1. Including diverse knowledges and worldviews in environmental assessment and planning: the Brazilian Amazon Kaxinawá Nova Olinda Indigenous Land case
- Author
-
Eufran Ferreira do Amaral, Jelle Hendrik Behagel, Fernanda Ayaviri Matuk, Moacir Haverroth, Felipe Nogueira Bello Simas, Esther Turnhout, Fernanda Ayaviri Matuk, Wageningen University / Federal Institute of Minas Gerais, Jelle Hendrik Behagel, Wageningen University, Felipe Nogueira Bello Simas, Federal University of Viçosa, EUFRAN FERREIRA DO AMARAL, CPAF-AC, MOACIR HAVERROTH, CPAF-AC, and Esther Turnhout, Wageningen University.
- Subjects
assessment ,Servicios ecosistémicos ,WASS ,Management, Monitoring, Policy and Law ,Forest and Nature Conservation Policy ,Indigenous ,Acre ,Ecosystem services ,Knowledge-based systems ,Indigenous knowledge ,Conocimiento tradicional ,Bos- en Natuurbeleid ,resource management ,Resource management ,Environmental impact assessment ,lcsh:Human ecology. Anthropogeography ,Indigenous and local knowledge ,Environmental planning ,lcsh:Environmental sciences ,Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics ,Nature and Landscape Conservation ,lcsh:GE1-350 ,Abordagem participativa ,Land rights ,Amazon rainforest ,Amazonia Occidental ,Povos indígenas ,Participatory management ,Pueblos indígenas ,Contribuições das pessoas para a natureza ,Terra Indígena Kaxinawá de Nova Olinda (TIKNO) ,Nova (rocket) ,Geography ,Serviços ecossistêmicos ,Conhecimento tradicional ,participatory approaches ,Automotive Engineering ,Gestión participativa ,Indigenous peoples ,lcsh:GF1-900 ,People's contributions to nature (PCN) ,ecosystem services ,Western Amazon ,Amazônia Ocidental ,nature’s contributions to people - Abstract
The concepts of 'ecosystem services' (ES) and 'nature's contributions to people' (NCP) inform environmental frameworks that set out to include Indigenous and Local Knowledge systems (ILK) and worldviews in policy and planning processes. These frameworks aim to enhance biodiversity conservation and human well-being in a legitimate and effective way. In this article, we explore how the concept of People's Contributions to Nature (PCN) is complementary to NCP. We use it to investigate challenges that planners and locals face in realizing the legitimate inclusion of diverse knowledges and worldviwes that account for people and ecosystems in a relational way. We introduce a case study where planners drew on ES and NCP and used participatory methods to implement a REDD+ policy in the Kaxinawá Nova Olinda Indigenous Land (Acre-Brazil). We find that both Kaxinawás and planners emphasize both NCP and PCN in their discourses. Nevertheless, differences between knowledge systems and disciplines, uneven power relations between Kaxinawás and planners, and an underconsideration of PCN by global frameworks challenge the legitimate inclusion of the Kaxinawá knowlege and worldviews to craft assessment and planning. We conclude that by explicitly addressing these challenges, science-policy interfaces can further advance knowledge legitimacy and policy effectiveness. Made available in DSpace on 2020-02-17T18:13:56Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 26972.pdf: 2786770 bytes, checksum: 2e2d7e7360a6dcb6d3c5dc10c9ca9fb8 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2020
- Published
- 2020