1. Social Emotional Learning Curriculums to Support Inclusive Education and Low-Income Students: A Meta-Analysis of The Incredible Years Program
- Author
-
Lee, Kayla Brooke
- Subjects
- Behavioral Psychology, Behavioral Sciences, Education, Psychology, Social Psychology, Incredible Years, Social emotional learning, Social emotional skills, Externalizing behavior, Low-income children, Low-income students
- Abstract
The purpose of this study was to examine the outcomes and internal validity of the literature regarding the Incredible Years program’s impacts on externalizing behaviors and social-emotional learning for students from low SES backgrounds. A meta-analysis of behavioral and social-emotional outcomes from the child, parent, and teacher trainings for students from low SES backgrounds was conducted. Nine studies were eligible for inclusion using the defined eligibility criteria.Across the nine studies, data was collected for a total of 3,360 children, with all studies reporting greater than 50% of participants having an income in the low-socioeconomic range. The type of Incredible Years intervention program reported for each included study was the parent training program (four), teacher classroom management training (two), the combined parent training and teacher classroom management program (two), and one study which compared the child intervention program with the combined child intervention and parent training program. Teacher training and parent intervention sessions were largely led by certified trainers and sessions varied in number and length. Overall social validity was strong across all studies, suggesting high parent and teacher satisfaction with the program.The overall effect size reported for Incredible Years programming on social emotional learning and externalizing behavior outcomes was in the small to moderate range. Moderator analysis for externalizing behavior outcomes suggested variable effect sizes based on targeted training, with parent training resulting in a stronger effect size than teacher training. Combined parent and teacher training reported the smallest effect size for externalizing behavior outcomes. When outcomes were further analyzed based on externalizing behavior outcomes, number of hours/days of parent/teacher training, and training type, results indicated stronger correlation between amount of training for parents and effect size for externalizing behavior outcomes compared to outcomes related to amount of training for teachers.Assessment of internal validity found eight of nine studies to fall in the methodologically sound range. A limitation across studies was the use of parent and teacher report as an outcome measure for child behaviors. Although there are limitations to this analysis, the results expand upon the literature for students by providing a synthesis of behavioral and social-emotional outcomes from the child, parent, and teacher trainings for students from low SES backgrounds.The findings of this review have implications for practitioners and how they address externalizing behaviors and SEL outcomes for students from low-income backgrounds. Future research related to the impact of the Incredible Years on low-income students is needed, including longitudinal outcomes and outcomes related to the dinosaur school classroom intervention specifically. Future studies should examine the impact of length of training and attendance at sessions for parent training on outcomes for students and the use of blinded observation data as an outcome measure rather than parent and teacher rating scales.
- Published
- 2022