1. Alcohol use and adverse childhood experiences : does self-compassion play a mediating role?
- Author
-
Downing, Amy
- Abstract
This doctoral thesis was designed to determine more about the impact of childhood maltreatment and specifically to discover if a positive psychological construct such as self-compassion can help to protect people against negative outcomes like hazardous drinking in adulthood. Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) are shown to be highly prevalent even within community samples (Bellis, Hughes, Leckenby, Perkins & Lowey, 2014; Office for National Statistics, 2020). A focal point in psychological research due to their prevalence and gravity, ACEs are associated with a multitude of serious negative consequences in adulthood (Nelson et al, 2002), one of the most common of which is hazardous drinking (Dube, Anda, Felitti, Chapman, Williamson & Giles, 2001). Although there is a lot of research connecting ACEs and hazardous drinking in adulthood, much of this focuses on physical and sexual abuse and does not address other forms of abuse and neglect (e.g. emotional abuse) or focuses on adolescent and clinical populations. Subsequently, there is a gap in the research literature investigating a potential association between all ACEs in a community sample. In addition to this, traditional models of addiction treatment and relapse prevention often neglect the role of unresolved trauma in recovery from heavy alcohol use and other substance difficulties (Najavits, Weiss, Shaw & Muenz, 1998; Miller & Guidry, 2001). Overlooking causal factors for hazarded drinking arguably leaves the root of the problem unresolved and leaves the individual more vulnerable to relapse. Treatments often take a problem saturated approach and do not consider positive personality traits which may help to facilitate meaningful change. Self-compassion has been shown to protect against some adverse outcomes following ACEs and therefore may mediate the relationship between ACEs and hazardous drinking. Chapter 1 presents a critical review and meta-analysis of a prospective association between childhood maltreatment and self-compassion. The term childhood maltreatment was employed in the literature review after scoping searches established that this is the most commonly used definition of childhood trauma in the literature base. The meta-analysis showed childhood maltreatment to be significantly negatively correlated with selfcompassion (z = 11.744, r = -0.312 (CI: -.0364 to -.0260), p < .001). Furthermore, emotional forms of maltreatment (e.g., neglect and abuse) were found to be associated with low selfcompassion, with men reporting higher levels of self-compassion overall than women. In conclusion, childhood maltreatment was associated with decreased levels of self-compassion in adulthood, but the rationale for this requires further exploration. Chapter 2 presents a cross-sectional empirical study entitled "From Adverse Childhood Experiences to hazardous drinking in adulthood: Does self-compassion mediate this relationship?". The study utilises retrospective self-report measures of ACEs and prospective measures of alcohol consumption and self-compassion to explore any associations between ACEs and hazardous drinking and to determine if self-compassion could mediate any association found. The data did not support an association between ACEs and alcohol use but did evidence a negative link between ACEs and self-compassion. Selfcompassion also partially mediated the relationship between ACEs and hazardous alcohol use. Correlational and mediation analysis showed that self-compassion partially mediated the relationship between ACEs and hazardous drinking, however that this effect is small.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF