1. Long-term survival of patients with CLL after allogeneic transplantation: A report from the European Society for Blood and Marrow Transplantation
- Author
-
Van Gelder, M, De Wreede, L, Bornhauser, M, Niederwieser, D, Karas, M, Anderson, N, Gramatzki, M, Dreger, P, Michallet, M, Petersen, E, Bunjes, D, Potter, M, Beelen, D, Cornelissen, J, Yakoub-Agha, I, Russell, N, Finke, J, Schoemans, H, Vitek, A, Urbano-Ispizua, A, Blaise, D, Volin, L, Chevallier, P, Caballero, D, Putter, H, Van Biezen, A, Henseler, A, Schonland, S, Kroger, N, Schetelig, J, Ehninger, G, Jindra, P, Sengeloev, H, Ispizua, A, Arnold, R, Veelken, J, Mufti, G, Milpied, N, Benedetto, B, Schaap, M, Leblond, V, Nikolousis, M, Hallek, M, Passweg, J, Ljungman, P, Masszi, T, Stelljes, M, Browne, P, Glass, B, Espiga, C, Bourhis, J, Roussy, G, Gribben, J, Foa, R, Sierra, J, Mayer, J, Thomson, K, Meijer, E, Blau, W, Holler, E, Bacigalupo, A, Guilhot, F, Carlson, K, Zachee, P, Ifrah, N, Marin, J, Socie, G, Mcquaker, G, Cortelezzi, A, Lenhoff, S, Tischer, J, Irrera, G, Fanin, R, Beguin, Y, Nagler, A, Mackinnon, S, Itala-Remes, M, Deconinck, E, Wulf, G, Corradini, P, Gilleece, M, Wing, B, Peniket, A, Ganser, A, Stuhler, G, Faber, E, Komarnicki, M, Kanz, L, Brune, M, Lamy, T, Sanz, M, Kyrcz-Krzemien, S, Orchard, K, Hunter, A, Sandstedt, A, Fegueux, N, Bandini, G, Robinson, S, Craddock, C, Crawley, C, Griskevicius, L, Bloor, A, Reman, O, Hilgendorf, I, Cannell, P, Ciceri, F, Kalhs, P, Sica, S, Greinix, H, Scime, R, Selleslag, D, Kruger, W, Huynh, A, Einsele, H, Bittenbring, J, Olivieri, A, Hermine, O, Gedde-Dahl, T, Zsiros, J, Guyotat, D, Cordonnier, C, Campos, A, Casini, M, Martinelli, G, Muller, L, Van Imhoff, G, Neubauer, A, Lioure, B, Hamladji, R, Noens, L, Theobald, M, Salvi, F, Ram, R, Poire, X, Or, R, Chalandon, Y, Solano, C, Wilson, K, Santasusana, J, Karakasis, D, Schafer-Eckart, K, Wahlin, A, Mohty, M, Velardi, A, Bron, D, Alegre, A, Cairoli, R, Marotta, G, Lange, A, Narni, F, Fauser, A, Rambaldi, A, Guillerm, G, Heras, I, Snowden, J, Wiktor-Jedrzejczak, W, Schanz, U, Cahn, J, Abecasis, M, Kobbe, G, Salim, R, Junghanss, C, Segel, E, Clement, L, Zak, P, Metzner, B, Espigado, I, Tilly, H, Schroyens, W, Favre, C, Russo, D, Gastl, G, Bay, J, Alessandrino, E, Majolino, I, Bosi, A, Zuckerman, T, Aljurf, M, Thomson, J, Pioltelli, P, Anagnostopoulos, A, Schouten, H, Tholouli, E, Gurman, G, Vural, F, Zver, S, Muniz, S, Afanasyev, B, Pohlreich, D, Hellmann, A, Rosler, W, Martin, S, Apperley, J, Finnegan, D, Renaud, M, Nemet, D, Culligan, D, Castagna, L, Cascavilla, N, Koh, M, Chacon, M, Ozdogu, H, Spencer, A, Llamas, C, Grasso, M, Lopez, S, Benedetti, F, Deeren, D, De Revel, T, Musso, M, Halaburda, K, Sureda, A, Angelucci, E, Diez-Martin, J, Hunter, H, Koc, Y, Bordessoule, D, Fouillard, L, Di Bartolomeo, P, Mazza, P, Novitzky, N, Peschel, C, Lopez, J, Cascon, M, Romeril, K, Schots, R, Brussel, H, Koistinen, P, Arcese, W, Aktan, M, Rodeghiero, F, Butler, A, Pizzuti, M, Melpignano, A, Carella, A, Valcarcel, D, De Toledo Codina, J, Galieni, P, Bader, P, Hahn, Cavanna, L, Sucak, G, Broom, A, Garcia, P, Nicolas-Virelizier, E, Rizzoli, V, Witz, F, Collin, M, Ringhoffer, M, Kansu, E, Martin, H, Moraleda, J, Pranger, D, Greil, R, Bazarbachi, A, Ozturk, M, Fagioli, F, Jantunen, E, Yeshurun, M, Altuntas, F, Bassan, R, Rohrlich, P, Jimenez, S, Glaisner, S, Vinante, O, Clausen, J, Lopez-Jimenez, J, Theunissen, K, Specchia, G, Pavone, V, Krauter, J, Edwards, D, Rifon, J, Everaus, H, Da Prada, G, Wattad, M, Milone, G, Walewski, J, Thieblemont, C, Nasa, G, Duchosal, M, Ferrara, F, Devidas, A, Delmer, A, Degos, L, Van Gelder M., De Wreede L. C., Bornhauser M., Niederwieser D., Karas M., Anderson N. S., Gramatzki M., Dreger P., Michallet M., Petersen E., Bunjes D., Potter M., Beelen D., Cornelissen J. J., Yakoub-Agha I., Russell N. H., Finke J., Schoemans H., Vitek A., Urbano-Ispizua A., Blaise D., Volin L., Chevallier P., Caballero D., Putter H., Van Biezen A., Henseler A., Schonland S., Kroger N., Schetelig J., Ehninger G., Jindra P., Sengeloev H., Russell N., Ispizua A. U., Arnold R., Veelken J. H., Mufti G., Milpied N., Benedetto B., Schaap M., Leblond V., Nikolousis M., Hallek M., Passweg J., Ljungman P., Masszi T., Stelljes M., Browne P., Glass B., Espiga C. R., Bourhis J. H., Roussy G., Gribben J., Foa R., Sierra J., Mayer J., Thomson K., Meijer E., Blau W., Holler E., Bacigalupo A., Guilhot F., Carlson K., Zachee P., Ifrah N., Marin J. R. C., Socie G., McQuaker G., Cortelezzi A., Lenhoff S., Tischer J., Irrera G., Fanin R., Beguin Y., Nagler A., Mackinnon S., Itala-Remes M., Deconinck E., Wulf G., Corradini P., Gilleece M., Wing B., Peniket A., Ganser A., Stuhler G., Faber E., Komarnicki M., Kanz L., Brune M., Lamy T., Sanz M., Kyrcz-Krzemien S., Orchard K., Hunter A., Sandstedt A., Fegueux N., Bandini G., Robinson S., Craddock C., Crawley C., Griskevicius L., Bloor A., Reman O., Hilgendorf I., Cannell P., Ciceri F., Kalhs P., Sica S., Greinix H., Scime R., Selleslag D., Kruger W., Huynh A., Einsele H., Bittenbring J., Olivieri A., Hermine O., Gedde-Dahl T., Zsiros J., Guyotat D., Cordonnier C., Campos A., Casini M., Martinelli G., Muller L. P., Van Imhoff G., Neubauer A., Lioure B., Hamladji R. -M., Noens L., Theobald M., Salvi F., Ram R., Poire X., Or R., Chalandon Y., Solano C., Wilson K., Santasusana J. M. R., Karakasis D., Schafer-Eckart K., Wahlin A., Mohty M., Velardi A., Bron D., Alegre A., Cairoli R., Marotta G., Lange A., Narni F., Fauser A., Rambaldi A., Guillerm G., Heras I., Snowden J., Wiktor-Jedrzejczak W., Schanz U., Cahn J. Y., Abecasis M., Kobbe G., Salim R., Junghanss C., Segel E. K., Clement L., Zak P., Metzner B., Espigado I., Tilly H., Schroyens W., Favre C., Russo D., Gastl G., Bay J. -O., Alessandrino E. P., Majolino I., Bosi A., Zuckerman T., Aljurf M., Thomson J., Pioltelli P., Anagnostopoulos A., Schouten H., Tholouli E., Gurman G., Vural F., Zver S., Muniz S. G., Afanasyev B., Pohlreich D., Hellmann A., Rosler W., Martin S., Apperley J., Finnegan D., Renaud M., Nemet D., Culligan D., Castagna L., Cascavilla N., Koh M., Chacon M. J., Ozdogu H., Spencer A., Llamas C. V., Grasso M., Lopez S. G., Benedetti F., Deeren D., De Revel T., Musso M., Halaburda K., Sureda A., Angelucci E., Diez-Martin J. L., Hunter H., Koc Y., Bordessoule D., Fouillard L., Di Bartolomeo P., Mazza P., Novitzky N., Peschel C., Lopez J. L. B., Cascon M. J. P., Romeril K. R., Schots R., Brussel H., Koistinen P., Arcese W., Aktan M., Rodeghiero F., Butler A., Pizzuti M., Melpignano A., Carella A. M., Valcarcel D., De Toledo Codina J. S., Galieni P., Bader P., Cavanna L., Sucak G., Broom A. J. M., Garcia P. G., Nicolas-Virelizier E., Rizzoli V., Witz F., Collin M., Ringhoffer M., Kansu E., Martin H., Moraleda J., Pranger D., Greil R., Bazarbachi A., Ozturk M., Fagioli F., Jantunen E., Yeshurun M., Altuntas F., Bassan R., Rohrlich P. -S., Jimenez S., Glaisner S., Vinante O., Clausen J., Lopez-Jimenez J., Theunissen K., Specchia G., Pavone V., Krauter J., Edwards D., Rifon J., Everaus H., Da Prada G. A., Wattad M., Milone G., Walewski J., Thieblemont C., Nasa G. L., Duchosal M., Ferrara F., Devidas A., Delmer A., Degos L., Van Gelder, M, De Wreede, L, Bornhauser, M, Niederwieser, D, Karas, M, Anderson, N, Gramatzki, M, Dreger, P, Michallet, M, Petersen, E, Bunjes, D, Potter, M, Beelen, D, Cornelissen, J, Yakoub-Agha, I, Russell, N, Finke, J, Schoemans, H, Vitek, A, Urbano-Ispizua, A, Blaise, D, Volin, L, Chevallier, P, Caballero, D, Putter, H, Van Biezen, A, Henseler, A, Schonland, S, Kroger, N, Schetelig, J, Ehninger, G, Jindra, P, Sengeloev, H, Ispizua, A, Arnold, R, Veelken, J, Mufti, G, Milpied, N, Benedetto, B, Schaap, M, Leblond, V, Nikolousis, M, Hallek, M, Passweg, J, Ljungman, P, Masszi, T, Stelljes, M, Browne, P, Glass, B, Espiga, C, Bourhis, J, Roussy, G, Gribben, J, Foa, R, Sierra, J, Mayer, J, Thomson, K, Meijer, E, Blau, W, Holler, E, Bacigalupo, A, Guilhot, F, Carlson, K, Zachee, P, Ifrah, N, Marin, J, Socie, G, Mcquaker, G, Cortelezzi, A, Lenhoff, S, Tischer, J, Irrera, G, Fanin, R, Beguin, Y, Nagler, A, Mackinnon, S, Itala-Remes, M, Deconinck, E, Wulf, G, Corradini, P, Gilleece, M, Wing, B, Peniket, A, Ganser, A, Stuhler, G, Faber, E, Komarnicki, M, Kanz, L, Brune, M, Lamy, T, Sanz, M, Kyrcz-Krzemien, S, Orchard, K, Hunter, A, Sandstedt, A, Fegueux, N, Bandini, G, Robinson, S, Craddock, C, Crawley, C, Griskevicius, L, Bloor, A, Reman, O, Hilgendorf, I, Cannell, P, Ciceri, F, Kalhs, P, Sica, S, Greinix, H, Scime, R, Selleslag, D, Kruger, W, Huynh, A, Einsele, H, Bittenbring, J, Olivieri, A, Hermine, O, Gedde-Dahl, T, Zsiros, J, Guyotat, D, Cordonnier, C, Campos, A, Casini, M, Martinelli, G, Muller, L, Van Imhoff, G, Neubauer, A, Lioure, B, Hamladji, R, Noens, L, Theobald, M, Salvi, F, Ram, R, Poire, X, Or, R, Chalandon, Y, Solano, C, Wilson, K, Santasusana, J, Karakasis, D, Schafer-Eckart, K, Wahlin, A, Mohty, M, Velardi, A, Bron, D, Alegre, A, Cairoli, R, Marotta, G, Lange, A, Narni, F, Fauser, A, Rambaldi, A, Guillerm, G, Heras, I, Snowden, J, Wiktor-Jedrzejczak, W, Schanz, U, Cahn, J, Abecasis, M, Kobbe, G, Salim, R, Junghanss, C, Segel, E, Clement, L, Zak, P, Metzner, B, Espigado, I, Tilly, H, Schroyens, W, Favre, C, Russo, D, Gastl, G, Bay, J, Alessandrino, E, Majolino, I, Bosi, A, Zuckerman, T, Aljurf, M, Thomson, J, Pioltelli, P, Anagnostopoulos, A, Schouten, H, Tholouli, E, Gurman, G, Vural, F, Zver, S, Muniz, S, Afanasyev, B, Pohlreich, D, Hellmann, A, Rosler, W, Martin, S, Apperley, J, Finnegan, D, Renaud, M, Nemet, D, Culligan, D, Castagna, L, Cascavilla, N, Koh, M, Chacon, M, Ozdogu, H, Spencer, A, Llamas, C, Grasso, M, Lopez, S, Benedetti, F, Deeren, D, De Revel, T, Musso, M, Halaburda, K, Sureda, A, Angelucci, E, Diez-Martin, J, Hunter, H, Koc, Y, Bordessoule, D, Fouillard, L, Di Bartolomeo, P, Mazza, P, Novitzky, N, Peschel, C, Lopez, J, Cascon, M, Romeril, K, Schots, R, Brussel, H, Koistinen, P, Arcese, W, Aktan, M, Rodeghiero, F, Butler, A, Pizzuti, M, Melpignano, A, Carella, A, Valcarcel, D, De Toledo Codina, J, Galieni, P, Bader, P, Hahn, Cavanna, L, Sucak, G, Broom, A, Garcia, P, Nicolas-Virelizier, E, Rizzoli, V, Witz, F, Collin, M, Ringhoffer, M, Kansu, E, Martin, H, Moraleda, J, Pranger, D, Greil, R, Bazarbachi, A, Ozturk, M, Fagioli, F, Jantunen, E, Yeshurun, M, Altuntas, F, Bassan, R, Rohrlich, P, Jimenez, S, Glaisner, S, Vinante, O, Clausen, J, Lopez-Jimenez, J, Theunissen, K, Specchia, G, Pavone, V, Krauter, J, Edwards, D, Rifon, J, Everaus, H, Da Prada, G, Wattad, M, Milone, G, Walewski, J, Thieblemont, C, Nasa, G, Duchosal, M, Ferrara, F, Devidas, A, Delmer, A, Degos, L, Van Gelder M., De Wreede L. C., Bornhauser M., Niederwieser D., Karas M., Anderson N. S., Gramatzki M., Dreger P., Michallet M., Petersen E., Bunjes D., Potter M., Beelen D., Cornelissen J. J., Yakoub-Agha I., Russell N. H., Finke J., Schoemans H., Vitek A., Urbano-Ispizua A., Blaise D., Volin L., Chevallier P., Caballero D., Putter H., Van Biezen A., Henseler A., Schonland S., Kroger N., Schetelig J., Ehninger G., Jindra P., Sengeloev H., Russell N., Ispizua A. U., Arnold R., Veelken J. H., Mufti G., Milpied N., Benedetto B., Schaap M., Leblond V., Nikolousis M., Hallek M., Passweg J., Ljungman P., Masszi T., Stelljes M., Browne P., Glass B., Espiga C. R., Bourhis J. H., Roussy G., Gribben J., Foa R., Sierra J., Mayer J., Thomson K., Meijer E., Blau W., Holler E., Bacigalupo A., Guilhot F., Carlson K., Zachee P., Ifrah N., Marin J. R. C., Socie G., McQuaker G., Cortelezzi A., Lenhoff S., Tischer J., Irrera G., Fanin R., Beguin Y., Nagler A., Mackinnon S., Itala-Remes M., Deconinck E., Wulf G., Corradini P., Gilleece M., Wing B., Peniket A., Ganser A., Stuhler G., Faber E., Komarnicki M., Kanz L., Brune M., Lamy T., Sanz M., Kyrcz-Krzemien S., Orchard K., Hunter A., Sandstedt A., Fegueux N., Bandini G., Robinson S., Craddock C., Crawley C., Griskevicius L., Bloor A., Reman O., Hilgendorf I., Cannell P., Ciceri F., Kalhs P., Sica S., Greinix H., Scime R., Selleslag D., Kruger W., Huynh A., Einsele H., Bittenbring J., Olivieri A., Hermine O., Gedde-Dahl T., Zsiros J., Guyotat D., Cordonnier C., Campos A., Casini M., Martinelli G., Muller L. P., Van Imhoff G., Neubauer A., Lioure B., Hamladji R. -M., Noens L., Theobald M., Salvi F., Ram R., Poire X., Or R., Chalandon Y., Solano C., Wilson K., Santasusana J. M. R., Karakasis D., Schafer-Eckart K., Wahlin A., Mohty M., Velardi A., Bron D., Alegre A., Cairoli R., Marotta G., Lange A., Narni F., Fauser A., Rambaldi A., Guillerm G., Heras I., Snowden J., Wiktor-Jedrzejczak W., Schanz U., Cahn J. Y., Abecasis M., Kobbe G., Salim R., Junghanss C., Segel E. K., Clement L., Zak P., Metzner B., Espigado I., Tilly H., Schroyens W., Favre C., Russo D., Gastl G., Bay J. -O., Alessandrino E. P., Majolino I., Bosi A., Zuckerman T., Aljurf M., Thomson J., Pioltelli P., Anagnostopoulos A., Schouten H., Tholouli E., Gurman G., Vural F., Zver S., Muniz S. G., Afanasyev B., Pohlreich D., Hellmann A., Rosler W., Martin S., Apperley J., Finnegan D., Renaud M., Nemet D., Culligan D., Castagna L., Cascavilla N., Koh M., Chacon M. J., Ozdogu H., Spencer A., Llamas C. V., Grasso M., Lopez S. G., Benedetti F., Deeren D., De Revel T., Musso M., Halaburda K., Sureda A., Angelucci E., Diez-Martin J. L., Hunter H., Koc Y., Bordessoule D., Fouillard L., Di Bartolomeo P., Mazza P., Novitzky N., Peschel C., Lopez J. L. B., Cascon M. J. P., Romeril K. R., Schots R., Brussel H., Koistinen P., Arcese W., Aktan M., Rodeghiero F., Butler A., Pizzuti M., Melpignano A., Carella A. M., Valcarcel D., De Toledo Codina J. S., Galieni P., Bader P., Cavanna L., Sucak G., Broom A. J. M., Garcia P. G., Nicolas-Virelizier E., Rizzoli V., Witz F., Collin M., Ringhoffer M., Kansu E., Martin H., Moraleda J., Pranger D., Greil R., Bazarbachi A., Ozturk M., Fagioli F., Jantunen E., Yeshurun M., Altuntas F., Bassan R., Rohrlich P. -S., Jimenez S., Glaisner S., Vinante O., Clausen J., Lopez-Jimenez J., Theunissen K., Specchia G., Pavone V., Krauter J., Edwards D., Rifon J., Everaus H., Da Prada G. A., Wattad M., Milone G., Walewski J., Thieblemont C., Nasa G. L., Duchosal M., Ferrara F., Devidas A., Delmer A., and Degos L.
- Abstract
Even with the availability of targeted drugs, allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (allo-HCT) is the only therapy with curative potential for patients with CLL. Cure can be assessed by comparing long-term survival of patients to the matched general population. Using data from 2589 patients who received allo-HCT between 2000 and 2010, we used landmark analyses and methods from relative survival analysis to calculate excess mortality compared with an age-, sex- and calendar year-matched general population. Estimated event-free survival, overall survival and non-relapse mortality (NRM) 10 years after allo-HCT were 28% (95% confidence interval (CI), 25-31), 35% (95% CI, 32-38) and 40% (95% CI, 37-42), respectively. Patients who passed the 5-year landmark event-free survival (N=394) had a 79% probability (95% CI, 73-85) of surviving the subsequent 5 years without an event. Relapse and NRM contributed equally to treatment failure. Five-year mortality for 45- and 65-year-old reference patients who were event-free at the 5-year landmark was 8% and 47% compared with 3% and 14% in the matched general population, respectively. The prospect of long-term disease-free survival remains an argument to consider allo-HCT for young patients with high-risk CLL, and programs to understand and prevent late causes of failure for long-term survivors are warranted, especially for older patients.
- Published
- 2017