Search

Yang et al., Acta Geologica Sinica‐English Edition, 91(2), pp. 749–750 claim that they discovered supercritical hyperpycnal flow deposits in the Early Cretaceous strata on Lingshan Island, East China. We would like to discuss this paper under the following topics: (a) the terminology of "supercritical hyperpycnal flow," (b) hyperpycnal flow deposition, and (c) supercritical flow deposition. Our aim is twofold in that the following debate will help unravel the complexities associated with the controversy around the paleosedimentary environment and sediment dynamic processes of the early Cretaceous deposits on Lingshan Island, in addition to providing an understanding of hyperpycnal flow and supercritical flow deposits. The Beilaishi section deposits on Lingshan Island are more likely storm‐induced tempestites within the lacustrine basin delta front and associated deep lacustrine turbidites. Frequent earthquakes due to tectonic‐magmatic activity are the most likely triggers for lacustrine storms. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

Highlights • Supplies from rivers cannot explain the supper high sedimentation rate of the RDSD. • Due to Dongsha Uplift since 3 Ma, roughly 1/2 formations since Miocene were denudated. • Annual denudation rate from Dongsha Uplift sine 3 Ma had been about 60 Mt/y. • Sediment denudated from the Dongsha Uplift can be the main source for the RDSD. Abstract The slope of the northern South China Sea (SCS) is one of the world's most active areas of modern marine sedimentary processes. A rapidly deposited sediment drift (RDSD) was identified on the slope near Dongsha Island. The sources of this body have been studied and discussed by several authors, but no consensus has been achieved. Based on multi-channel seismic profiles interpretation and data analysis of long-term observation of bottom currents, we identified that although the amounts of sediments input from the Pearl and Hanjing Rivers, and from Kao-ping and Tseng-Wen Rivers are large, considering the current situation of northern SCS, none of the Pearl River, the Hanjiang River, the Kao-ping River and the Tseng-Wen River can maintain the deposition pattern of the northern SCS margin as the single source, especially to maintain the supper high sedimentation rate at the RDSD area. The Miocene drape formation (MDF) calmly draped over an unconformity after rifting stage resulting in a relatively constant thickness of about 2000 m throughout the overall northern SCS continental margin, and followed by a standard configuration of a clinoform, the Pliocene formation and another clinoform of about another 700 m in total thickness. Due to Dongsha uplift since 3 Ma, roughly 1/2 of MDF and the N 2 formation in the Dongsha area measures 150 km by 200 km were denudated resulting in an average annual denudation rate of 60 × 106 t/y. If these sediments were deposited on a slope region within an area measuring 100 km by 100 km, the sedimentation rate could reach 250 cm/ky. This is clearly an impressive new sediment source that has never been discussed before. Moreover, the RDSD is near the Dongsha Uplift and on the adjacent slope. We believe that this new sediment source should be the main contributor for the RDSD development. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]

• Extensive Middle Miocene fining in southward clastic sequences were deposited in the north of East Java. • Two newly identified turbidite fans exhibit opposite source directions based on 3D seismic data. • The formation of the turbidites fans were predominantly controlled by the paleotopography of the Early Miocene and intense regional tectonic events. • East Java was in a laterally neritic to bathyal environments with occasionally exposed volcanoes during the Middle Miocene. East Java, on the southeastern margin of the Sundaland Shelf, is an ideal and pilot location to study paleogeographic changes due to the interactions of the Eurasian and the Indian-Australia plates. Many studies have been conducted; however, some issues remain poorly understood, such as the initial compression stage and associated paleogeography of East Java. Here, we report newly acquired high-resolution seismic data and drilling wells in the area of the Madura Strait. We systematically reconstruct a three-dimensional model on the paleogeography of East Java in the Middle Miocene in combination with others' results. Different depositional environments and characteristics of the related lithofacies observed on both sides of the Middle Miocene volcanic arc imply that weak subaerial and subaqueous volcanism existed in East Java. The extensive Ngrayong fining in the southward clastic sequences, located north of the mentioned volcanic arc, were deposited in a bathyal marine environment, which showed an oversteepening slope and basinal characteristics with outer neritic to bathyal facies within the present-day Kendeng Zone and Madura Strait area. This differs from the northern region of the present-day Rembang-Madura Inversion Zone and the northern offshore region of East Java, which were deposited in a transitional and neritic marine environment. We identified two new turbidite fans showing opposite source directions based on 3D seismic data within the Madura Strait area. Four controlling factors contributed to the formation of the Ngrayong turbidite fans, including the paleotopography of the underlying Kujung Formation, short-term intense regional tectonic events, high rates of sediment supply and occasional volcanic activity. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]