, Zobair, Y, Ansley, H, Marcela, V, Newsome, NVeeral Ajmeral, P, Alazawi, W, Alkhatry, M, Alkhouri, N, Allen, A, Allison, M, Alswat, K, R Alvares-da-Silva, M, Alves-Bezerra, M, J Armstrong, M, Arufe, D, Aschner, P, Baffy, G, Bansal, M, Bedossa, P, Belfort, R, Berg, T, Berzigotti, A, Betel, M, Bianco, C, Brass, C, L Brosgart, C, Matthews Brunt, E, Buti, M, Caldwell, S, Carr, R, Casanovas, T, Castera, L, Caussy, C, Cerda, E, Chalasani, N, Kheong Chan, W, Charatcharoenwitthaya, P, Charlton, M, Cheung, A, Chiodi, D, Chung, R, Cohen, D, Corey, K, P Cotrim, H, Crespo, J, Dassanayake, A, Davidson, N, De Knegt, R, De Ledinghen, V, Demir, M, Diaz, S, Mae Diehl, A, Dimmig, B, Dirchwolf, M, Duseja, A, Dvorak, K, Ekstedt, M, El Wakil, R, Lucía Ferraz, M, Friedman, S, Fuchs, M, Gastaldelli, A, Geerts, A, Geier, A, Girala, M, Goh, G, Goossens, N, Graupera, I, Hagström, H, Henry, Z, Hunyady, B, Hutchison, A, Isaacs, S, Jornayvaz, F, Kemp, C, Kile, D, Kim, W, Kleiner, D, Kohli, R, Kugelmas, M, Lavine, J, Lazo, M, Leite, N, Lozano, A, Luukkonen, P, Macedo, P, Mansour, D, Mantzoros, C, Marchesini, G, Marciano, S, Martinez, K, Vladimirova Mateva, L, M Mato, J, Mccary, A, Miele, L, Mikolasevic, I, Miller, V, Moreno, R, Moylan, C, Nakajima, A, Charles Nault, J, Norris, S, Noureddin, M, P Oliveira, C, Ong, A, Padilla, M, Pais, R, Panduro, A, K Panigrahi, M, Papatheodoridis, G, Pelusi, S, Pérez, M, Perez Escobar, J, Perseghin, G, Pessoa, M, Petta, S, Pinzani, M, Platon Lupsor, M, Rabiee, A, Romeo, S, Rotman, Y, Rowe, I, Salupere, R, Satapathy, S, M Schattenberg, J, Schaufert, W, Schnabl, B, Seim, L, Serfaty, L, Shapiro, D, K Singal, A, Skladany, L, Stefan, N, Stine, J, Sundaram, S, Svegliati-Baroni, G, Szabo, G, Tacke, F, Tanwandee, T, Targher, G, Terrault, N, Tetri, B, Thiele, M, Tisthammer, B, Torre Delgadillo, A, Trauner, M, Tsochatzis, E, Van Kleef, L, Van Mil, S, Vanwagner, L, Antonio Velarde Ruiz Velasco, J, Vesterhus, M, Vilar-Gomez, E, Watt, K, Wattacheril, J, Wilkins, F, Willemse, J, Zekry, A, Zelber-Sagi, S, Rinella, Mary E, Lazarus, Jeffrey V, Ratziu, Vlad, Francque, Sven M, Sanyal, Arun J, Kanwal, Fasiha, Romero, Diana, Abdelmalek, Manal F, Anstee, Quentin M, Arab, Juan Pablo, Arrese, Marco, Bataller, Ramon, Beuers, Ulrich, Boursier, Jerome, Bugianesi, Elisabetta, Byrne, Christopher, Castro Narro, Graciela E, Chowdhury, Abhijit, Cortez-Pinto, Helena, Cryer, Donna, Cusi, Kenneth, El-Kassas, Mohamed, Klein, Samuel, Eskridge, Wayne, Fan, Jiangao, Gawrieh, Samer, Guy, Cynthia D, Harrison, Stephen A, Kim, Seung Up, Koot, Bart, Korenjak, Marko, Kowdley, Kris, Lacaille, Florence, Loomba, Rohit, Mitchell-Thain, Robert, Morgan, Timothy R, Powell, Elisabeth, Roden, Michael, Romero-Gómez, Manuel, Silva, Marcelo, Singh, Shivaram Prasad, Sookoian, Silvia C, Spearman, C Wendy, Tiniakos, Dina, Valenti, Luca, Vos, Miriam B, Wai-Sun Wong, Vincent, Xanthakos, Stavra, Yilmaz, Yusuf, Younossi, Zobair, Hobbs, Ansley, Villota-Rivas, Marcela, Philip NVeeral Ajmeral, William Alazawi, Maryam Alkhatry, Naim Alkhouri, Alina Allen, Michael Allison, Khalid Alswat, Mario R Alvares-da-Silva, Michele Alves-Bezerra, Matthew J Armstrong, Diego Arufe, Pablo Aschner, Gyorgy Baffy, Meena Bansal, Pierre Bedossa, Renata Belfort, Thomas Berg, Annalisa Berzigotti, Michael Betel, Cristiana Bianco, Clifford Brass, Carol L Brosgart, Elizabeth Matthews Brunt, Maria Buti, Steve Caldwell, Rotonya Carr, Teresa Casanovas, Laurent Castera, Cyrielle Caussy, Eira Cerda, Naga Chalasani, Wah Kheong Chan, Phunchai Charatcharoenwitthaya, Michael Charlton, Amanda Cheung, Daniela Chiodi, Ray Chung, David Cohen, Kathleen Corey, Helma P Cotrim, Javier Crespo, Anuradha Dassanayake, Nicholas Davidson, Robert De Knegt, Victor De Ledinghen, Münevver Demir, Sebastian Diaz, Anna Mae Diehl, Bruce Dimmig, Melisa Dirchwolf, Ajay Duseja, Karel Dvorak, Mattias Ekstedt, Reda El Wakil, María Lucía Ferraz, Scott Friedman, Michael Fuchs, Amalia Gastaldelli, Anja Geerts, Andreas Geier, Marcos Girala, George Goh, Nicolas Goossens, Isabel Graupera, Hannes Hagström, Zachary Henry, Bela Hunyady, Alan Hutchison, Scott Isaacs, François Jornayvaz, Cynthia Kemp, Denise Kile, Won Kim, David Kleiner, Rohit Kohli, Marcelo Kugelmas, Joel Lavine, Mariana Lazo, Nathalie Leite, Adelina Lozano, Panu Luukkonen, Paula Macedo, Dina Mansour, Christos Mantzoros, Giulio Marchesini, Sebastián Marciano, Kim Martinez, Lyudmila Vladimirova Mateva, Jose M Mato, Alexis McCary, Luca Miele, Ivana Mikolasevic, Veronica Miller, Rosalba Moreno, Cynthia Moylan, Atsushi Nakajima, Jean Charles Nault, Suzanne Norris, Mazen Noureddin, C P Oliveira, Arlin Ong, Martín Padilla, Raluca Pais, Arturo Panduro, Manas K Panigrahi, George Papatheodoridis, Serena Pelusi, Marlene Pérez, Juanita Perez Escobar, Gianluca Perseghin, Mario Pessoa, Salvatore Petta, Massimo Pinzani, Monica Platon Lupsor, Atoosa Rabiee, Stefano Romeo, Yaron Rotman, Ian Rowe, Riina Salupere, Sanjaya Satapathy, Jörn M Schattenberg, Wendy Schaufert, Bernd Schnabl, Lynn Seim, Lawrence Serfaty, David Shapiro, Ashwani K Singal, Lubomir Skladany, Norbert Stefan, Jonathan Stine, Shikha Sundaram, Gianluca Svegliati-Baroni, Gyonzgi Szabo, Frank Tacke, Tawesak Tanwandee, Giovanni Targher, Norah Terrault, Brent Tetri, Maja Thiele, Baron Tisthammer, Aldo Torre Delgadillo, Michael Trauner, Emmanuel Tsochatzis, Laurens Van Kleef, Saskia Van Mil, Lisa VanWagner, Jose Antonio Velarde Ruiz Velasco, Mette Vesterhus, Eduardo Vilar-Gomez, Kymberly Watt, Julia Wattacheril, Fonda Wilkins, José Willemse, Amany Zekry, and Shira Zelber-Sagi
- Abstract
The principal limitations of the terms NAFLD and NASH are the reliance on exclusionary confounder terms and the use of potentially stigmatising language. This study set out to determine if content experts and patient advocates were in favour of a change in nomenclature and/or definition. A modified Delphi process was led by three large pan-national liver associations. The consensus was defined a priori as a supermajority (67%) vote. An independent committee of experts external to the nomenclature process made the final recommendation on the acronym and its diagnostic criteria. A total of 236 panellists from 56 countries participated in 4 online surveys and 2 hybrid meetings. Response rates across the 4 survey rounds were 87%, 83%, 83%, and 78%, respectively. Seventy-four percent of respondents felt that the current nomenclature was sufficiently flawed to consider a name change. The terms “nonalcoholic” and “fatty” were felt to be stigmatising by 61% and 66% of respondents, respectively. Steatotic liver disease was chosen as an overarching term to encompass the various aetiologies of steatosis. The term steatohepatitis was felt to be an important pathophysiological concept that should be retained. The name chosen to replace NAFLD was metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease (MASLD). There was consensus to change the definition to include the presence of at least 1 of 5 cardiometabolic risk factors. Those with no metabolic parameters and no known cause were deemed to have cryptogenic steatotic liver disease. A new category, outside pure metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease, termed metabolic and alcohol related/associated liver disease (MetALD), was selected to describe those with metabolic dysfunction–associated steatotic liver disease, who consume greater amounts of alcohol per week (140–350 g/wk and 210–420 g/wk for females and males, respectively). The new nomenclature and diagnostic criteria are widely supported and non-stigmati
- Published
- 2023