1. Writing in Creole contexts : a study of Jamaican primary school students and teachers
- Author
-
Tucker, Shawna-kaye, Murphy, Victoria, and Chalmers, Hamish
- Subjects
Second language acquisition ,Language acquisition ,Creole ,Education ,English literacy - Abstract
The poor writing outcomes of Jamaican students across all levels of education have been a subject of lament for educators and policymakers for several years. Despite such concerns, very little research has explored the challenges experienced by learners with Jamaican Creole as a home language when writing in English. While Jamaican Creole is the first language of most speakers, only Standard Jamaican English (English) is afforded official status and therefore is the language of instruction. Within this context, many children are educated through the medium of English while their first language is often disregarded and denigrated in the classroom. Given the differences between the languages, particularly in the areas of morphosyntax and phonology, as well as the importance of these skills in writing - it is worth exploring the nature of writing among learners in the Jamaican context. The present study therefore explores the characteristics of writing among learners with Jamaican Creole as their home language relative to their English dominant peers and investigates whether there are specific writing challenges experienced by these learners. The wider ecology of the writing classroom (instruction, curriculum, and language education policy) is also taken into consideration to gain a fuller understanding of student writing outcomes. A sequential mixed methods design consisting of three phases of gradually increasing focus was employed. In the first phase, a systematic review of the research on writing development among learners more typically identified as EAL was conducted to provide some insight on the nature of writing among learners whose home language differs from English -- the language of schooling. This was followed by the content analyses of the Jamaican curriculum and policy documents guiding writing instruction. In the final stages, semi-structured interviews were carried out with classroom teachers and language and literacy measures were administered to 90 Jamaican primary school students in Grade Six. Statistically significant differences were found in the overall writing outcomes of learners with Jamaican Creole as a home language and their peers with English as a home language (p < .001), with the former group performing more poorly on all writing subskills. In terms of the ecology of the writing classroom -- instructional approaches more in line with English immersion were dominant in both the classroom and the policy and curriculum documents, with teachers reporting feeling ill-equipped to teach writing in the Jamaican creole context. Findings from each phase of the study are integrated and discussed with reference to the simple view of writing and wider research to create a fuller account of the writing outcomes of learners with Jamaican Creole as a home language. Implications for second language writing theory as well as for writing pedagogy and policy in creole-speaking contexts are also discussed.
- Published
- 2023